Failed by state and society

Published
2

THERE can be no disagreeing that the young woman from southern Punjab who died yesterday was monumentally failed twice over by state and society.

First, she was unfortunate enough to live in a country where physical safety is low on the list of the state’s priorities, one of the factors which led to her alleged rape on Jan 5.

This form of assault is so grievous, and the topic so taboo in our conservative society that many victims have not been able to muster up the courage to report the crime to even their families, let alone the police.

But this 18-year-old had the resolve to see a case registered against her alleged attackers. The wheels of justice work in strange ways in Pakistan, though, and on Thursday, the main suspect was granted bail by a local court.

That is when she was failed a second time; even then, however, she was determined to fight back within the confines of the law, and went to the Bet Mir Hazar police station to lodge a protest with the investigation officer for having, in his report, apparently favoured the man she accused of raping her. We can only guess at how the encounter played out, but she subsequently doused herself with petrol and set herself alight on the premises. The burns she sustained led to her death yesterday.

Some might argue that rape is a crime of the shadows against which the state has no power. That is entirely incorrect. Every country where allegations of rape are investigated with determination and prosecuted with force has seen its incidence drop.

Pakistan, however, has never made it a priority to make a strong effort to stamp out this horrific crime and to send out a firm signal that rapists will face the full wrath of the law.

And this is because of societal attitudes that create the misogynistic taboos and perverted notions of ‘honour’ that surround sexual crimes. If, in her death, the young lady tells us the story of the legal and law-enforcement systems’ neglect of the crime of rape, so too do those who were witness to her desperate act but made no apparent attempt to stop her.

Opinion

Editorial

State of confusion
Updated 05 Aug, 2026

State of confusion

FROM the looks of it, America has no exit strategy to extricate itself from the disastrous war with Iran. US...
Pension decision
05 Aug, 2026

Pension decision

THE government’s decision to formally operationalise the new Defined Contribution Pension Fund Scheme is a step...
Preventable deaths
05 Aug, 2026

Preventable deaths

THE deaths of 144 children from measles and diphtheria in Karachi during the first seven months of the year expose a...
Swat bombing
Updated 04 Aug, 2026

Swat bombing

IT is a bitter irony that terrorists struck a protest against violence in Swat on Sunday, causing at least 17...
Tariff blow
04 Aug, 2026

Tariff blow

FOR an export sector already squeezed by high production costs, the additional 10pc tariff on top of the existing...
Perilous peaks
04 Aug, 2026

Perilous peaks

THE deaths of 10 climbers in an avalanche on Broad Peak is a sad reminder of the perils that many mountaineers face...