THE Federal Board of Revenue’s proposed tax amnesty scheme to lure 3.8 million tax thieves into declaring their ‘hidden’ wealth at home and abroad is unlikely to produce the intended results. Slated to be launched next month, it doesn’t appear to be the right route to increasing revenues and expanding the tax base. If the past is anything to go by, the scheme can at best allow tax dodgers to launder their ill-gotten assets by paying a nominal tax on their value at an official gain of a few million rupees. The government is living off heavy bank loans and foreign dole, but the cost that will go into raising such a meagre amount for the economy will be formidable. As is usual, the opportunity will tempt more people, including many honest taxpayers, to cheat the government in the hope of availing another amnesty a few years down the road. This is not how governments can or should increase their revenues. The proposal only indicates a lack of political will to take tough decisions. A government that dithered on its commitment to implement value added tax for fear of a political backlash hardly inspires confidence about its ability to document the economy to boost the tax-to-GDP ratio of less than 10 per cent, the lowest in the region.

The FBR proposal is reflective of the unwillingness of the tax collectors to bring to justice those who avoid paying taxes. Against tall claims by successive heads of the board, the number of people filing tax returns has dropped sharply and more than two-thirds of the government revenue is generated from inflationary, indirect taxes. In the budget for the last fiscal, the government had promised to bring 700,000 wealthy people into the net. More than a year later, the scheme has fizzled out. To improve its revenue collection, the government will have to tax all incomes irrespective of source and revamp tax administration. Amnesty and whitening schemes will only further entrench the culture of tax evasion in the country.

More From This Section

Too much for too little

THERE is no deadlock, Interior Minister Nisar Ali Khan had told the country regarding talks with the outlawed TTP....

The name of the game

WHAT’S in a name? A lot, it turns out, at least in the case of a proscribed organisation that wants to participate...

Roles reversed

THE story has been repeated ad nauseam over the decades, but is still a favourite with many Pakistanis who bemoan...

Life without dignity

CAN a family survive with dignity on the minimum wage of an unskilled worker, asked the Supreme Court on Monday in...

Comments are closed.

Comments (5)

Iftikhar Husain
September 28, 2012 11:20 am
Tax collection must start from top rich people because they can afford to pay. I agree with the contents of the editorial.
Mateen Asif
September 28, 2012 6:07 am
It will only benefit black sheep, and the intended results would never be achieved, Agreeing to the content of editorial, the plans gonna backfire.
September 28, 2012 6:03 am
I strongly endorse the views of the Editor. undoubtedly such amnesty which encourage and induce all those who are already searching for such loops in our tax system to avoid tax. Further, unflinching stand of Government should be to pursue such tax evader with iron-hand, with no such sign of weakness. This weakness will not encourage such tax evaders but also frustrates all tax-payers.
September 28, 2012 3:49 am
Spot on!
September 29, 2012 2:41 am
About 30 years ago,when tax rates were very high in India....the tax authorities followed almost the same route of did not work. Around a decade ago,India introduced something called PAN ID ..permanent account number on photo ID card.Any big transaction requires the show of this ID card.Along with lowering of tax rates the enforcement of the use of the ID card has brought down tax evasion to a large extent. Direct taxes in India fetch a lot more than Indirect Taxes. Wonder why Pakistan,a country which is based on "Islamic values" which according to believers has not match in the world should have such a large tax dodging population and the country is dependent on US aid to bankroll the expenses of running a state and a country?
Explore: Indian elections 2014
Explore: Indian elections 2014
How much do you know about Indian Elections?
How much do you know about Indian Elections?
Front Page