5 controversies which highlighted the India-Australia test series

Published March 29, 2017
India's Virat Kohli shakes hands with Australia's captain Steven Smith after India won the series. ─Reuters
India's Virat Kohli shakes hands with Australia's captain Steven Smith after India won the series. ─Reuters
India's Lokesh Rahul celebrates after his team's victory in the fourth test cricket match against Australia in Dharmsala, India. ─AP
India's Lokesh Rahul celebrates after his team's victory in the fourth test cricket match against Australia in Dharmsala, India. ─AP

India clinched a hard-fought series against Australia 2-1 after winning the fourth and final Test in Dharamsala.

Here are the main flash-points of a tour which will be remembered as much for its controversies as its cricket:

Reviewgate

Emotions were running high after Australia won the opening Test in Pune, but visiting skipper Steve Smith set off a storm of controversy in the second game.

Smith looked to his dressing room while deciding whether to review his lbw dismissal in Bangalore, in a moment he described as a “brain fade”.

But Indian captain Virat Kohli accused the visitors of routinely abusing the decision review system, stopping just short of calling Smith a cheat.

An ensuing war of words, as both captains stood their ground, required the cricket boards of India and Australia to intervene but even a clear-the-air meeting between the skippers failed to smooth things over.

Shouldergate

The rancour worsened in the third Test when Australia's Glenn Maxwell was caught mocking a shoulder injury sustained by Kohli while diving to save a boundary.

Maxwell, after making a similar plunge in the outfield, was seen clutching his shoulder and grinning to his team-mates in a parody that infuriated Indian fans and commentators.

Kohli had the last laugh, grabbing his shoulder in a theatrical fashion after Australian opener David Warner was dismissed for 14 the next day.

Stumpgate

The fourth and final Test in Dharamsala saw a fresh controversy as Ravindra Jadeja and Matthew Wade engaged in a slanging match that could have been left on the field ─ had India's cricket board not intervened.

The verbal clash was picked up by stump microphones and the board posted the complete exchange on its website and social media channels for all to hear.

Smith later expressed disappointment that the board had “sieved through the archive to find a conversation out on the field” between the two opponents.

Cheatgate

Also in the final Test, Smith was caught out by an eagle-eyed cameraman as he called Murali Vijay a cheat for claiming a catch that had clearly hit the grass.

Smith, watching the incident from the dressing room, was seen saying “F****** cheat!”, but he later apologised for letting his emotions get the better of him.

Friendgate

All could have been forgiven and forgotten on the final day, but Kohli remained unhappy despite India's series win. The home captain said he wouldn't think of the Australian players as friends “ever again”, a comment which drew a strong reaction from Aussie media. Smith also revealed that he invited the Indian players to share a beer with his team, but was rebuffed as the series ended in acrimony.

Opinion

Editorial

Words that wound
18 Jun, 2026

Words that wound

LONG before a church is burned, a mosque vandalised or a mob assembled, the poison that enables such violence has...
‘New urban province’
18 Jun, 2026

‘New urban province’

CONSIDERING the advance state of urban decay that affects Karachi, voices are often raised calling for the megacity,...
Punjab budget: mixed bag
18 Jun, 2026

Punjab budget: mixed bag

PUNJAB’S budget for FY27 is a mix of good and bad political choices, with a cash-strapped centre tightening the...
Spoiler alert
17 Jun, 2026

Spoiler alert

AFTER the temporary peace deal between the US and Iran is physically signed in Geneva on Friday, an arduous process...
Storm-tested cities
17 Jun, 2026

Storm-tested cities

THE deaths caused by the latest spell of monsoon rains in KP and Punjab illustrate how quickly severe weather can...
Chakwal tragedy
17 Jun, 2026

Chakwal tragedy

A NINE-year-old girl is dead because a Punjab Crime Control Department gunman mistook her family’s car for a...