Indians lampoon govt over rise in traffic fines

Published September 6, 2019
A traffic police officer uses a device to fine a driver for breaking traffic rules in Mumbai on September 5. — Reuters
A traffic police officer uses a device to fine a driver for breaking traffic rules in Mumbai on September 5. — Reuters

BENGALURU: Many Indians have ridiculed a sharp increase in traffic fines this week, lampooning the poor state of roads and joking that the revenue from the fines would soon exceed that from taxes.

The government hopes to bring order to India’s often chaotic roads with a tenfold increase in fines for more serious offences to between 5,000 rupees ($70) and 100,000 rupees ($1,400).

The new fines went into effect on Sunday. They come as economic growth has slumped to a six-year low, and government data shows a slowdown in the growth of goods and services tax (GST) collections, raising the prospect that Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government will miss its fiscal deficit target this year.

“If the traffic police and government became half efficient in collecting fines for traffic violations, it will easily cross the GST and IT (income tax) collections,” said one Twitter user.

Another Twitter user joked: “At this rate Govt. can abolish GST & concentrate on traffic fines.” Media reported a tractor driver in Gurugram — near the capital, New Delhi — had to cough up 59,000 rupees ($820) in fines for 10 violations, while a rickshaw driver separately was hit with fines that were nearly twice the cost of his vehicle.

“India’s fiscal deficit will soon turn into a fiscal surplus,” said another Twitter user, referring to the rate at which the government was raking in traffic fines.

The size of the fines is particularly concerning in a country where the per capita monthly income is only 10,500 rupees ($147).

But officials say the heavy fines are needed to improve safety in a country where more than 100,000 people are killed and nearly 500,000 injured every year in road accidents.“Shouldn’t people’s lives be saved? There should be respect for the law,” Nitin Gadkari, minister for road transport and highways, told the ANI news agency.

People also posted pictures of huge potholes and asked what his department was doing to fix them. An artist had his video go viral after he dressed up as an astronaut and pretended to moonwalk across potholed roads in the tech hub of Bengaluru.

Published in Dawn, September 6th, 2019

Editorial

Environment deficit
05 Jun, 2026

Environment deficit

WORLD Environment Day arrives as the planet edges deeper into climatic uncertainty. New global temperature records...
Rights concerns
05 Jun, 2026

Rights concerns

TWO recent news reports have highlighted foreign concerns about the state of human and labour rights in the country....
Patient care crisis
05 Jun, 2026

Patient care crisis

HEALTHCARE in Pakistan is a footnote. Claims by successive governments to introduce vast reforms with huge schemes...
Budget delay
Updated 04 Jun, 2026

Budget delay

With economic stabilisation yet to translate into tangible improvement in living standards, the country’s leaders are finding it increasingly difficult to ignore demands for relief.
Absentee lawmakers
04 Jun, 2026

Absentee lawmakers

TWENTY per cent. That is the percentage of lawmakers whose commitment to their vocation is reflected in the time ...
Deliberate provocations
Updated 04 Jun, 2026

Deliberate provocations

THE latest events at Al-Aqsa Mosque reflect the growing impunity with which extremist Israeli settlers operate. ...