Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


China defends CPEC; India claims it passes through its territory

Updated Jan 20, 2017 10:08am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

NEW DELHI: China defended on Wednesday the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) as a project meant for regional peace and development after Indian prime minister hinted that it violated India’s territorial sovereignty, even though he did not name it in his speech.

Speaking at the inaugural session of the Raisina Dialogue on Tuesday, Narendra Modi had said: “Respect for sovereignty is important for regional connectivity to improve.”

He said that it was not unusual for two large neighbouring powers (like India and China) to have some differences. “In the management of our relationship, and for peace and progress in the region, both our countries need to show sensitivity and respect for each other’s core concerns and interests,” he added.

When asked to respond to Mr Modi’s remarks at a media briefing, Hua Chunying, the spokesperson for China’s foreign ministry, said: “Regarding CPEC, this is a project that is devised for long-term development and cooperation in various fields... It is for regional peace and development.”

The India Today quoted her as saying that the project “targets no third country and it will not affect China’s position on Kashmir”.

The unambiguous Chinese foreign ministry statement, however, did not stop Indian Foreign Secretary S. Jaishankar from bringing up the same subject on the second day of the Raisina Dialogue and claiming that CPEC passed through its territory.

“CPEC passes through a territory that we see as our territory. Surely people will understand what Indian reaction is. There needs to be some reflection and I am sorry to say that we have not seen signs of that,” he said.

China and Pakistan have fast-tracked the construction work of the CPEC, a large part of which passes through Azad Kashmir, to which India lays claim in its ongoing dispute with Pakistan. Once completed CPEC will provide all-weather energy route for China from the Gulf. Reports said that India’s concerns had increased in recent weeks with reports of China-Pakistan naval cooperation in Gwadar port of Balochistan, which would serve as the entry point to CPEC.

Mr Jaishankar said that China’s rise as a major “dynamic” factor in the Asian affairs served to remind that differences with China had not gone away. “With China, the overall broadening of ties, especially in business and people-to-people contacts, has been overshadowed by differences on certain political issues,” he said.

“But it is important for the two countries not to lose sight of the strategic nature of their engagement or falter in their conviction that their rise can be mutually supportive.”

Reports said that the foreign secretary’s comments about CPEC and “political issues” were significant as both India and China had dealt with the differences over the last several months. India is unhappy over China’s stance at the Nuclear Suppliers Group where its membership bid was scuttled last year.

China’s territorial assertion over Asia received a jolt in July 2016 when the Permanent Court of Arbitration gave an adverse verdict on the South China Sea issue.

Mr Jaishankar was quoted as saying that India’s position on South China Sea was in sync with the international community’s position.

Published in Dawn, January 19th, 2017


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Comments (252) Closed

ABC Jan 19, 2017 07:39am

Might is not right and China will realize it while others will be watching the tamasha by nature. You can fool people for some time, but not for ever. You suffer for your deed and it never fails!

Nasir Jan 19, 2017 08:21am

If India consider CPEC as usual why are they so much concerned?

Gus Jan 19, 2017 08:19am

Chinese actions on ground is negative

VIJ Jan 19, 2017 08:21am

China has touched the Pandora's box by CPEC , now trump is inviting Taiwan president for his swearing in , India is hosting Tibet meet and started exploring oil in SCS all these things are for regional good and prosperity why Chinese should react bluntly? If Chinese can think they can play the game Americans are masters in it .

Rahul Jan 19, 2017 08:25am

I must appreciate Modi's open speak and courage .. to submit his point of view with full force. We lacked such flair in past 10 years of India's leadership...

Shahid Mahmood Jan 19, 2017 08:26am

O yes India.... the big country with a small heart!!

Ahsan gul Jan 19, 2017 08:25am

We have a government that have hired incompetent foreign relations people. Does PML-N ever do anything right?

Game changer Jan 19, 2017 08:32am

Indian concerns are non-concerns. Pak China must march forward. Long live Pakistan.

Denali Jan 19, 2017 08:43am

@Rahul same story another day

Abdul malik Jan 19, 2017 08:48am

Indian statement highlights the disputed status of Kashmir, so let there be immediate implementation of UN resolutions on Kashmir.

PAKISTANI Jan 19, 2017 08:59am

@Rahul , but he is dump and unaware of ground realities and what people of Kashmir want. Sooner or later Kashmir will no longer be part of India.

somebody panicking Jan 19, 2017 08:56am

@Shahid Mahmood yes that small hearts are repairing thousands of Pakistani hearts in Indian medicals.

D. Rajput Jan 19, 2017 08:56am

Sometimes it is very hard to understand what China wants say? Both are the oldest civilizations but so much trust deficit, can't see rise of Asia until both countries have good relations.

Nomi Jan 19, 2017 09:04am

India is just good at point scoring whereas, in practical she is a zero power with super zero intel. Shall India behaved in a responsible way by resolving all issues with Pakistan, today SA would depict different picture. By showing attitude to Pakistan is only making Pakistan more stronger , important and attractive to the powerful world.

Alii Jan 19, 2017 09:06am

@Rahul Are you sure? He didn't even name CPEC... or China... or Pakistan.

saudagar Jan 19, 2017 09:03am

all in a day`s work for INDIAN and CHINESE diplomats . nothing new.

Jawad Jan 19, 2017 09:15am

Well done China!! We love you!!

Fhavy Jan 19, 2017 09:16am

@Game changer In actual fact China is investing only 11 billion dollars from its coffers. The rest of 35 billion dollars are coming from Chinese PSUs for which Pakistan will have to pay 27% interest. This interest rate is so high that even Pakistan's current generation, their children and children's children will not be able to pay back this money. That is the game changing economic strategy... Good luck with CPEC

rajan Jan 19, 2017 09:12am

We warned Chinese not to trespass India. CPEC is a trespassing. Let us see what Chinese do it for that !!!

Nasir Jan 19, 2017 09:14am

@somebody panicking Not really .... about 1/2 dozen cases

Qasim Ahmad Jan 19, 2017 09:17am

Pak-China Dosti Zindabad

kanwarch Jan 19, 2017 09:26am

@somebody panicking Yes just for money. If you are so kind then why not allow sports people to play in India. Wherever there is money for Indians then all the nice things come out otherwise they keep on making sure that Pakistan and its interests are damaged everywhere in the world.

Ravi Jan 19, 2017 09:30am

What is the solution to Kashmir?..annexation with Pakistan or an Independant nation?

Rajendra Jan 19, 2017 09:33am

If china doesn't respect INDIA's sovereignty, then it should not expect respect from INDIA as well.

D.K. PAMNANI Jan 19, 2017 09:37am

Modi's statement is appreciable that too without naming, other countries could understand India's genuine concern.

Hameed Jan 19, 2017 09:32am

@somebody panicking Indian doctor have a very reputation in America. People avoid them. They can not diagnose. I have had many experiences..

Only human Jan 19, 2017 09:37am

@somebody panicking , ;) well said...

Hameed Jan 19, 2017 09:38am

@Fhavy If Pakistan pays 50% interest, then it is Pakistan business.

Khan Jan 19, 2017 09:36am

Indian are habitual day dreamers.

Funny to hear them whining for past 70 plus years

javed Jan 19, 2017 09:36am

@Ahsan gul, I strongly disagree, we cannot have an incompetent foreign minister since we don't have any foreign minister.

JUSTICE Jan 19, 2017 09:37am

Instead of Indian getting jealous on CPEC project, the Indian government should bring land dispute issue with UNO and let them solve Kashmir issue according to UN resolutions and live in peace forever. Kashmir belong to Kashmiri people, they have to decide if they want to join Pakistan or not. Indian can't effort to keep Kashmir under occupation, Indian soldiers are starving in occupied Kashmir.

javed Jan 19, 2017 09:39am

Well... then India should do something about it, right!

sajed syed Jan 19, 2017 09:44am

@Fhavy , a part that is sadly missed (deliberately hidden by the Hukumrans) from common man.

vp Jan 19, 2017 09:39am

@Qasim Ahmad Once it was hindi-chini bhai-bhai, you can see what was done afterwards..

Hamid Shafiq Jan 19, 2017 09:41am

@Rahul words is nothing do some action and then see some reaction.

Zakir hussain Jan 19, 2017 09:42am

Indian should provide same logistical development to Vietnam

Zakir hussain Jan 19, 2017 09:47am

@D.K. PAMNANI Indian should provide same logistical development to Vietnam

KALEEM Jan 19, 2017 09:46am

@somebody panicking A few hundreds every year travel to India for cheaper medical facilities and Indian hospitals do no favor, its business after all!

Desi Dimag Jan 19, 2017 09:45am

India will not sit idle if its sovereignty breaches.

ompuri Jan 19, 2017 09:45am

When will China stop the atrocities on the Uyghurs?

NOBODY Jan 19, 2017 09:53am

@javed Maybe we will.. wait and watch :)

Ind Jan 19, 2017 09:50am

Mr. Modi give right of self determination to Kashmir they will prove you wrong.

Thind Jan 19, 2017 09:58am

@Nasir ....I work for a private hospital in Delhi and we treat 1/2 dozen beloved Pakistanis everyday. Please don't let it hurt your ego, I am sure Pakistan would have done the same. Love from India.

NOBODY Jan 19, 2017 09:59am

@KALEEM Actually the hospitals and some organisations do.. For some poor Pakistani patients who could not afford they collected funds for the heart surgery in Bangalore.

Valiya Jan 19, 2017 09:55am

@KALEEM Cheap and best

Inqelab Zindabad Jan 19, 2017 10:02am

@Shahid Mahmood Small or big, we have one..

giri Jan 19, 2017 10:03am

China should stop behaving like a bully. Because they will not succeed in their designs. They will see that in south china sea soon. Their arrogance and ego will be crushed soon.

Happy new year Jan 19, 2017 10:07am

More hard reaction and action needed...

giri Jan 19, 2017 10:07am

@KALEEM : That is what they say about INdian movies in Pakistan. Now when Dangal is not released in Pakistan they are crying foul and blaming India. May be because they now know who is dependent on whom. If Modi stops medical visa then many will die in Pakistan. Only rich can go to USA. Accept your weaknesses with broad mind only then bilateral progress is possible.

Indian Jan 19, 2017 10:05am

@KALEEM But, why not going to China for medical purposes ie world famous for cheaper facilities? Probably not able to afford.

Sohail Gem Jan 19, 2017 10:08am

China will soon emerged as super power in the world..

Keep going China and Pakistan.

Kamran 3 Jan 19, 2017 10:09am

@Desi Dimag India is a weak country.

Nc Jan 19, 2017 10:09am

@Shahid Mahmood Mr Shahid let you have the big heart we are happy ..What ever we have...

south Asia Jan 19, 2017 10:17am

India too should review One China policy.

khanm Jan 19, 2017 10:16am

I get this gut feeling that there is something going to happen, seems like India is quite envious about this C E P E C..they can deal with Pakistan with cold start wonder how they will deal with China... unless.... We Manifest plainness, Embrace simplicity, Reduce selfishness, Have few desires...

sohail Jan 19, 2017 10:24am

“CPEC passes through a territory that we see as our territory." seems dare you say this when people in IOK are already fed up of your govt

John Jan 19, 2017 10:22am

@Kamran 3 thats why score is 4-0

Arun Jan 19, 2017 10:29am

@Shahid Mahmood Better than being a smaller country with no heart

DIL DIL PAKISTAN Jan 19, 2017 10:39am

Unable understand india criticism??

DIL DIL PAKISTAN Jan 19, 2017 10:39am

It shows india never want good relations with Pakistan.

Rohit Jan 19, 2017 10:35am

@south Asia Don't worry, Trump is coming .. so no actionable on our part...for next 4 years at least!.. "Ser will get Sava Ser soon.."..

DIL DIL PAKISTAN Jan 19, 2017 10:37am

India's frustration at its peak.

Peace Jan 19, 2017 10:39am

Good job Dawn for publishing fair article mentioning all parties position.

Manoj Lalchandani Jan 19, 2017 10:43am

@Rahul Yes, but what worries me is that we are not a non aligned state any more. That really worries me and it is this aspect of our foreign policy I dis-agree.

ISB Jan 19, 2017 10:47am

India evil dreams will catch dust. full stop.

shivaji Jan 19, 2017 10:44am

China....What about the international sea dispute...have you ever accept the verdict of International court....and now your claiming the land also...

Kabir Jan 19, 2017 10:45am

@Desi Dimag "India will not sit idle if its sovereignty breaches" Ok will India go the UNO ? please reply

dev Jan 19, 2017 11:04am

@Fhavy at about 25% , the loan compounded annually doubles every 42 months, so pak can claim 100+ billion project after 4yeas and so on

SAM Jan 19, 2017 11:06am

All India can do is complain and cry fowl, thats pretty much all they have done in the past 70 years. Pakistan is and should continue to forge ahead with its plans!

true minds Jan 19, 2017 11:08am

Modiji has said that China should not see threat on India rise.

China is worry of Japan-US-India relation which will be joined by Russia after Trump take the seat.

Abdul Jan 19, 2017 11:09am

Entry point of CPEC the Khunjarab Pass to Raikot is part of Pakistan since November 1948 and you can't event think it as part of Azad Kashmir and we unconditionally merged with Pakistan in 1948 by defeating Dogra Raj Gov. so you even don't think that GB/NAs sometime back are part of AK. Shame on Narendar Modi who is saying that GB/NAs is part of India, his statement is ridiculous if he think that it is your part then please arrange a UN sponsored referendum and ultimately you can get 100/0 votes in favor of Pakistan so don't think about GB and free IoK (Jammu & Kashmir).

KhwarAzmi Jan 19, 2017 11:21am

Azad Kashmir is not the territory of the Republic of India. Even J&K is not the territory of the Republic of India which it has occupied against the will of her people whose grandparent generation, parent generation and current generation wants to join Pakistan.

India is just hellbent on creating trouble in the neighborhood.

ANT Jan 19, 2017 11:16am

It is strange that Indian governments including Modi are unable to take a hard line when it comes to China. Ghosts of '62 continue to haunt New Delhi.

Rah Jan 19, 2017 11:24am

China's role in South Asia till now has been very negative. Be it India, Japan, Afghanistan, Vietnaam, South Korea, Mongolia, or any other countries.

Alba Jan 19, 2017 11:35am

@rajan ..... ... The Indian military had better study the Korean War before they try to take on the Chinese army. I remember one GI in Vietnam saying, "We found this dead officer killed in the air strike who was over six feet tall. So we knew he was not Vietnamese. We knew he was Chinese because their artillery fire was so accurate."

kumar Jan 19, 2017 11:33am

China want world to respect one-China policy but it respects none of the neighbors concerns

Freeman Jan 19, 2017 11:39am

@Indian my dear commentator Pakistanies are paying for medical services, if you don't want their money, than may can ask Indian Hospitals to stop taking our medical cases.. we pay you serves.. fair enough...

prashant Jan 19, 2017 11:40am

They could have renamed CPEC to something else if it would have been for regional peace. What if India contributes for regional peace in Indian ocean and sounth china sea?

M Waseem K Jan 19, 2017 11:54am

@giri Look who is talking

Indian Jan 19, 2017 11:54am

@Fhavy True

M Waseem K Jan 19, 2017 11:53am

@south Asia And China should act on disintegrate India Policy

Irfan Jan 19, 2017 11:59am

India is Cruising for Bruising.

Arun-KS Jan 19, 2017 11:59am

Indians always face Chinese with dignity, some do not, who are these some?

Alba Jan 19, 2017 12:06pm

@giri .... What are China's designs? Care to explain that?

Syed Ahmad Jan 19, 2017 12:12pm

@somebody panicking You make it sound like the Indians are doing that for free..

Arun JAIN Jan 19, 2017 12:16pm

What a mature statement by Mr Modi!!! Dear Hua , what kind of peace is prevailing in the region due to South China Sea conflict? Double standard. China deserves better leadership.

Syed Ahmad Jan 19, 2017 12:19pm

@Thind yes, but they charge a lot of money. Its not charity, which is what you make it sound like.

El Cid Jan 19, 2017 12:19pm

India can't afford, will not allow CPEC to flourish.

Saurabh Jan 19, 2017 12:24pm

@Freeman you don't pay. India NGOs raise money to treat you. We pay and you enjoy the services.

Sandeep Jan 19, 2017 12:28pm

Great bring it on! The more the Chinese will deny, the louder and harsher it will get!

Joseph Jan 19, 2017 12:25pm

From day one India is opposing CPEC,but all Indian claims brush aside by China & Pakistan.The bleak chances of India to join CPEC will diminish if India keep on adamant.

Saif zulfiqar Jan 19, 2017 12:30pm

Modi has failed in the International matters completely.

Samir lone Jan 19, 2017 12:45pm

Thanks for the laughs, India! I am Kashmiri and proud to call myself Pakistani. This is our land and we don't need your stamp of approval. Tried to isolate Pakistan, got snubbed every day ever since.

Samir lone Jan 19, 2017 12:41pm

@Rahul let's see how far Modis mouth gets you. So far just empty rhetoric purely for domestic consumption. Zero substance. Pathetic!

a Jan 19, 2017 12:48pm

@Rahul Flair yes, finesse NO ! He's such a poor orator at the international level that you almost have to make extra effort to understand what he's actually saying. Our nations still fail to understand that a major part of being the leader ôf a nation is being able to put the nation's stand across effectively and effortlessly. And the language for that is English. Like it or not. Truth be told.

Faisal warraich Jan 19, 2017 12:53pm

Entire Kashmir is natural part of pskistan. India cannot see Pakistan marching on the road of prosperity.

Anwar Mahmood Jan 19, 2017 12:59pm

China and Pakistan are marching together and forward. CPEC does look grand.Enjoy my poem as such:

The world now does so understand That CPEC project is much grand Pak and China got the role Together they dominate Asia whole

The odd one bad just may not like CPEC pentrates, does'nt spike Energy for China, wealth for Paks CPEC now does every body talks

China Paks are grand sans fears CPEC yes now every one hears And the world does understand CPEC is on Pak China land

Goods and energy and lot more Pak and China will share for sure The jealous odd can only cry CPEC. they aint got to try

Z Jan 19, 2017 01:04pm

peanut butter and jelly..

jay Jan 19, 2017 01:15pm

@somebody panicking totally right bro

Bhola Bhala Jan 19, 2017 01:16pm

Pakistanis are supporting China but applying for immigration in the US. They should try China.

VINEETH G Jan 19, 2017 01:13pm

Now what would China say if Modi were to go ahead and visit Taiwan and sign agreements for bilateral cooperation citing these were for 'regional peace and development' ?

Sohan Jan 19, 2017 01:14pm

Pakistan beware! It is great Chinese game that Pakistan does not understand. I think China will complete CPEC but note that China is not building it for Pakistan's economic development but only as a back up to China's energy routes through South China Sea which are being disputed by many countries. That was the main motivation for the CPEC plus keep China's navy at Gwadar. The fact is that the CPEC land route will never be economically viable and hence not used compared to sea routes. As long as sea routes are not disrupted, the CPEC will be a stranded asset and lot of waste of money and resources.

Masoud Jan 19, 2017 01:20pm

CPEC will surely find its way from jammu & srinagar as well, just little time is required for the great development of kashmiris.

Masoud Jan 19, 2017 01:21pm

@Faisal warraich: You are right. India cannot digest other's growing in the region

Pune-India Jan 19, 2017 01:26pm

@KALEEM: Then why didn't you do such business with China's hospital..??

Amjad Jan 19, 2017 01:35pm

India could settle the issue easily by implementing UNO's resolutions on Kashmir.

Bystander Jan 19, 2017 01:40pm

@Fhavy our 20% GDP is higher than this total amount put together. Although it may be a huge interest but at least not our children and children's children will have to remain paying this. You are hyper-pessimist in this regard, obviously.

Khan Jan 19, 2017 01:35pm

There is absolutely no need for China to clarify anything to India as CPEC is none of their business. Modi lives in a dream world and thinks all Pakistani land belongs to India and people living there should be slaved or go to hell. But in fact, Kashmir is illegally occupied by India and UN should act to have it liberated.

Fahd Jan 19, 2017 01:40pm

@ VIJ, Americans not to long ago conceded south china sea to China. China made a mockery of American so called Red line by dancing all over it. Then there is the Red line in Syria that came and went!

Mahmood Jan 19, 2017 01:43pm

India is simply jealous. Try and take on China, see how far you get.

Genghis Khan Jan 19, 2017 01:47pm

Well done India; We love you.

Jalbani Baloch Jan 19, 2017 01:43pm

India should keep its mouth shut. GB is part and parcel of Pakistan and not only this, but even Pakistan has a rightful claim over the Indian occupied Kashmir, and the day is not far, when the Pakistan flag will flutter over the CM House of Kashmir, being a fifth province of Pakistan. Long Live Kashmir and long live Pakistan.

Genghis Khan Jan 19, 2017 01:49pm

@Qasim Ahmad , USA- India Dosti Zindabad.

Genghis Khan Jan 19, 2017 01:54pm

@Mahmood , Have you not heard about Japan- China war?

true minds Jan 19, 2017 01:58pm

If China don't consider freedom of Xinjiang Muslim ,Taiwan and can not obey the order of world court on South China sees it and there are countries who know how to tackle such undiscipline dragon.

shafi Jan 19, 2017 01:53pm

@Alba Instead Indians better read the Japanese slaughter of chines in the WWII. Would be more useful when push comes to shub.

true minds Jan 19, 2017 02:00pm

@VIJ you got it.

Arun JAIN Jan 19, 2017 02:05pm

@Masoud It could be other way round. China can not digest that India is growing.

IMTIAZ ALI KHAN Jan 19, 2017 02:12pm

Long live Sino-Pak friendship! Iron brothers! Qian Jin! Love to China from Pakistan.

IMTIAZ ALI KHAN Jan 19, 2017 02:13pm

Praying for the day when we can also say love live Indo-Pak friendship! True Blood Brother!

Skeptic Jan 19, 2017 02:15pm

@Arun JAIN - Yeah, sure, whatever makes your turban jump! China is the second largest economy in the World, and will soon over take the US as #1. The sheer size and liquidity at the disposal of the Chinese economy, does not compare with India - despite its growth rate.

Get out of your shell. Every nation is 'growing' at different rates. India could never catch up with China, even if it grows at 10% per year. Because the US will still be a challenge to overcome for India, before it could catch up with China.

Viking Star Jan 19, 2017 02:32pm

Unfortunately India is not in a position to challenge mighty China. The latter is flexing it's muscles at a great pace and is set to become major military and political power of the world. China is already controlling half of the world (Asia, Asia Pacific and now the middle east). India must realize it can not be the big brother of Pakistan as China badly needs Pakistan for its expansion program, and thus would fully support Pakistan. With Russia coming closer to Pakistan, it's another big dent to India. The only solution for Indias survival is to shed it's ego, realize it's worth and try and be friendly with Pakistan.

saif Jan 19, 2017 02:32pm

We have our legitimate claims on Indian Occupied Kashmir. Why do you indians think, it is correct to build dams there, despite of objections? Exactly! to provide electricity to Kashmir. That means, the de facto controlling power has the responsibility to work for the good of the people. So even if we are assume Pakistan not to be a de jure controlling power, like you indians claim, it is our duty to do everything to ensure their well being and prosperity. And that is what we are doing.

samhere Jan 19, 2017 02:30pm

If China want their sovereignty to be respected then they should respect India's sovereignty too. Practice what you preach.

Afgan KHan Jan 19, 2017 02:43pm

India should join CPEC

saif Jan 19, 2017 02:44pm

@Sohan So what? China and Pakistan have common interest in that. We know, it is mainly an energy corridor for china. Our direct and indirect benefits are numerous. One indirect benefit is, Pakistan's security will become china's security. Your pain on the presence of chinese navy in Gawadar is difficult to hide.

lafanga Jan 19, 2017 02:44pm

CPEC neither violates Indian sovereignty nor it is a threat to India. On the contrary India has been invited to join CPEC. Storm in a teacup as usual when it comes to Indian relations with China and/or Pakistan.

Masoud Jan 19, 2017 02:42pm

What territory India is referring to, whole of kashmir belongs to kashmiris who are desperately trying to get freedom from indian oppression and join Pakistan. Currently CPEC is covering areas that belongs to Pakistan. Hopefully soon Jammu & Srinagar will also get linked through CPEC.

Ateeq Ahmed Jan 19, 2017 02:45pm

Mr. Minister, in that case Pakistan call upon India to withdraw its forces from Kashmir and stop building that railways immediately.

lafanga Jan 19, 2017 02:41pm

@Desi Dimag "India will not sit idle if its sovereignty breaches"

Ok what are you going to do about it. Stop CPEC or stop China? LOL

lafanga Jan 19, 2017 02:45pm

@VINEETH G "Now what would China say if Modi were to go ahead and visit Taiwan and sign agreements for bilateral cooperation citing these were for 'regional peace and development' ?"

India is not in the same league as China so crossing any of the Chinese red lines will be suicidal for India. Think before you thump your chest.

Harmony-1© Jan 19, 2017 02:47pm

Chinese response is another snub to Modi in a list of many in his eternal desire to 'isolate Pakistan'. He doesn't learn - peace and prosperity is good for all in the region not enmity!

sheraz khan Jan 19, 2017 02:50pm

Modi gone mad

Alam Jan 19, 2017 02:56pm

@somebody panicking........RSS not aware of this. they will stop it as soon as they come to know. They will claim these patients will go to Kashmir after treatment. Are Indian doctors treating them free?

amin Jan 19, 2017 02:55pm

Indians can barely hold on to the Kashmir territory they have seized. They want more bloodshed in Kashmir because it is not their brothers that are dying

Hamza Jan 19, 2017 02:59pm

We will keep working, India shall do sweating part.

Viks Jan 19, 2017 02:59pm

From an Indian side, I feel very happy to see the development activity planned professionally and being implemented with care. I hope to see this project will break the jinx and open Pakistani economy as well as it will help Pakistani society to open up socially too. I wish that the Indian concerns around CPEC passing through the Kashmir are addressed peacefully too.

Alam Jan 19, 2017 03:03pm

Every part of Kashmir belong to Kashmiris. India should allow Kashmiris to decide every matter pertaining to Kashmir.

C.A.P. Jan 19, 2017 03:06pm

So sad that India wants to derail CPEC for running through "disputed" territory while it has always consistently stonewalled every attempt to resolve the "dispute" itself over the last 70 years. India is not voicing a legitimate grievance, it is only being a hypocrite and the offline equivalent of a troll. And China and Pakistan can see right through India's tactic, that's why they both outright reject India's protestations with the dismissive contempt they deserve. India needs to do some self-reflection.

Harmony-1© Jan 19, 2017 03:12pm

Look at the finger pointing at Xi in the picture - lack of manners!

Alina Jan 19, 2017 03:17pm

India's just being psychotically paranoid. Whereas Pakistan and China see CPEC as a purely economic project aimed at regional integration, and magnanimously even went so far as to invite India to join it, India, in its determined commitment to unending hostility to its neighbors, continues to see CPEC in zero-sum geopolitical terms. Pakistan and China will just sit back and enjoy the light show while India merrily shoots itself in the foot with that kind of poisonous attitude. India better start behaving sensibly and stop picking a silly fight with its neighbors that it can't possibly win. India's stupidity is pitiable.

Riaz Jan 19, 2017 03:19pm

Giri......dream on! Read history and peoples capability please!

Arshad Mahmood Jan 19, 2017 03:20pm

India can cry all it likes, it took the matter to UN and accepted UN's decision that it was a disputed territory. Comply with UN resolution & resolve the issue before claiming it as your territory.

Sheraz Jan 19, 2017 03:27pm

I can only see the big numbers but very small number of logical and realistic minds on the other side of the border....

DR. Farooq Khan Jan 19, 2017 03:26pm

Speed up CPEC construction,

Kamal Jan 19, 2017 03:33pm

China is not crazy about spending billions if it was not feasible and benefit region. India should stop meddling in Pakistan-China affairs and join in and stop messing with USA and China rift as it little pawn coming in way super power fight.

Tahir Baloch Jan 19, 2017 03:37pm

Why India is concerned about CPEC now?

SDA Jan 19, 2017 03:38pm

@sohail Well said.

taimoor khan Jan 19, 2017 03:39pm

Only disputed land is the Indian held kashmir. The rest is sovereign part of Pakistan. Modi needs to come out of his delusion.

SDA Jan 19, 2017 03:48pm

@rajan Chinese are very hard working people compared to Indians. They will find something to overcome this hurdle.

Maxx Jan 19, 2017 03:43pm

China-Pakistan has trade through KKH which passes through Gilgit-Baltistan for the last 30 years or more, if India thinks it passes their territory, why this issue was not raised earlier...

This is actually height of hypocrisy by India and Modi. India in reality is more concerned about Gwadar port being given to China on 45 year lease and she is developing it and is certainly the main stumbling block for India, There would be Chinese navy, Chinese submarines presence as well to safe guard the waters as usually happens with any blue water navy.

India need to come out of its hypocrisy which she practices more often than not. IOK belongs to people of Kashmir and they don't want to align or live with India...simple as that.

Arshad Jan 19, 2017 03:48pm


true minds Jan 19, 2017 04:00pm

@KhwarAzmi read the history.

M. Ahmed Jan 19, 2017 04:00pm

Entire Kashmir belongs to Pakistan, its India that is violating territorial sovereignty of Pakistan

Arshad Jan 19, 2017 04:01pm

This statement is the another sign of mischief by India, a reminder of past.

akram Jan 19, 2017 04:15pm

instead of flapping about sovereignty, to which no one is going to care anyway. India would be better off looking to bring democracy to Kashmir and settling the dispute, after which they can join and make use of CPEC for their own exports and economic growth.

Mustafa Jan 19, 2017 04:17pm

India was invited to join CEPEC , whats the hesitation

akram Jan 19, 2017 04:20pm

@Rahul and what has it achieved? the end result matters not. No one cares in China or Pakistan what modi thinks. So what was the point?

akram Jan 19, 2017 04:19pm


Democracy my friend is the solution, a true choice for all the people of Jammu & Kashmir to decide their fate.

ALIBABA the great Jan 19, 2017 04:25pm

Let us wait and see what China does if they claim to be a Super Power ! Just now sincere appreciation for India's outburst !!

jawaid Jan 19, 2017 04:20pm

During the past many years I have not seen a day when India would be fair and friendly and not belligerent toward Pakistan.

FRUSTRATED INDIAN Jan 19, 2017 04:23pm

Modi is like a fox. He always acts innocent and finally he bits the peoples hands who gave him the vote. He is very dangerous to india itself. Now i understand how muslims in india feel under his rule. I feel very ashamed for voting him. What ever pakistan thinks about modi is right. Btw, am from south.

Syed F. Hussaini Jan 19, 2017 04:25pm

The classical definitions are transforming.

The contest between the top and the expanding middle class is now regional at the threshold of globalization.

In the power structure, the bottom has been rendered irrelevant, as far as the control mechanism is concerned.

The Indian middle class is attempting to negotiate with the Chinese top.

Unless the middle class make themselves relevant in other regional domains, they can't join the conversation.

In this regional contest for a piece of action, the top can easily come out a winner--in China the usual in India the middle class elsewhere whatever...

Eliminating the middle class is as impossible as eliminating the bottom.

Only the top mathematics can predict whether this equation would eliminate the top or, the middle class.

The bottom is zero with a mathematical power to render everything to zero and to survive with the power of zero to infinity.

Good Luck, Zero!

China-Beijing Jan 19, 2017 04:30pm

CPEC to Pakistan is more than The Marshall Plan to Europe.

History will prove this.

Let's come back and talk about CPEC 10 years later from now.

khan Jan 19, 2017 04:32pm

@Abdul and also shame to the government of pakistan their is not a single member of gb in the national assembly of pakistan how can we say that gb is a part of pakistan first give the people of gb their rights then claim its a part of pakistan

Ahsan Jan 19, 2017 04:27pm

CPEC project work started 2 years ago but India did not object. Their thought at that time was that it will not materialise. Now out of traditional jealousy with Pakistan and fear of mighty China they pretended Azad Kashmir as a part of their territory . CPEC will pass through Azad Kashmir before entering into Zhinjiang in China. As a matter of fact entire Kashmir belongs to Pakistan so what's the problem.

Awan Jan 19, 2017 04:30pm

@VIJ ...let's see China reaction if India dare to go for. It's not American time now China can stand for his right.

Blunt Jan 19, 2017 04:34pm

So India's terrorist activities inside Pakistan has failed to stop CPEC progress they are now start crying on other forums.

KING KHAN Jan 19, 2017 04:33pm

@PAKISTANI Nope I dont agree

IMTIAZ ALI KHAN Jan 19, 2017 04:48pm

@China-Beijing Wishing best of luck to both the countries.

China-Beijing Jan 19, 2017 05:00pm


As I have said a number of times, India is sponsoring the terror groups inside Pakistan, most noticeable the Taliban in Pakistan. And India is also coordinating the terror activities inside Pakistan for the sheer purpose of destabilizing Pakistan and hindering Pakistan's development.

Zealot Jan 19, 2017 05:05pm

Foreign office Wake Up please.Enemy is making statement on kashmir!!!

Naveed Jan 19, 2017 05:05pm

If sounds quite funny when Indians claim Pakistan part of Kashmir, ignoring the fact that people of Indian occupied Kashmir don't want to live under India.

LAHORI KID Jan 19, 2017 05:47pm

Modi spoke about respecting territorial sovereignty while occupying Kashmir for decades, planning to build damns to stop the water from coming to Pakistan, and he's upset about CPEC?

Indian muSLIM Jan 19, 2017 05:52pm

Modi has nothing better to do.

Shahid Jan 19, 2017 05:55pm

It is intstructively interesting to read nature and number of comments. Not a pretty picture.

Satyameva Jayate Jan 19, 2017 06:10pm

@Indian muSLIM - What is better for a PM than to serve his country's best interest? That is what Modi did.

Indian muSLIM Jan 19, 2017 06:15pm

@Satyameva Jayate are u kidding me, he has served only Bakhts and the BJP fanatics. His Foreign Policy is clearly falling apart which made India a laughing stock in the Global Arena.

Merchant Jan 19, 2017 06:19pm

@Rahul the kind of flair you have mentioned is reflected in the carefree or careless speeches of Donald Trump

Waaris Jan 19, 2017 06:21pm

Which bit of Indian territory Modi is talking about?? Is it the newly acquired Afghanistan or a future bad dream of Balochistan??

yaqut khan Jan 19, 2017 06:28pm

India should read the history of gilgit baltistan.india is behaving like land grabber.

zak Jan 19, 2017 06:48pm

The Chinese should refer them to UN resolutions. It is not Indian territory legally nor morally ( people of IOK want them out, forget people of AJK). Indian gibberish should be treated with the same worthlessness.

Raj Jan 19, 2017 06:48pm

@China-Beijing There is truth in your words.

BAXAR Jan 19, 2017 06:58pm

@Sohan " It is great Chinese game that Pakistan does not understand. " If there is anything Pakistan understands, it is great games. We live on great games since time immemorial. Our power lies upon strategic position. There is no great game in the region if Pakistan is not there. Why on earth you think we allied with China when it was only a shadow of it's present, right after the independence?

ghaznavi Jan 19, 2017 07:00pm

Hold a transparent referendum in AJK and the Northern Areas , put two choices to the people, joint India or join Pakistan. The results will shut the Indians once for all and revive the UN resolutions. There is nothing to lose here

D-Nawaz Jan 19, 2017 06:56pm

It has been Indian policy since day one of Independence to hurt Pakistan. We have learned to live under the hate policy and we have found a way to tackle it successfully. CPEC is reality and will bring prosperity not only in Pakistan but to many countries. India is a thorn as usual until all thorns are scraped.

Indian muSLIM Jan 19, 2017 07:01pm

Modi's concern about CPEC is just to overshadow his failure to Execute Chabahar port plan which he and his associates created a hype of.

sana-1 Jan 19, 2017 07:03pm

Useless talk and talk and talk and talk.....what else can India do? If Azad kashmir is a part of India so does the whole pakistan.....why Indian history stops after 1947? Cant read that we got independence, with kashmir as our part, including jammu kashmir! You are occupying our land! If you are trying to say that azad kashmir is yours then come and take it, only if you CAN! p.s., Indians are just too emotional people, their leaders are uselessly diverting their anger towards the Impossible issues saying that they can take on a fight with two major Nuclear armed neighbors! Uselessly wasting tax payers money on two cents talks!

Farouq Omaro Jan 19, 2017 07:04pm

Chinese think they can do anything, beware of these communists. Don't forget their atrocities in Tibet & East Turkestan.

Karthik Jan 19, 2017 07:02pm

CPEC is not in Indian territory. The whole world knows it. India is playing a dirty game and want to pull down Pakistan. Guys you are not alone. Very soon there is going to be Kashmir in the southern part of India. India suppress our belief and our traditions. All i wish is make India pay for whatever it is doing to us. Do not leave India to be a part of CPEC.

Karthik Jan 19, 2017 07:11pm

@PAKISTANI Kashmir is already not a part of India. The people should choose where do they want to go. India cannot hold them by force. Let the Kashmiris decide. If india thinks that they will choose the indian side, what is there to fear ?

aamir ayub Jan 19, 2017 07:08pm

India don't make anyone foolish by your claim. The Gilgit and Baltistan has been part of Pakistan since 1948. If you believe Kashmir is your then first implement the UNO resolution to decide the truth and then if you win the plebiscite you can make such claim. But you always avoided plebiscite for which Pakistan has been urging. Kashmir's 80 per cent population is of Muslim and the same rule must be applied on Kashmir which was applied in making India and Pakistan that the areas where Muslims are in majority will be part of Pakistan and of Hindu community will form India.

Karthik Jan 19, 2017 07:08pm

@sheraz khan Ha ha.. Well Said..

Indian muSLIM Jan 19, 2017 07:20pm

@sana-1 well said Sana and unfortunately it is so true. Modi and BJP is diverting the attention from real issues of India since they are too incompetent to even work on them.

LL Jan 19, 2017 07:22pm

India is making a fool out of itself. Let's face it India is about to lose its own Kashmir to Pakistan, let alone claiming Pakistani controlled Kashmir

Indian muSLIM Jan 19, 2017 08:10pm

@Karthik Totally agree with you. Everyone knows the Dirty role and Tactics played by Brahman centric government of Delhi in Tamil Nadu back in late 80s and 90s which resulted in the death of thousand of innocent Tamils.

yauqut khan Jan 19, 2017 08:42pm

@Abdul malik yes there are 5 resolutions on kashmir and UN has plebscite formuala according to those 5 resolutions.pakistan agrees with UN on that while india is hiding behind simla agreement.

yauqut khan Jan 19, 2017 08:44pm

@Rajendra china is actually violating pakistan's soveriegnty by considering IOK as indian part.

yauqut khan Jan 19, 2017 08:52pm

there are 5 resolutions on jammu and kashmir.UN has plebscite formula according to those 5 resolutions.pakkistan agrees with UN on that while india is hiding behind simla agreement,avoiding plebscite.indian claim on whole jammu and kashmir is invalid and against the basic human rights.

MARIYAM Jan 19, 2017 08:50pm

So, India is unable to defend its territorial independence as China has built roads through it territory.

KH Jan 19, 2017 09:08pm

@Nomi, yes, you are right.

LAHORI KID Jan 19, 2017 09:20pm

@Rajendra Respect is earned, so far, China is against India's practices, Pakistan doesn't agree with India, Kashmir is pounded by Indian soldiers, and you talk about respect? Respect given is respect earned.

Masood Jan 19, 2017 09:23pm

@somebody panicking : Do not exaggerate. There are a few of them, with a very heavy fee. Nothing is free. The Pakistani patients are charged exactly what the Americans pay and I have a living proof.

Genghis Khan Jan 19, 2017 09:45pm

It is very wrong on the part of China.

kaushal Jan 19, 2017 09:45pm

that's correct I think China should refrain against dealing with India coz they can't simply ignore India its almost equal to equal situation if not one sided Thanks

sana-1 Jan 19, 2017 09:47pm

@somebody panicking You are talking as if you are doing some favor to Pakistan? If Pakistanis go there then they also use your airlines, hotels, restaurants, buses, taxis just to name a few and majorly you hospital and doctor fees which is a cash flow out of Pakistan to India! In short you are getting its actually Pakistanis that is majorly benefiting your country not vice versa! Talking about charity, your country (not government) helped only those whom i can count on my fingers! BTW charity and NGOs are made for this reason...if any Indian was here we would have had helped him too, the only difference is we dont consider that as a favor to India rather a human!

Rahat Jan 19, 2017 10:26pm

@Rahul Modi wanted to get in power on the pillars of Religious extremism and hatred. Now he is reluctantly walking that walk. China has clearly snubbed India many time. India is giving careful statements like Territorial Sovereignty without mentioning much. I think India should learn the realities of the region and take a step back because Modi will eventually expose India as an extremist country that it is.

Rahat Jan 19, 2017 10:34pm

@Ali good point

Rahat Jan 19, 2017 10:36pm

@Fhavy The way India is weeping, tell a total different story.

Rahat Jan 19, 2017 10:43pm

@ABC Try to explain it to India. The regional bully

Mohammed Daud Jan 19, 2017 11:05pm

@Rajendra: Whenever we talk about CPEC, Indians start pouring in their advices against it. CPEC is a big stomach-ache and a nightmare for India, would never like it to get through. India now came up with new argument to China that CPEC passes through its territory, and India will never allow any threat to its sovereignty, as if Pakistan is India’s territory, it looks like CPEC made India mad and crazy. We must remember that only our enemies and the ignorant are against CPEC no one else. Long live Pak-China friendship.

syed zafar kazmI U.S Jan 19, 2017 11:01pm

Is there any country in the region India has not simmering disputes with?

syed zafar kazmI U.S Jan 19, 2017 11:02pm

@VIJ And India is right in the lap of the "master".

syed zafar kazmI U.S Jan 19, 2017 11:05pm

@Rahul Bluntness is the essential part of bullishness

syed zafar kazmI U.S Jan 19, 2017 11:12pm

@Shahid Mahmood You are being quite charitable; in view of what Kashmir has suffered at their Indian rulers hands for the past 7 decades, it is quite apt to imagine if at all they have any heart.

syed zafar kazmI U.S Jan 19, 2017 11:14pm

@somebody panicking Sure. Money buys anything

syed zafar kazmI U.S Jan 19, 2017 11:15pm

@somebody panicking While their own hearts are rotting inside out

syed zafar kazmI U.S Jan 19, 2017 11:22pm

@Fhavy if CPECS debt burden is so self destructive for Pakistan for all its future generations, Modi and his cohorts should celebrate it every moment of their life instead of losing their sleep protesting against at every imaginable opportunity.

syed zafar kazmI U.S Jan 19, 2017 11:23pm

CPEC is the glorious destiny shared in the region by two dynamic, forward thinking, progressive and peaceful nations creating opportunities for many other peoples of like mind and spirit in the region. Long live China & Pakistan

Dr. Salaria, aamir Ahmad Jan 20, 2017 12:48am

Yet another silly joke by Modi and his cronies.

sukhera Jan 20, 2017 01:50am

@Fhavy .Where did you get 27% interest rate on Chinese loans to Pakistan. These unsubstantiated comments don't serve any purpose except that people will brand you as a liar and untrustworthy.Before you accuse someone, there should always be enough proof to prove your accusations.Without proof, you are basically making a hopeless case out of thin air.

Freeman Jan 20, 2017 06:32am

Mr. Modi has habbit to index fingers while talking and that's a really annoying. Impolite gesture.. not suitable for any country PM

M. Siddique Jan 20, 2017 07:55am

PM Modi needs to wake up to realities of the world and smell the coffee. India illegally occupies Kashmir and beats the drums as well. If India wants to be part of peaceful neighborhood then it should join CPEC and get economic benefits. War mongering won't help.

Suri Jan 20, 2017 07:57am

@aamir ayub check your facts, India is a secular country. Religious Minorities in India are leading a better life compared to Pakistan

KhwarAzmi Jan 20, 2017 08:27am

Azad Kashmir is not Indian territory, never was and willl never be. The only territory in wuestion is the Indian occupied Lashmir whose majority Muslim population don't want to be with Hindu majority India. All Kashmiri demonstrators have Pakistani flags.

alok Jan 20, 2017 08:47am

@Shahid Mahmood : about china then.

Mohammad S. Khalid Jan 20, 2017 04:16pm

What a pity stance of poor India.

Joe Jan 20, 2017 04:21pm

@MARIYAM Correct But time does not remain same.

China-Beijing Jan 20, 2017 05:10pm


Well said.

That's why while they are willing to spend billions of dollars buying weapons when hundreds of millions of India's poor don't even have a toilet.

It's immoral.

Karamat Hussain Jan 20, 2017 06:41pm

@Ravi Whatever the kashmiris wish - easily sorted with a plebiscite but India too scared to hold one because they know Kashmiris will definitely not want to be with India

Atif Jan 20, 2017 08:11pm

@giri India should stop behaving like a bully. Because they will not succeed in their designs. They will see that in Kashmir soon. Their arrogance and ego will be crushed soon.

Mustafa R. Jan 20, 2017 08:21pm

What Modi says, thinks or wants hardly matters to China or Pakistan.

Mustafa R. Jan 20, 2017 08:22pm


Of course anything positive for Pakistan is negative for India.

Mustafa R. Jan 20, 2017 08:20pm


'I must appreciate Modi's open speak and courage .. to submit his point of view with full force'

Go ahead and appreciate, pride is free, false pride is cheaper yet.

Ijaz Jan 20, 2017 08:30pm

India's comments are irrelevant.

Kashmir is Pakistan and as such India is violating Pakistani territorial integrity every day and committing abuse against our citizens.

Vaibhav Jan 20, 2017 09:56pm

@somebody panicking true bro in Chennai,banglore,Delhi by Apollo,Tata and hiranandani

Indian muSLIM Jan 20, 2017 10:48pm

@sana-1 agree with that. We have Geetha case in view whereby she was taken Care by Mr Late Edhi like her own Daughter.

Jaspreet Singh Jan 20, 2017 10:56pm

@Hameed come on, kuch bhi. Please be grateful what Indians to the patients from Pakistan. Don't be thankless. Dawn has published so many stories about how Pakistand patients been treated in India. We know that we are not as competent as Pakistan is in all areas space, medical etc etc but we do believe in Humanity.

SP Jan 20, 2017 11:01pm

@Shahid Mahmood Maybe you meant China ?

Usama Jan 21, 2017 12:35am

Surrounded on all sides by China- Coco Island in the east, In the south Srilanka has leased 1500 acres land to china and in the west its Gawadar- India should find allies besides Afghanistan in the region. America is no coming to help, so find someone else ?? Why is India so proud of itself, while more than half of its population does not have access to toilets. Stop this craze India, You hv no comparison to China, And maybe this time Israel will too get some bruises that it deserved but escaped in 1999.

Honest Jan 21, 2017 01:26am

China is rattled by a rising India. But India will not be offensive to chill!! India is morally a superior country and its common people are a cultured people.

Hello World Jan 21, 2017 02:07am

@Tahir Baloch - because it goes past its territory... doesnt give a hoot for a mere 50 billion dollars project and indians doesnt need to.. they have many projects going beyond 200+ billion dollars... i am sure pakistan would also have other projects around its regions of the same magnitude going bot its business without any hiccups or indian interference.... guess i should have made you clear by now then.

Hello World Jan 21, 2017 02:09am

@M. Ahmed - just by saying doesnt mean it belongs.. try taking care of the existing hungry people and then think of adding more.

Hello World Jan 21, 2017 02:19am

@syed zafar kazmI U.S - is there a neighboring country that china doesnt has disputes with..... is there a country other than china that sees eye to eye with pakistan....NO, NONE.

Asad Khan Jan 21, 2017 02:32am

Modi has to learn not to point fingers at world leaders! Bad manners PM!!!

chacha Jan 21, 2017 02:52am

Raising finger on a leader of a country is consider disrespect, dimwit Mody

Riaz Ahmad Jan 21, 2017 06:33am

@Ahsan gul PML-N government is no different to the people who have elected it to power, both do nothing right, that is the sum total of true reality.

Rk Jan 21, 2017 07:04am

@Sohail Gem Chinese investment in Sri Lanka is causing major problems for Sri Lanka’s President Mathripala Sirisena and has become a point of tension in Sri Lanka–China relations.

Muneer Jan 21, 2017 10:00am

Respect of sovereignty is important to improve regional connectivity.Modi sahib this true also for your neighbour Pakistan.

Tariq ALi Jan 21, 2017 10:54am

If India spends more time improving itself instead of complaining about everything like babies, they will end up being a better country.

Thind Jan 21, 2017 01:00pm

@Syed Ahmad ...yes you are right, no charity there. But medical treatments is not purely a commodity trade either. You might find it hard to believe, but Pakistanis get a lot of love from many people in India, notwithstanding recent tensions.

SAM Jan 21, 2017 01:03pm

@somebody panicking "Repairing thousands of hearts"? since when may be 4 0r 5 Pakistani got treated in India in the last the 10 years. But when CPEC kicks in Millions of Pakistani's will have jobs and better living and hospitals where millions will treated everyday.