India's top court strikes down ban on 'offensive' online comment

Published March 24, 2015
The Supreme Court said the 2009 amendment to India's Information Technology Act known as section 66A was unconstitutional and a restriction on freedom of speech. — Reuters/file
The Supreme Court said the 2009 amendment to India's Information Technology Act known as section 66A was unconstitutional and a restriction on freedom of speech. — Reuters/file

NEW DELHI: India's top court on Tuesday struck down a controversial law that made posting “offensive” comments online a crime punishable by jail, after a long campaign by defenders of free speech.

The Supreme Court said the 2009 amendment to India's Information Technology Act known as section 66A was unconstitutional and a restriction on freedom of speech.

“Section 66A is unconstitutional and we have no hesitation in striking it down,” said Justice R F Nariman, reading out the judgement. “The public's right to know is directly affected by section 66A.“

The Supreme Court had been asked to examine the legality of section 66A, which makes sending information of “grossly offensive or menacing character “punishable by up to three years in jail.

In 2012 two young women were arrested under the act over a Facebook post criticising the shutdown of financial hub Mumbai after the death of a local hardline politician.

The charges were later quashed by a Mumbai court.

But the case, which followed several arrests across the country for political cartoons or comments made online, sparked outrage and fierce debate about online censorship in India.

The government later issued guidelines on enforcing the law.

But in its judgement, the court said that the amendment could not be “saved by the assurances of the government that it will not be misused”.

Opinion

Editorial

Reserved seats
Updated 15 May, 2024

Reserved seats

The ECP's decisions and actions clearly need to be reviewed in light of the country’s laws.
Secretive state
15 May, 2024

Secretive state

THERE is a fresh push by the state to stamp out all criticism by using the alibi of protecting national interests....
Plague of rape
15 May, 2024

Plague of rape

FLAWED narratives about women — from being weak and vulnerable to provocative and culpable — have led to...
Privatisation divide
Updated 14 May, 2024

Privatisation divide

How this disagreement within the government will sit with the IMF is anybody’s guess.
AJK protests
14 May, 2024

AJK protests

SINCE last week, Azad Jammu & Kashmir has been roiled by protests, fuelled principally by a disconnect between...
Guns and guards
14 May, 2024

Guns and guards

THERE are some flawed aspects to our society that we must start to fix at the grassroots level. One of these is the...