Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience



Your Name:

Recipient Email:

The band's lead guitarist Taimur Rahman says the blocking of his band’s page was indicative of diminishing space for liberals in the country.—File Photo
The band's lead guitarist Taimur Rahman says the blocking of his band’s page was indicative of diminishing space for liberals in the country.—File Photo

ISLAMABAD: The Pakistan Telecom Authority (PTA) on Friday denied that it had blocked the popular Facebook page for a liberal Pakistani rock band ‘Laal’, days after the page became inaccessible for users from within the country.

“We have not closed the page of Laal, Facebook has its own terms of reference and it closes pages that seem indecent to them,” Khurram Ali Mehran, a spokesman for the regulatory body, told AFP.

The denial comes as Facebook claimed the page had been blocked inside Pakistan at Islamabad’s request, under an agreement to limit access to material that violates local laws.

Mehran, the PTA spokesman, denied the existence of such an agreement, saying Facebook had acted alone.

“We have no agreement with Facebook whatsoever, it's a pack of lies,” he said.

The page has been inaccessible to users inside Pakistan since Wednesday, angering activists campaigning against censorship in the country.

Also read: The case of Pakistan's vanishing Facebook pages

“Pakistan's agreement with Facebook came to light last year when a senior official from the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority, an Internet regulatory body, was summoned by the Lahore High Court in a case concerning the YouTube ban, but its terms have not been made public.

Rock band “Laal” (Red) formed in 2007 and are known for their progressive politics. Their Facebook page has more than 400,000 likes, with users frequently joining debates on issues ranging from feminism to the role of the country's army in politics.

Other pages like “Taalibansarezalimans” (The Taliban are oppressors) and “Pakistani.meem” which describes itself as pro-democracy and secularism, have similarly been blocked in recent days.

“Facebook didn't even inform us, I realised when I noticed no activity on our page,” Taimur Rahman, Laal's lead guitarist, told AFP.

A Facebook spokeswoman told the news agency: “While we never remove this type of content from the site entirely, like most Internet services, we may restrict people from accessing it in the countries where it is determined to be illegal.

“Before we restrict the content, we take significant steps to investigate each unique claim, consult with local counsel and other experts in the country, and will only remove content in the most limited way possible,” she added.

According to a page on Facebook that deals with government requests, 162 pieces of content were restricted for viewership inside Pakistan between July to December 2013.

“We restricted access in Pakistan to a number of pieces of content primarily reported by the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority and the Ministry of Information Technology under local laws prohibiting blasphemy and criticism of the state,” the page says.

Pakistan practises extensive Internet censorship, blocking YouTube in 2012 following the release of a low-budget film disrespectful of Islam. Websites for Baloch separatist movements in the country's southwest are also banned.

While attempts to access those sites result in a government message informing the user that the content has been blocked for viewership within Pakistan, clicking Laal's page ( or the other liberal pages instead re-directs a user towards their own home feed.

Shahzad Ahmad, director of the Bytes For All organisation that campaigns for free speech said: “The is a mass murder of free speech in Pakistan.

“Yasser Latif Hamdani, a lawyer, added: “This is a grave mistake by Facebook. Also for the Pakistani government to make such requests is illegal and unconstitutional.

Rahman, the musician, said the blocking of his band’s page was indicative of diminishing space for liberals in the country.

“If you have progressive or liberal views you will be gunned down or silenced but if you have extremist views and take up arms Pakistan will give you the status of a stakeholder in power and negotiate with you,” he said.

Comments (8) Closed

Frankenstine Jun 06, 2014 07:18pm

in a country like ours with such a pathetic literacy rate who bother about FREE SPEECH. I wish the author come up with something good

Muz Jun 06, 2014 07:49pm

The PTA bans pages and websites which are informative and progressive yet allow the extremist pages like TTP-Pakistan and Umar Media to run freely without a check.

malik Jun 06, 2014 08:14pm

Now this is called advertisement. to ban some thing is like adding catalyst to chemical reaction of getting famous. Just visited their face book page.

Nafisa Jun 06, 2014 08:41pm

This is really concerning!

Saad Zafar Jun 06, 2014 10:45pm

@malik This is NOT an advertisement. Laal is a popular leftist band in Pakistan. Denying access to their page is serious concern of all of us.

Taimoor Khan Jun 07, 2014 12:54am

Free speech they said? well I got news for them, majority of Pakistanis think these so called liberals are traitors and sell outs to country and its values. Either they show that they are in majority otherwise , shut it, and be side lined, this is how majority vote works.

Naveed Lotia Jun 07, 2014 05:08am

The IT Minister, Anusha Rehman should be fired and someone more open minded placed instead.

mohammadnoonnanna Jun 07, 2014 09:50am

I agree with Malik and Taimoor. It is a fashion in Pakistan to look for opportunities of publicity. They also indulge in activities repugnant to our social strates.