Apex court suspends BHC ruling on Quetta DHA

Published March 17, 2021
A three-judge Supreme Court bench comprising Justice Umar Ata Bandial, Justice Qazi Amin Ahmed and Justice Mazzahar Hussain Naqvi also granted leave to appeal to the Quetta DHA.
— Photo courtesy SC website/File
A three-judge Supreme Court bench comprising Justice Umar Ata Bandial, Justice Qazi Amin Ahmed and Justice Mazzahar Hussain Naqvi also granted leave to appeal to the Quetta DHA. — Photo courtesy SC website/File

ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court on Tuesday suspended the Dec 2020 order of the Balochistan High Court (BHC) in which several provisions of the Defence Housing Authority (DHA) Quetta Act 2015 were held unconstitutional.

A three-judge Supreme Court bench comprising Justice Umar Ata Bandial, Justice Qazi Amin Ahmed and Justice Mazzahar Hussain Naqvi also granted leave to appeal to the Quetta DHA.

A five-judge full-court of the BHC had held that since the DHA was like a non-government agency therefore acquisition of property by it would violate the constitutional right to property.

The high court had also declared that the DHA could not be allowed to develop its own master plan or perform other municipal functions. Besides, the power of the authority to declare a specified area in which development could be carried out was also held to be unconstitutional.

High court declared DHA’s acts of property acquisition, developing its own master plan unconstitutional

As a result of the high court judgement, all development work in Quetta DHA had been paralysed.

Senior lawyer Makhdoom Ali Khan, representing the petitioner Quetta DHA, argued before the Supreme Court that Article 24 of the Constitution permitted acquisition of property for a public purpose. The DHA was acting in public interest and all allotments were made to members of the public by ballot, he said.

The counsel argued that the high court had itself acknowledged that the DHA was working in the interest of the people while many other residential societies were doing poor quality work.

Mr Khan said that the statute authorised the DHA to exercise municipal functions and develop master plans for the areas it had purchased or leased but the high court had not appreciated this aspect of the case. The developing of master plans for or performing municipal functions in lands owned by the DHA was only proper and there was nothing unconstitutional about it, the counsel argued.

He said that the major premise of the BHC judgement was that the DHA Quetta Act 2015 was in conflict with the Land Acquisition Act 1894. He contended that the high court had incorrectly concluded that the Land Acquisition Act was a federal law and it was in conflict with the DHA Quetta Act and therefore the latter was unconstitutional as per Articles 141 to 143 of the Constitution.

The counsel submitted that since the Government of India Act, 1935, the Land Acquisition Act had been a provincial not a federal statute. There was, therefore, no conflict between a federal and a provincial statute and no article of the Constitution was, thus, violated.

He further said that the DHA Quetta Act provided that the authority would act in accordance with the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act so the question of any conflict did not arise.

The Supreme Court noted these submissions and observed that a case for grant of leave had been made out as these were important questions of law which required consideration.

As the counsel said that the entire operation of the DHA has been paralysed and its work stopped, causing it and its allottees tremendous hardship, the court suspended the judgement of the BHC.

Published in Dawn, March 17th, 2021

Opinion

Editorial

Warming ties
05 Jul, 2022

Warming ties

BILATERAL ties with the US are clearly on the mend after an extensive rough patch under the PTI government. While ...
LNG emergency
Updated 05 Jul, 2022

LNG emergency

The problem is that Pakistan does not have sufficient cash at the moment to buy even a single LNG cargo at present prices.
The invisible half
05 Jul, 2022

The invisible half

WHAT better illustrates the Afghan Taliban’s misogynistic and mediaeval worldview than the fact that not a single...
Wise counsel
Updated 04 Jul, 2022

Wise counsel

Fuelling the fires of communalism for petty political gains is dangerous and can have a long-lasting impact on India’s stability.
Hazardous waste
04 Jul, 2022

Hazardous waste

GIVEN we have not yet developed streamlined systems for managing locally produced hazardous waste, we are inviting...
Mob ‘justice’
04 Jul, 2022

Mob ‘justice’

OVER the past few days, a string of deadly incidents has been reported from Karachi in which enraged mobs have...