Some Samsung products banned in US over Apple patent row

Published
0

NEW YORK: Apple won a partial victory in its long-running patent dispute with Samsung on Friday when a US administrative panel found Samsung in violation of two Apple patents and blocked imports of some Samsung devices.

But the US International Trade Commission (ITC) cleared Samsung on four other patents in dispute.

President Barack Obama's administration has 60 days to veto ITC rulings.

Over the weekend, the administration invalidated a June order that sided with the South Korean company and banned imports of Apple's iPhone 4 and a variant of its iPad 2.

The patents involved in Friday's ruling aren't related to that June order.

Samsung Electronics Co and Apple Inc are in a global legal battle over smartphones. Apple argues Samsung's Android phones copy vital iPhone features.

Samsung is fighting back with its own complaints.

The legal disputes come as competition in the marketplace intensifies.

Samsung has been cutting into Apple's dominance in phones and is now the leading smartphone manufacturer.

Samsung is also pushing into Apple's territory with its own Android tablet computers.

These cases typically involve older products that are no longer widely sold.

Two of the phones cited in Friday's ruling were both 2010 models, the Continuum and the Transform.

But a victory in such cases could affect what features are included in future devices and could slow down a rival's momentum.

Apple could also seek to ban imports of phones released since the case was filed in 2011.

Samsung spokesman Adam Yates said the company was disappointed in the ban, but he said the ruling did reject Apple's effort ''to use its overbroad design patents to achieve a monopoly on rectangles and rounded corners.''

Yates said Samsung will continue to release new products and has taken measures to ensure they will continue to be available in the US.

In a statement, Apple said the ITC ''has joined courts around the world in Japan, Korea, Germany, Netherlands and California by standing up for innovation and rejecting Samsung's blatant copying of Apple's products. Protecting real innovation is what the patent system should be about.''

Last year, a federal court ruled that Samsung owed Apple $1 billion in damages for infringing on non-essential Apple patents.

But the judge refused to impose an import ban on Samsung phones and later struck $450 million from the verdict, saying the jurors miscalculated. An appeals court in Washington heard arguments in that case Friday, but it has not issued a ruling.

In June, the ITC ruled that Apple violated one of Samsung's patents, a ''standards-essential patent,'' meaning holders are supposed to license them to all companies on ''fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory'' terms.

US courts have ruled that such patents cannot be the basis for import bans. But the ITC, which is an administrative agency and not a court, follows a different standard.

The Obama administration wants the ITC to adhere to the same principles.

Opinion

Editorial

Kashmir unresolved
Updated 30 Sep, 2026

Kashmir unresolved

The just solution lies in India addressing the issue through a trilateral dialogue involving the legitimate representatives of the Kashmiri people and Pakistan.
Water shortage
30 Sep, 2026

Water shortage

THAT the country is entering the Rabi season with an anticipated water shortage of nearly 25pc, the lowest carryover...
Young hearts
30 Sep, 2026

Young hearts

THE observance may have passed, but the message of World Heart Day should not fade with it. The occasion is a useful...
Terror and politics
Updated 29 Sep, 2026

Terror and politics

There is an urgent need to tone down the rhetoric and tackle terrorism as a collective challenge for both the affected provinces and the federation.
Watching the glaciers
29 Sep, 2026

Watching the glaciers

THE latest signs from Pakistan’s mountains are worrying. Suparco says the number of unfrozen glacial lakes it...
Dangerous agenda
29 Sep, 2026

Dangerous agenda

AS the world remains fixated on the US-Iran conflict, elsewhere in the Middle East, Israel is consolidating its grip...