After all, what is the big deal if a few of them die?

Published
55

It is a strange world we live in today. In one corner, people are working hard to save the lives of stray animals, setting up rescue centres so that none go cold or hungry. In another, there are people uniting to save trees and forests, ensuring no part of nature is intentionally harmed.

And, in yet another corner, there is Thar.

Unfortunately, nobody seems to be trying to save anything but their seats out here.

The gap between the people of Thar and its leaders continues to grow as more than 60 infants have lost their lives in this region since the year began.

Sindh’s Chief Minister Syed Qaim Ali Shah, however, seems to think these deaths are largely exaggerated and that his governance can hardly be blamed for these tragedies.

Although the CM has been defending his government in the face of Thar infant deaths for years now, let us just suppose for a very tiny instant, that he is right.

Let us suppose, despite the PPP-led government’s best efforts, these deaths are still occurring — has Shah not spent enough years blooming into a seasoned politician to still not know how to at least address this sensitive issue when speaking to the media?

Also read: 311 Thar children died in 11 months: report

“If there was drought and lack of healthcare facilities, then men and women would also have suffered equally,” he said, adding that, “It was injustice to hold his government responsible for something that was not even prevailing”.

Despite being a senior politician who has been keeping the chief minister’s seat warm for several years now, Shah didn’t seem to realise he was not addressing a private gathering of yes-men in some remote part of the province. That he was, in fact, speaking to a socially aware and highly critical audience.

Despite his experience and perhaps, some basic health knowledge of the issues in Thar, he seemed to think an infant’s health is no different than an adult’s when making the above statement.

How is it acceptable that a chief minister can be so uninformed?

Also read: Death haunts Tharparkar, again

Boasting about the facilities available at the Mithi Civil Hospital, Shah did not respond to the criticism by parents hailing from Chhachhro, Diplo, Islamkot and other smaller towns, who complained about lack of medicines and other necessary facilities at healthcare centres.

Instead, he questioned them: “How is the government expected to know about every death in the desert?”

Well, figure it out chief minister.

According to provincial food minister Syed Nasir Hussain Shah, the Thar Development Authority, envisaged by the Sindh government after the deaths of children in 2014, is yet to be formed — it appears a dozen more dying babies is just what they needed to kick-start the programme.

Whether it is malnutrition, famine, maternity-related issues or lack of medical practitioners — it remains the government’s utmost responsibility to address the deaths in Thar.

Distributing pity cheques and releasing some funds to grieving parents who have just buried their children is a poor attempt at damage control.

Speaking on the issue, PPP MNA Imran Zafar Leghari didn't seem to think these deaths were a “big deal” either. And he was very matter-of-fact about it, “that’s what happens in hospitals — people die there.”

Ask the parents of these children, Mr Leghari, what the big deal is.

Also read: Minister attributes Thar children deaths to their mothers’ ‘carelessness’

Do our politicians then deserve the seats they so brashly defend? If the PPP is to continue cradling Sindh, perhaps, it's time the party invested in someone who is just as enthusiastic about defending the people of Sindh.

Someone who, as a bonus, possesses the capacity to address grave national tragedies with care and above all, admits when they are in the wrong.

As mentioned in this week’s Dawn editorial on the matter, it is time criticism stopped being termed a ‘conspiracy’ against democracy and instead be addressed for what it really is: failure.

Opinion

Editorial

Kashmir unresolved
Updated 30 Sep, 2026

Kashmir unresolved

The just solution lies in India addressing the issue through a trilateral dialogue involving the legitimate representatives of the Kashmiri people and Pakistan.
Water shortage
30 Sep, 2026

Water shortage

THAT the country is entering the Rabi season with an anticipated water shortage of nearly 25pc, the lowest carryover...
Young hearts
30 Sep, 2026

Young hearts

THE observance may have passed, but the message of World Heart Day should not fade with it. The occasion is a useful...
Terror and politics
Updated 29 Sep, 2026

Terror and politics

There is an urgent need to tone down the rhetoric and tackle terrorism as a collective challenge for both the affected provinces and the federation.
Watching the glaciers
29 Sep, 2026

Watching the glaciers

THE latest signs from Pakistan’s mountains are worrying. Suparco says the number of unfrozen glacial lakes it...
Dangerous agenda
29 Sep, 2026

Dangerous agenda

AS the world remains fixated on the US-Iran conflict, elsewhere in the Middle East, Israel is consolidating its grip...