White House win gives Trump a legal reprieve

Published November 7, 2024
Partial results by US media on Nov 6, 2024. — AFP
Partial results by US media on Nov 6, 2024. — AFP

WASHINGTON: Donald Trump’s election victory not only catapults him back to the White House but grants him a reprieve from looming court battles and soaring legal bills.

As president, the 78-year-old Trump can make the federal criminal cases facing him vanish and see the state cases put on hold until he leaves the Oval Office four years from now.

Trump pledged during the election campaign against Vice President Kamala Harris to fire Jack Smith, the special counsel who filed federal charges against him, “within two seconds” of taking office.

A US president does not have the authority to dismiss a special counsel, but Trump could — and almost certainly would — name a new attorney general who could do so. He could also simply order the Justice Department to drop the charges.

Smith, who was appointed by Merrick Garland, President Joe Biden’s attorney general, brought two cases against Trump — for conspiring to overturn the results of the 2020 election and for mishandling top secret documents after leaving the White House.

The election interference case is ongoing in Washington but no trial date has been set and it has been complicated by the US Supreme Court ruling in July that a former president has broad immunity from criminal prosecution.

Trump is accused of conspiracy to defraud the United States and conspiracy to obstruct an official proceeding — the session of Congress called to certify the Biden win which was violently attacked on January 6, 2021, by a mob of his supporters.

The Republican is also accused of seeking to disenfranchise US voters with his false claims that he won the 2020 election.

His documents case was tossed out by a federal judge in Florida, a Trump appointee, on the grounds that Smith was unlawfully appointed. The special counsel has appealed the dismissal, but both federal cases appear doomed now that Trump has won the presidency.

State cases

Trump also faces two state cases — in New York and Georgia. He was convicted in New York in May of 34 counts of falsifying business records to cover up a hush money payment to porn star Stormy Daniels on the eve of the 2016 election to stop her from revealing an alleged 2006 sexual encounter.

Trump was scheduled to be sentenced in July but his lawyers asked that his conviction be tossed in light of the Supreme Court immunity ruling. Judge Juan Merchan is to rule on the dismissal motion on November 12 and has set sentencing — should it still be necessary — for November 26.

Trump, the first former president convicted of a crime, faces up to four years in prison on each count. As a first-time offender, however, he was considered far more likely to receive a fine and probation — and that was before his White House win.

“It would also be possible to have a deferred sentence if it involved any jail term,” said Claire Finkelstein, a law professor at the University of Pennsylvania.

In Georgia, Trump faces racketeering charges over his efforts to subvert the 2020 results in the southern state, but that case will likely be frozen while he is in office under a federal policy of not prosecuting a sitting president.

Published in Dawn, November 7th, 2024

Opinion

Editorial

Momentary relief
Updated 10 May, 2026

Momentary relief

THE IMF’s approval of the latest review of Pakistan’s ongoing Fund programme comes at a moment of growing global...
India’s global shame
10 May, 2026

India’s global shame

INDIA’s rabid streak is at an all-time high. Prejudice is now an organised movement to erase religious freedoms ...
Aurat March restrictions
Updated 10 May, 2026

Aurat March restrictions

The message could not have been clearer: women may gather, but only if they remain politically harmless.
Removing subsidies
Updated 09 May, 2026

Removing subsidies

The government no longer has the budgetary space to continue carrying hundreds of billions of rupees in untargeted subsidies while the power sector itself remains trapped in circular debt, inefficiencies, theft and under-recovery.
Scarred at home
09 May, 2026

Scarred at home

WHEN homes turn violent towards children, the psychosocial damage is lifelong. In Pakistan, parental violence is...
Zionist zealotry
09 May, 2026

Zionist zealotry

BOTH the Israeli military and far-right citizens of the Zionist state have been involved in appalling hate crimes...