19 September, 2014 / Ziqa'ad 23, 1435

Shifting stories

Published Sep 15, 2013 08:31am

ONE useful aspect of a grand old house in Europe or America was the weathervane. Stuck at the apex, it did not look very elegant, but its value was not measured by aesthetics. It gauged the direction of the wind in an age when nature had far more control over human affairs.

The British built the grand imperial cities of Kolkata, Madras, Mumbai, and, in the 20th century, New Delhi. But there were no weathervanes, possibly because nature is more predictable in India. When it rains it pours. When storms arrive, dark clouds swirl across the sky as advance battle formations.

Delhi is not London, where you can perspire as you leave home, get caught in a chilly shower and return with a cold.

But what Delhi has lost in external sensors, it more than compensates through internal aerials. Human nature is the worry in Delhi, not nature. In that special patch of the capital which provides temporary housing to the various castes of the ruling class, every ear has a powerful antenna, constantly fine-tuned to pick up the waft and flow of that dramatic phenomenon called the political wind.

Delhi’s layers of power brokers have not survived the rise and fall of empires without an acute sense of homage to those on the ascendant, even when the possible has not become probable, let alone factual. A historian would do well to record how conversation has changed over the last five years in India’s august capital.

In 2009, Delhi could talk of nothing else but how Congress, and its presiding Gandhi family, would rule India for the next 20 years at the very least. It was up to Rahul Gandhi to decide when he wanted to become prime minister, a view echoed formally by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh at a famous press conference that year.

There was much admiration, in rotund phrases, for Rahul Gandhi’s choice of a waiting room as his preferred abode. A mild unease about corruption by the winter of 2010 did not much change the narrative; Rahul Gandhi’s team continued to be feted at dinners and wooed as high officials of the next durbar.

Then came Anna Hazare, with Baba Ramdev in tow. Heads wagged solemnly, but the wise had seen it all. This was one of those periodic blips that must inevitably interrupt a majestic procession. It would disappear, said all the ministers deputed to swat the fly, as quickly as it had come. Had no one heard about public memory? It was short, short, short. The smiles remained wide.

Then came the shock of UP elections in 2012. The script said Congress would declare victory if it won 80 seats (a number picked up from expensive opinion polls), and this would become the arch through which Rahul Gandhi could walk towards the prime minister’s chair. Defeat introduced the first shades of doubt.

Narendra Modi’s re-election in Gujarat later that year began to change the scenario. Paradoxically, Modi aroused both apprehension and hope. His political skills and governance record were powerful assets; could Congress turn the Gujarat riots into a polarising negative? And so hundreds of opinion pieces and news stories flooded the media, suggesting that the Bharatiya Janata Party would defeat itself if it chose Modi as its mascot.

The BJP, however, heard the voice of its cadre, which lived on the street rather than in Delhi’s warrens. Now that he is the party nominee for prime minister, to visible enthusiasm, Modi has one important thing left to worry about. So far he was surrounded only by supporters. Now he will be pursued by sycophants. That can be dangerous in a game where there continues to be many a slip between cup and lip.

Delhi is worried about Modi not because of his party, but because he is an outsider, shorn of the English-induced cultural or academic sophistications that Delhi’s elites expect from anyone audacious enough to demand their services. Modi served tea to customers in his brother’s teashop and his family remains linked to its roots.

His English is unlikely to impress the Queen of England. But most of all, Delhi is anxious about his reputation for being tough. Delhi deals in compromise, not accountability, and no one really wants a bull rampaging through the expensive china that elites have accumulated over so many decades.

Delhi has handled outsiders before, at different levels of power. But they have mostly done Delhi the favour of proving incompetent.

Lal Bahadur Shastri was the one outsider who could have changed the dynamic of this city, but he did not live long enough, and may have been scarred by the Tashkent agreement with Pakistan by then. So Delhi will resist Modi with one face, the private one, and beam with its other, public face.

It is going to be a fascinating face-off for the six months left before elections.

The writer is an author and editorial director of The Sunday Guardian, published from Delhi.


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Floods of misery

A disaster of epic proportions is unfolding for the 325 million people that will inhabit Pakistan by 2050.

Dear Islamabad, sorry

There have been routine packages sent to the capital and they have mostly been received well.

Comments (10) (Closed)


BISWAJIT ROY
Sep 15, 2013 10:28am

"His English is unlikely to impress the Queen of England"-- This is regretteble that a renowned journalist gives so much importnace to english speaking skills...that illiterate guy Modi is being praised by European union , british MPs and German diplomats not because for his english speaking skills but because of his extra ordinary achievements...See chinese president japansee president frence and german president choose speak in theier native language in international forum...only leaders from slave nations like India choose to speak their colonial heritage language .

dr vimal raina
Sep 15, 2013 12:46pm

Sir you are right...next six months 'maza aayega'.

Utkarsh
Sep 15, 2013 12:50pm

I love the way you've used Delhi as a character, a snooty snob, which is frankly how my family sees the Congress rather than the bureaucracy, which is what I think you were ascribing that aspect to. I would like Modi to be the PM if only for his charisma and the hope for development he brings. I just hope he manages to rein in some of BJP's friends I absolutely hate, like the VHP, and prevent people like Sushma Swaraj from imposing their stupid moral values over the rest of us. This is a secular nation, and I think Modi believes in secularism too, because I have never heard him talk of religion in his speeches ever. These days even Indians have become disillusioned by secularism and have forgotten what it really means. I just hope if Modi comes to power he bolsters India's secularism and tolerance and proves his detractors wrong. (I'll have left India next year, because I have lost all hope with the nation and its future, but I still want things to get better. It's not that India is getting worse, but that it's getting better at such a slow pace that I lack the patience to deal with.)

Onkar Sharma
Sep 15, 2013 12:50pm

A wonderful article by MJ Akbar. He is doctor who can predict the disease without touching the pulse. I look forward to reading his article in the Dawn every Sunday.

Sandeep Singh
Sep 15, 2013 04:34pm

NaMo will speak in Hindi and so will all the bureaucrats.

Sanjay Mittal
Sep 15, 2013 07:10pm

MJ Akbar I salute you. Again! Perfect diagnosis.

We need to break away from dynastic succession and whatever happens we must do that.

Friendly Neighbor
Sep 15, 2013 10:31pm

Very good article. Changed my impression of Dawn. Keep it up.

Pankaj
Sep 16, 2013 02:08am

Best of all the assessments, I read or heard about Modi, till date. Thanks....

Anand; India
Sep 16, 2013 03:48am

@Sandeep Singh:

And he will eat Dhokla, and so will all the bureaucrats. Right.

Anand; India
Sep 16, 2013 03:50am

@BISWAJIT ROY: Can please list those 'extra ordinary achievements' for the benefit of the readers; in QUANTITIVE terms.