Restore judges or face music: Ex-SCBA chief tells Musharraf

Published
0

LAHORE, March 14: If the new parliament adopts a resolution declaring that the Nov 3 actions are not part of the Constitution, President Musharraf will be left with no option but to have the much-criticised steps validated by a two-thirds majority of the National Assembly and the Senate or face the consequences for violating the basic law, a former president of the Supreme Court Bar Association said here on Friday.

Advocate Akram Sheikh said while talking to Dawn that since the PPP, the PML-N and the Awami National Party had joined hands to form a coalition, there was no possibility of President Musharraf being able to have his admittedly extra-constitutional steps validated. Therefore, he said, the president would have to negotiate a safe exit to escape the consequences of trampling the Constitution.

He said President Musharraf could stay in office only with the support of the parties that had been voted to power. He said if these parties withheld even their tacit support, the edifice of the president would crumble within no time.

In his opinion it would be better for the president to restore the deposed judges before the inaugural session of the National Assembly on March 17 to escape embarrassment. He said the Nov 3 action was taken by Gen Musharraf in his capacity as the army chief which no constitutional functionary was empowered to do.

The verdict of the Feb 18 election was against the extra-constitutional measures taken on Nov 3, Advocate Sheikh said, adding that now the president should bow to the will of the political sovereigns and, by an administrative order, free the detained judges and allow them to perform their judicial duties.

The former SCBA chief said this was an honourable option which would cause the president comparatively less damage and would also avert a collision between the presidency and parliament.

He said in case the parliament adopted a resolution for the reinstatement of the deposed judges, the executive would be duty-bound to enforce it.

As for speculations that a stay order could be obtained against the reinstatement of Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, he said the move did not seem plausible. He hoped that the judiciary would not involve itself in such matters when the parties that had won the polls had no plan to oust the sitting judges. He said these parties had also indicated that they would resolve the issue of subsequent inductees in the judiciary through a process of regularisation as done in the Al-Jihad Trust case.

Opinion

Editorial

Candid admission
Updated 30 Oct, 2026

Candid admission

Both ruling and opposition parties have lost credibility and political ground due to their ongoing vendetta.
Disrupted LPG supply
30 Oct, 2026

Disrupted LPG supply

THE petroleum minister’s explanation in the National Assembly that the recent closure of the Iran border has...
Judicial disaffection
30 Oct, 2026

Judicial disaffection

THE resignation of Justice Mohsin Akhtar Kayani from the Lahore High Court is another indicator of the deepening...
Restructuring plans
Updated 29 Oct, 2026

Restructuring plans

The primary reason for governance failure in Pakistan is not the geographical size of the existing provinces but the reluctance of provincial capitals to empower local bodies.
Polluted priorities
Updated 29 Oct, 2026

Polluted priorities

Enforcement must continue, but decisions should follow evidence, not the visibility of machinery on city roads.
Continuing genocide
29 Oct, 2026

Continuing genocide

FOR the people of Gaza, despite the ‘ceasefire’ reached last October, the genocide never really ceased. This ...