THE confusion of those absorbing Finance Minister Hafeez Sheikh’s comments on the planned tax amnesty for the 3.8 million potential tax dodgers with undeclared assets here and abroad is perfectly understandable. He is being ambiguous, perhaps intentionally. He says such proposals are meant for netting those with large amounts of black money to hide. But he reminds everyone that it is not yet ‘government policy’ (because it requires presidential approval). He doesn’t say that it will not become government policy and so it may be safe to assume that the proposal remains on the table. Apparently, the minister favours the amnesty and wants the Federal Board of Revenue to shift its focus to those with large amounts of black money. He has chosen to be ambiguous in his comments possibly because of objections raised by visiting IMF officials.

When the PPP government came up with its first tax amnesty scheme in 2008, it promised not to reward dodgers. It has failed to keep its word. Only a few months ago, it announced a reprieve for stock investors to provide a fresh trigger to investment in shares for boosting capital markets. The amnesty is being touted by the FBR as the last opportunity for tax dodgers to come clean. Still, chances of tax evaders availing of the scheme are as slim as that of government action against them. After all, they already have legislation in place guaranteeing tax exemption for money brought into Pakistan through normal banking channels as remittances. This legislation gives tax evaders enough space to whiten their untaxed money. They pay a small commission to a money-exchange dealer and get remittances in their names. It is hugely frustrating to see the state rewarding those who cheat the government with the help of a corrupt tax machinery.

Media reports suggest the FBR is pushing the proposal as a one-time effort to generate additional revenues to meet the tax target for the current fiscal. However, the scheme is unlikely to help the FBR rake in significant amounts of tax. The 2008 amnesty had yielded just about Rs2.5bn. India has had more than 14 disclosure schemes but the response has been far from encouraging and the ‘parallel’ economy continues to thrive there. Shouldn’t we learn from the Indian experience if not from our own? A better way would be to deal sternly with tax dodgers whom the government intends to help in laundering their illegal wealth. The FBR claims to have all the required information about them. If it must reward someone, it should reward honest taxpayers and not tax evaders.

More From This Section

More than money needed

IF it weren’t for the history and the present context, it would have been a grand announcement. Balochistan, Prime...

Measuring poverty

POLITICALLY, poverty has been a sensitive issue in Pakistan, as it has been in many other developing countries. It ...

Lure of the blue passport

PASSPORT and visa issues continue to occupy our leaders. The latest evidence of this came on Friday when members of...

Yet another chance

WITH the government determined to have a dialogue with the TTP come what may, the rest of the stakeholders have...


Comments are closed.

Comments (5)

BNS
October 3, 2012 9:50 pm
If CBR knows who does not pay taxes, and knows approx. what amount is cocealed, what stops it to approach the tax dodgers and bring them in a court of law?
Cyrus Howell
October 4, 2012 12:15 am
When will too much corruption be too much?
raika45
October 3, 2012 1:42 pm
Do you have an anti corruption agency?If so how effective or independent is it? Do you have a central bank that vets money sent overseas in large amounts? Do you have a strict check at ALL your exit points looking for those taking cash out of the country? The most important.Do you have a check of your people working overseas who hand money to agents there who then get their men in Pakistan to send rupees to the beneficiories, while the foreign cash the agents get is stashed overseas.For this you need dedicated and honest people to take action.Do you have them? The irony is that these law breakers claim to be true Muslims and pray 5 times a day.
jalaluddin S. Hussain
October 3, 2012 4:19 pm
I fully agree. The tax dodgers must be be brought to tax net, but very discreetly.
Iftikhar Husain
October 3, 2012 11:07 am
I fully support the the contents of the editorial. The government has knowledge of the tax dodgers but keep it a secret from the people for the reasons the government knows. The tax dodgers must be brought to tax net for the betterment of the country.
Explore: Indian elections 2014
Explore: Indian elections 2014
How much do you know about Indian Elections?
How much do you know about Indian Elections?
Cartoons
E-PAPER
Front Page