Indonesian court finds president negligent in air pollution lawsuit

Published September 17, 2021
Indonesia's President Joko Widodo speaks at the Istana in Singapore October 8, 2019. — Reuters/File
Indonesia's President Joko Widodo speaks at the Istana in Singapore October 8, 2019. — Reuters/File

JAKARTA: An Indonesian court ordered on Thursday President Joko Widodo and other senior government officials to improve the hazardous air quality of the capital Jakarta after finding them guilty of environmental negligence in a civil lawsuit.

The citizen lawsuit was filed in 2019 against the president, the ministers of health, environment and home affairs, as well as other prominent local leaders.

The 32 plaintiffs said the lawsuit was a last-ditch attempt to compel authorities to take action against severe air pollution in the bustling metropolis of Jakarta and its surrounds, an area home to more than 30 million people.

In its verdict, judges at the Central Jakarta District Court said the actions of the defendants had contravened the law.

The ruling obliges the president to establish national air quality standards to protect human health, and the health minister and Jakarta governor to devise strategies to control air pollution.

“The defendants were found to be negligent at controlling air pollution. We appreciate the verdict, and we are satisfied,” Ayu Eza Tiara, a lawyer representing the plaintiffs said.

The court also ordered the defendants to take other measures, including an analysis of cross-border emissions, and for older vehicles to be periodically tested for emissions.

Presidential spokesman Fadjroel Rahman said decisions regarding any further action would fall on the environment minister.

In a message on Twitter, Jakarta Governor Anies Baswedan said his administration would not appeal and was ready to implement the ruling to achieve cleaner air in the capital.

The environment ministry, the home affairs ministry, and the health ministry did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Rapid urbanisation and chronic traffic in Jakarta, along with nearby coal-fired power plants, have contributed to the poor air quality, according to the Centre on Energy and Clean Air (CREA).

Published in Dawn, September 17th, 2021

Opinion

Editorial

Digital deal
19 Jun, 2026

Digital deal

THINGS have moved rapidly where the Iran-US memorandum of understanding is concerned. While the physical document ...
Failing the public
19 Jun, 2026

Failing the public

WHETHER it is Sindh’s struggle to secure clean drinking water or Balochistan’s difficulty in improving the...
Crushed lives
19 Jun, 2026

Crushed lives

COURTS and commissions have often been up in arms over the health and ecological hazards associated with...
Words that wound
Updated 18 Jun, 2026

Words that wound

Hate speech rarely begins with physical attacks.
‘New urban province’
18 Jun, 2026

‘New urban province’

CONSIDERING the advance state of urban decay that affects Karachi, voices are often raised calling for the megacity,...
Punjab budget: mixed bag
18 Jun, 2026

Punjab budget: mixed bag

PUNJAB’S budget for FY27 is a mix of good and bad political choices, with a cash-strapped centre tightening the...