US keeping Al Qaeda men in inhuman conditions

Published
0

WASHINGTON, Jan 15: There has been little media coverage of the conditions in which Al Qaeda/Taliban prisoners flown by the United States from Kandahar to the naval base at Guantanamo, Cuba, are being kept, but the New York-based Human Rights Watch has now joined Amnesty International in drawing attention to the prisoners’ confinement.

About 50 of them are now at the camp, and they have reportedly been put in unsheltered cages with tin roofs. The cages are surrounded by several perimeters of chain-link and razor wires for maximum security.

The cages, according to the World Socialist Website, have no walls and the prisoners are, thus, exposed to the climate.

Kenneth Roth of Human Rights Watch said during a television programme on Monday the prisoners were being kept in conditions that were clearly inhumane. He agreed that the detainees were dangerous men, but stressed that foreign prisoners must be treated in the same way as the US would expect American prisoners to be treated.

The London-based Amnesty International last week also criticised the hooding and chaining of the prisoners as they were being moved from their places of detention to Kandahar airport. The American Muslim Council has protested against the shaving off of the beards of the detainees. The authorities at Guantanamo say the prisoners have had their hair and beards shaved to prevent lice infestation.

The US argues that the prisoners are illegal combatants and calls them detainees instead of prisoners of war. The Geneva Convention on the treatment of PoWs provides no real guidelines on how “illegal combatants” (that is, those not in uniform of an established army) should be treated, but Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld

has said every effort will be made to follow international regulations. The US has also said it is willing for human rights organizations to visit the Guantanamo facility.

More prisoners are to be moved to the base from Kandahar, where some 500 men are now believed to be in US custody. There is no information here yet about Pakistanis among the prisoners at Kandahar or Guantanamo. A British citizen is reported to be at Guantanamo, and British consular officials are said to have been informed about him.

The World Socialist Website has speculated that Guantanamo has been chosen as a secure location because if the prisoners were kept on US soil, there might have been legal challenges to their confinement.

Opinion

Editorial

Farewell to arms?
Updated 03 Aug, 2026

Farewell to arms?

PALESTINIAN resistance group Hamas recently made a major concession by agreeing to give up its weapons. It should be...
Unplanned future
03 Aug, 2026

Unplanned future

A PROJECTION that Pakistan’s population could reach 400m by 2040 should not be treated as another dramatic number...
No more torture
03 Aug, 2026

No more torture

EVEN the best laws on the books are worth little unless the state shows the willingness to enforce them. This is...
Urban flooding
Updated 02 Aug, 2026

Urban flooding

THE warning from the disaster management and weather authorities that a new monsoon spell could trigger urban...
Fatal workplaces
02 Aug, 2026

Fatal workplaces

THE methane explosion near Quetta that killed 34 coal miners is the latest entry in Pakistan’s long register of...
Dual standards
02 Aug, 2026

Dual standards

IT appears that the Pakhtunkhwa Milli Awami Party has fallen foul of the Election Commission of Pakistan. A...