CB alone can hear Article 184 matters: Justice Mazhar

Published
0

ISLAMABAD: Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar, a member of the Sup­r­eme Court’s constitutio­nal bench (CB), ruled on Saturday that only the CB has the authority to exercise the Supreme Court’s original jurisdiction under Article 184, the appellate jurisdiction under Article 185(3), or the advisory jurisdiction under Article 186.

“I wish to state unequivocally, without contradiction in words or deeds, that in the current scenario, no bench of this court, except the Constitutional Bench, may exercise: (i) the Supreme Court’s original jurisdiction under Article 184; (ii) its appellate jurisdiction under clause (3) of Article 185, where a High Court judgement or order issued under Article 199 involves the constitutionality of a law or a substantial question of constitutional interpretation; and (iii) its advisory jurisdiction under Article 186,” he observed.

The 20-page concurring note came in support of the CB’s Jan 28 order in which the Jan 13 and 16 orders by a sma­ller regular bench were recalled by declaring the same as non-est. The Jan 28 order also set­t­led the thorny issue raised by Justice Man­soor-led sm­a­ller bench whether the constitutio­nal comm­ittee set up under Article 191A can undo the effect of a judicial order by withdrawing a jurisdictional case already taken cognisa­nce of by a regular bench.

“In all fairness, in my view, there is no room for difference of opinion: any exercise of this jurisdiction outside CB at present would be coram non judice,” Justice Mazhar explained.

In 20-page note, the judge backs constitutional bench’s order issued on Jan 28

He mentioned Article 191A (5) dictates that all petitions, appeals, or re­v­iew applications aga­inst judgements rende­red or orders passed, pen­ding or filed in the SC prior to the commencement of 26th Ame­ndment stand transferred and will only be heard and decided by the CB.

“With all humility at my command and with due reverence, if any regular bench, despite the clear and unambiguous constitutional provisions, over-ambitiously assumes jurisdiction or undertakes to decide the alleged controversy based solely on respondent’s counsel’s argument in a tax matter without self-realisation, it would not only constitute a wrongful exercise of jurisdiction but also amount to a violation of Article 191A of the Constitution,” Justice Mazhar elaborated.

According to the note, judges have taken an oath to preserve, protect and defend the Consti­tu­tion. Moreover, the Code of Conduct for Judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts, framed by the Supreme Judicial Co­u­ncil under Article 128 (4) of the Constitu­t­ion of 1962 and subsequ­ently amended under Article 209 (8) of the Constitution 1973, imp­lies complete submission to the Constitution and, under it, to the law, it added.

Until the final adjudication of the pending petitions, we cannot shut our eyes to and ignore a ground reality that not only is the CB being assembled regularly under the current framework of the Constitution, but cases are also being fixed and heard regularly, the judge asserted.

The present proceedings are confined solely to the question of the all­e­ged vires of Subsection 2 of Section 221-A of the Customs Act, 1969, inserted through the Finance Act, 2018.

Justice Mazhar said he was a staunch beli­ever of the concept that the role of a constitutio­nal judge was different from that of a monarch who was free to exert power and pass orders of his choice over his subjects. On the other hand, he said, a constitutional judge must always remain mindful that they, too, were bound by the very constitution they were entrusted to interpret and enforce and therefore were the first and foremost subject to the constitution and the law.

Published in Dawn, February 9th, 2025

Opinion

Editorial

Muddled hierarchy
Updated 15 Nov, 2026

Muddled hierarchy

The jurisdiction of the two courts and a mechanism for settling disputes between them should be spelt out in law, not left to judges to fight over.
Growing crisis
Updated 15 Nov, 2026

Growing crisis

Calling population growth a national emergency is easy. Ensuring that the response reaches the people who need it is the real challenge.
Organised rackets
15 Nov, 2026

Organised rackets

ON the International Day against Transnational Organised Crime, observed today, Pakistan finds itself in a tight...
Referendum talk
Updated 14 Nov, 2026

Referendum talk

Unless the PPP is deliberately using Sindh as a bargaining chip, it should issue a clarification with a clear, consistent position on new administrative units, not one tailored to protect its home turf.
Mineral wealth
Updated 14 Nov, 2026

Mineral wealth

Minerals should not be presented as a solution to Pakistan’s long-term economic difficulties. The aim should be to build an industrial base rather than export raw materials.
Late diagnosis
14 Nov, 2026

Late diagnosis

AS we mark World Diabetes Day today, Pakistan faces a troubling question: how many people are living with diabetes...