McCartney to release silent song against AI law

Published
0
In this file photo, Paul McCartney arrives at Haneda airport in Tokyo on May 15, 2014. – Photo by AFP
In this file photo, Paul McCartney arrives at Haneda airport in Tokyo on May 15, 2014. – Photo by AFP

LONDON: Pop legend Paul McCartney will release a silent music track next month as part of a silent album to protest Britain’s copyright law changes that would give exemptions to tech firms.

Other artists such as Hans Zimmer and singer Kate Bush have joined the project, highlighting what they say are the dangers artificial intelligence (AI) poses to creativity.

McCartney’s contribution to the album, Is This What We Want, will draw “attention to the damning impact on artists’ livelihoods controversial government proposals could cause”.

It is a two minute 45 seconds recording of an empty studio featuring a series of clicks.

More than 1,000 artists, including Annie Lennox, Damon Albarn and Jamiroquai, have collaborated on the silent album, which was released in February.

They maintain that the government’s law changes “would make it easier to train AI models on copyrighted work without a licence”.

“Under the heavily criticised proposals, UK copyright law would be upended to benefit global tech giants. AI companies would be free to use an artist’s work to train their AI models without permission or remuneration,” they added.

The changes “would require artists to proactively opt-out from the theft of their work, reversing the very principle of copyright law”, they added.

Only 1,000 copies of the vinyl album have been pressed.

In May, some 400 writers and musicians, including Elton John, condemned the proposals as a “wholesale giveaway” to Silicon Valley in a letter to The Times newspaper.

Other signatories included the 83-year-old McCartney, singer-songwriters Ed Sheeran, Dua Lipa and Sting, and writers Kazuo Ishiguro, Michael Morpurgo and Helen Fielding.

Prime Minister Keir Starmer has previously said the government needs to “get the balance right” with copyright and AI while noting that the technology represented “a huge opportunity”.

“They have no right to sell us down the river,” Elton John told the BBC in May, urging Starmer to “wise up” and “see sense”.

According to a study by UK Music last week two out of three artists and producers fear that AI poses a threat to their careers.

More than nine out of 10 surveyed demanded that their image and voice to be protected and called for AI firms to pay for the use of their creations.

Published in Dawn, November 18th, 2025

Opinion

Editorial

Narrative confusion
Updated 14 Oct, 2026

Narrative confusion

The centre must say clearly how long it intends it to last, what it hopes to achieve in that time, and how the province’s elected mandate will be restored.
El Niño’s long reach
14 Oct, 2026

El Niño’s long reach

THE extraordinary El Niño gathering strength in the Pacific could make 2026 the hottest year on record, with 2027...
Deeper poverty
Updated 14 Oct, 2026

Deeper poverty

PAKISTAN’S poverty crisis is far deeper than official indicators suggest. While the government celebrates economic...
Yemen escalation
Updated 13 Oct, 2026

Yemen escalation

Such an agreement can also help bring peace to Saudi Arabia, while ending Yemen’s humanitarian nightmare.
Inequitable taxation
13 Oct, 2026

Inequitable taxation

FINANCE Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb has once more reviewed the latest incentive scheme to bring retailers into the...
Taxila’s hidden past
13 Oct, 2026

Taxila’s hidden past

A HILL dismissed more than a century ago as an unremarkable heap of ruins has yielded one of Taxila’s most...