Karachi 'world's cheapest city' yet again: report
102
A report featured on the BBC this week revealed that the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) has recognised Karachi as the cheapest city in the world. It was awarded the same title last year by the EIU during its annual survey on the worldwide cost of living.
The survey took into account the cost of living in 133 cities worldwide using New York City as the base. A basket of more than 160 goods and services was compared, including utilities, clothing and food prices.
Also read: Karachi: a hard city
The low cost of living in Karachi could be attributed to the decrease in the inflation rate in Pakistan’s largest city over the past year.
The State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) Inflation Monitor showed that the year-on-year inflation rate in Karachi was 7.6% in January 2014 and consisted of 10.6% food inflation and 5.4% non-food inflation.
In January 2015, the year-on-year inflation rate in Karachi had dropped to 4.5%, comprising 1.2% food inflation and 7.1% non-food inflation.
SBP Governor Ashraf Mahmood Wathra had described the fall in inflation as broad-based and was quoted saying:
“The deceleration in [food inflation] is mainly the result of better supply conditions while [non-food inflation] is explained by a combination of factors, including plummeting international oil price as well as decline in other global commodity prices; lagged impact of earlier conservative monetary policy stance and moderating aggregate demand; and stable exchange rate,” he added.
Also read: State Bank revises inflation target for fy15
Bangalore, Caracas, Mumbai and Chennai are also among the five cheapest cities on the EIU list.
The five most expensive cities in the world remained unchanged this year, with Singapore topping the list. It was followed by Paris, Oslo, Zurich and Sydney.
Read more
On DawnNews
Comments (102) Closed
Mar 03, 2015 02:26pm
"Life is cheap here"
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:28pm
Bangalore is no way inexpensive
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:33pm
I think their basis of comparison would be converting rupee to dollar and since rupee has fallen so much down that 500 Rupee is equal to 5 dollar. In Pakistan a person can have a good meal in a reasonable restaurant for 150 which is 1.4 dollars. When you look at it that way then its definitely cheap.
But when considering that on average 50% of Pakistani earn around 10000 Rs (96$) per month then its definitely not cheap, infact its very very hard for the poor people in Pakistan who incidently also are the majority.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:36pm
Not only cheapest city , it is the most dangerous city for living. Two crowns at a time. Hero and villian, double role for Karachi
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:38pm
people get killed in mere 500 hundred only
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:39pm
Cheapest to get killed, but expensive to find a burrial . . .
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:42pm
I dont know how they reach these figures. If you just compare the prices of everyday-use food items with the prices of last 2-3 years, you would know at what rate they have increased.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:45pm
Karachi is still the most poor friendly city in the world despite the unabated rule of all sorts of Mafias and terrorists
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:51pm
I don't know Sheesha prices in Karachi hiked sky rocketing since last year. The fruit has not yet reached to me.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:53pm
Well done Karachi.my favorite city in the world.that includes Paris/London/Istanbul/Dubai/Cardiff.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:53pm
Of course it's the cheapest city in the world!
How can you not get that title when a Full tank of Petrol costs the same as a person's life?
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:54pm
I Love you Karachi.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 02:59pm
Had it been said that Karachi is the most expensive city, every one of us would have immediately accepted it and would have started our funny criticism. Just because of something negative about Pakistan which we like to hear mostly..
Praise of Pakistan can not be tolerated not only by India or Bangladesh but by ourselves also. Non-patriotism, and that is our problem.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 03:05pm
Chandigarh: A plate of Bhature and Channa with tea cost Rs 118/- in a plush 5 star restaurant. Beat that.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 03:08pm
Wrong report for sure.. because Bangalore & Chennai is most costly & expensive city, Kolkata is the cheapest city in India..
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 03:22pm
When a naan roti costs Rs10/- while thousands of tons of wheat rots in storage, its hard to reconcile with statements such as this.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 03:22pm
Bangalore,Mumbai are no way cheap ...cheapest city in the world is Kolkata ..I can bet anything for that ...
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 03:25pm
Cheap does not mean quality of products is not good , infact it is world class.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 03:39pm
Bangalore - Cheap !!!! You must be joking !!!
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 03:42pm
Moosa, you cannot imagine how much teh prices have changed in other cities in the world compared to Karachi. In some cities more than 200-300% percent.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 03:44pm
bangalore is definitely no inexpensive, its one of the expensive ones in India.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 03:47pm
My Karachi! May Allah Bless this City.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:09pm
why so much negativity? I think its a proud thing for Pakistani people you should appreciate good thing of your country. As a resident of Delhi i would be more than happy if it was my city.
Congratulation for Pakistani Friends.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:15pm
Utter non-sense. Direct comparisons of cost are meaningless. What matters is how long it takes to earn enough to pay for any product or service. Suppose you earned Rs. 25000 per month. (Let us say the same job pays $15/hr in US)
One visit to Agha Khan Hosp. 2.0 days wages same in US 4 hours wages
Average 3 bed room home 16 years of wages same in US 3-4 years of wages.
4 litres of milk 1/2 days of wages same in US about 20 min of wages
grocery for a month for a family of 4 about 15 days wages same in US 3-4 days of wages. These numbers are based on single bread winner in the family.
Every commodity in Pakistan cost about or slightly less than the international price of that commodity except it is substantially inferior in quality.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:18pm
Karachi Most badly treated city in the world. but still thriving , and growing, Proud to be a Karachiites,
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:19pm
Yes its a ghareeb parwar city....Luv you Karachi...
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:24pm
I don't know on which basis they said Karachi the cheapest... But as compared to western cities it is cheapest. However, lahore is i think Pakistan's most expensive city. Expensive property, expensive malls, clothing, food etc
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:26pm
hahha is that a good news?? and cheap city for what exactly? umm let me guess, to have some one killed on contract basis, or get IED planted oh now u guess lots of others stuff too except quality life
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:27pm
@Dipak Singh Bro indian cities are cheaper not as in single. They are cheaper when we compare them to the highly developed cities like Newyork, London, Paris etc. I think its easy to buy a home in Indian cities rather than having a flat in London or so. Currency also make a huge difference..
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:28pm
@Nauman M A cup of tea price: 700 in PC Karachi... Beat that
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:32pm
Yeah, heard even Human lives have no value there...
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:35pm
Karachi being the mega-city in one of the world's poorest countries, must have this dubious honor of being the cheapest city when compared with New York as the yard-stick. But, within Pakistan, there are many cities much more cheaper but not qualified to be included in the survey.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:39pm
Karachi, bangalore, Chennai and Mumbai, cheap!!!!!!!!! How could be it, may be cheaper when compared to pay scales of New York
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:39pm
Karachi is also home to beautiful sindhi pashto girls.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:45pm
Calcutta, capital of West Bengal Province, is the cheapest city in India, where Rs. 30. expenses for dinner (with rice, fish, vegetable).
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:49pm
Bangalore and cheap. This is a utter nonsense report. Kolkata is the cheapest city among metropolitans.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 04:52pm
can someone post how much an average 2 br apartment costs and what is the average salary of an educated person's salary is?
a teacher earns 2 lacs in a year and it takes 25 years to buy such a house in a place like cochin. in boston with 60k salary it takes only 5 years to earn such a house. i would like to hear how much in karachi and other pakistani or indian cities
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 05:02pm
I have never seen such blatant abuse of statistics. Prices without reference to earnings is meaningless. I was born in Karachi and have lived here and in Houston, TX for many years within the last decade. Minimum wage in Texas is $6/hr. for a 40 hr work week that is $240. Is the minimum wage in Karachi equal to or more than Rs. 24000 per week. Now tell me what is cheaper.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 05:06pm
Average per capita income of a US citizen is $ 49,800/= which compares to $ 3,100 of Pakistan. A one sixteenth of the US. Now divide the cost of every item of expenditure for living in New York by 16 and compare it with Karachi for the same item to see where actually we stand. Lemons and grapefruits cannot be counted together as same.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 05:06pm
Mumbai also rated as bottom 5 cheap cities. Well ! why isn't my pocket also feeling the same. Can we have a similar report comparing earning and salaries in these cities ? I'm sure these cities will again be at the bottom and with a wider difference.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 05:09pm
Not if you take into account the earning power of average residents of the city. Their method of comparison is flawed.
Yes very cheap in the sense of value of life !
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 05:33pm
to add to my earler post,
an unskilled laborer earns 350 rupees. it costs 150 rupees for a meal. so little more than two meals a day. in Massachusetts the minimum wage is 10 dollars per hour with which he or she can buy two mcd.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 05:42pm
@MHamza
Oh.. are you comparing Karachi with London Newyork Paris?? lolz.. you made my day.. :)
Kolkata is a Mega City of India, Si, I comparing Kolkata with Bangalore Chennai Mumbai & delhi.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 05:53pm
With dilapidated infrastructure and poor law and order conditions, the "cheapness" of the city falls in the face of its residents...
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 06:07pm
@Parvez bhai 10 is pretty reasonable I think.Here in Hyderabad India a Nan will cost around 50-60 Pakistani Rupee
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 06:09pm
@sharabi yes ...its really good for people especially the poor class.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 06:18pm
this so called "economist intelligence unit EIU" is stupid. Karachi in no way shape or form "cheap" when all factors are considered. Sure, if you are speaking with foreign currency in your pocket then its cheap. If you are comparing apples to apples then it is expensive!
yeah sure if you are using New York City as the base of your study then of course Karachi is cheap.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 06:27pm
@Syed Hussain Akbari : Foolish praise is far worse then genuine criticism.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 06:37pm
cheapest in every sense....Compromise is the best and cheapest if that is how we intend to live.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 06:54pm
Here is the prices of different roti in india, compare them with pakistani prices you will know
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 07:05pm
@Nauman M courtesy of Edhi and Chippa , Channa is free twice a day near most road intersections
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 07:16pm
Cheap is not good. Poor people make city cheap and Ugly and Rich make city expensive and beautiful. So I m not proud of this distinguish.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 07:31pm
@Mohammad Iqbal - While Karachi is a (very) dangerous city, there are a number of cities around the world much more dangerous, statistically Mexico City has the most people murdered each year, equally Jo-burg in South Africa. There is enough dumbing down of Pakistan/Karachi by the western media - lets not unnecessarily add to it.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 07:33pm
I have been to most cities of world and out of experience says that Pakistan is definitely the most cheapest country of world while Karachi should bed number 1.Pakistan is great
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 07:44pm
I am born and live in Bangalore. And, personally, I do not acknowledge Bangalore as one of the cheapest to live. It may be compared to New York, but as per the general standard of our living, it is costly.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 07:54pm
I find it out of context & misleading article that manages to get onto Dawn's homepage.. Karachi maybe cheapest for expats relocating there but not for Karachi walas unless they get paid in US$
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 08:18pm
How can it be the cheapest city, when even the beggars don't accept less than 20 rupees.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 08:58pm
Where is this Cheapest Karachi? Not the one I know.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 09:12pm
My father told me that Karachi was an awesome place to live back in the 60's and 50's. Then a wave came where educated and well settled immigrants from India started their second migration to either England, or Saudi Arabia, or Canada or US. That is when things started to get worse. I guess those wise people who were pretty educated and well settled in India knew how the world was operating and knew what will happen to Pakistan that is why they decided to migrate and now they are well settled abroad. Pretty sad story for Pakistan though. I am not sure if memons are still running the businesses in Karachi or not but they are the last hope for Karachi.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 09:18pm
I live in Bangalore (20+ years) and San Francisco (7+ years as a resident and travel there almost every year). I think food in a similar type restaurant in Bangalore is same or more expensive than San Francisco. Same thing goes for 3 star and above hotels. Both these are in real $ to Rs term. So in terms of PPP, Bangalore would be more expensive. But you could get food much cheaper in Bangalore if you went to local smaller (but decent) restaurants - probably same price as McDonald / Burger king in US. House prices in Bangalore is exorbitant, office space is even more (in my last job with a major US IT giant, we moved a lab space from Bangalore to US East coast because east coast was much cheaper).
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 09:36pm
Life might come cheap here but it is also a city where nobody sleeps hungry! Karachi will rise.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 09:56pm
@Syed Hussain Akbari: Non-patriotism is our problem??? WOW you've clearly never been in the same room as a south indian and a north indian
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 10:00pm
@Dipak Singh: Just want to let you know how big Karachi is...it's Seven times...thats 7 times...the size of bombay
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 10:17pm
In most cities in Afganistan,Iraq,Iran all you require is a gun.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 11:16pm
@OOps...
I hope you are being sarcastic. The article is about “Karachi world's cheapest city” and not Life is cheap in Karachi.
Recommend
0
Mar 03, 2015 11:49pm
cheap life doesn't necessarily mean good life. They need to take into account the quality of life like emergency services, food quality, law enforcement etc. I wouldn't be surprised if karachi dominates the bottom of that list.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 12:00am
@Dipak Singh come on nobody is talking about India or Pakistan it is about the
cheapest city.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 12:08am
@OOPS
I concur with you...
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 12:08am
Karachi karachi hai yar
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 12:53am
Once the security situation gets better, tourists will start coming back to this beautiful city with beaches and quality food. I love Karachi, the city I was born in.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 12:58am
@Robbing Hoods The ruining of Karachi started when Afghan refugees starting coming. I am sorry, I may be biased but this is the fact. Ask any Karachites.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 02:20am
I LOVE Karachi.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 04:16am
Study may be purely look at the numbers but if the do a cost of living and earning potential results might be different.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 04:23am
I also think the tittle is little ambiguous as cheap mean "lowest cost of living" in major metropolitan cities around the world. But certainly not best in terms of earning so it balance the low cost with low income. Also low cost is in comparison of other cities which also doesn't mean people living there have means to buy everything.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 04:42am
Salam u all
May Allah bless this city and ofcourse our whole country from all sorts of evil and sick minded people who try to destroy the beauty of karachi culture ...
I LOVE U KARACHI ....
KINDLY KEEP PRAYING FOR THE BETTERMENT IF THIS CITY
WE DO MISS the old days but
INSHALLAH INSHALLAH
good times will come soon.
I LOVE U KARACHI...
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 06:04am
I don't know how they came up with this. I recently moved to Australia and the prices of daily use items after conversion with dollar are pretty much same. The only change is the income of people in Karachi is very low as compared to the expenses. And yes face the reality people, life is cheap in Karachi sadly.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 06:08am
@vNu
boston it would take 50 years....it is the most expensive city in USA
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 06:36am
@luv karachi "Karachi is also home to beautiful sindhi pashto girls."
In a discussion about cost of living in Karachi, where do girls come in to the picture?
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 06:41am
@vNu "can someone post how much an average 2 br apartment costs and what is the average salary of an educated person's salary is? a teacher earns 2 lacs in a year and it takes 25 years to buy such a house in a place like cochin. in boston with 60k salary it takes only 5 years to earn such a house. i would like to hear how much in karachi and other pakistani or indian cities"
Apples to apples comparison only if you are talking about buying house outright. Most people in US buy house on loan which takes 15-30 yrs to pay off depending on the type of mortgage, cost of house and income.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 08:13am
@Mohammad Iqbal Karachi is a city of 20 million people. In any world statistics for dangerous cities it does not even show up. Check the murder rate and violence in South American or South African cities to have an idea what real violence is. With TTP and drug mafia on the run some troubled slum areas in the city will also soon become peaceful.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 08:32am
@Nadeem Are they? Thanks for that useful information
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 09:00am
Instead of this unrelenting blah, blah, blah; let us do something useful for a change.
Let us try to normalize the cost of living with income.
It should be that hard, is it?
Let us start with makaan, roti and kapda. tweek a bit with the essential expense relating to education, healthcare and transportation. convert all measures into hourly income instead of dollars or rupees.
I can do the number crunching if all of you can post,
- cost of a 2 br apartment or a reasonable house
- daily expense for food if one has to eat in an average restaurant
- kapda for a year
- expense for a graduate program
- transportation expense
- health insurance for a year
and the minimum wage and average salary.
Come on guys, let us do it.
Let us find where the life is most miserable and where it is comfortable.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 09:03am
Karachi is the most expensive city if one compares the level poverty we have. The inflation rate of 7.6% is too high when one compares 2-3 % for the U.S and some other so called expensive cities. And for poor citezen who consume basic necessities such as food the inflation is 11%, how could that be cheap. Do thay get the raises in their pay as much?
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 09:17am
And I am in Sydney and miss Karachi:(
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 09:43am
No doubt it is cause and effect of lack of law and order, and insecurity which makes it the cheapest, for no one really is willing to invest in this environment. And with poor infrastructure, perpetual traffic jams, polluted air, inadequate mass transport system, over-population,, one can see why it is the cheapest... Only the poor desperate soul would want to live there.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 10:32am
@Syed Akbari - include Sri Lanka too. Why would someone be jealous of such things ? Accept the fact and move on. Karachi is a cheaper place relatively.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 10:54am
@MELBOURNE: And I am in Sydney and miss Karachi:(
Just curious, why don't you move back to Karachi ? Sorry, I'm not being sarcastic, it's a genuine question. I lived in San Francisco for years, but decided to move to Bangalore some 10 years back and think that was my best decision. There are some 10's of thousands people in Bangalore who are US citizens of Indian origin or lived in US for many many years and voluntarily moved back here. You should live where your heart wants.
Recommend
0
Mar 04, 2015 11:07am
It is true that Karachi is poor friendly city, every one can get job there, food prices are acceptable, quality goods are available at reasonable prices and life enjoyble. There is only security problem wchich is almost sovled.
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 01:42am
@Dipak Singh hey man the report is talking of world not India
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 07:15am
Does this include getting someone bopped off ?
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 10:35am
@Nadeem Cardif.......lmao......ahaha
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 11:53am
I find Delhi much more cheaper than Bangalore specially in transport services, although property is bit cheaper in Bangalore than Delhi.
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 12:04pm
I could read so many comments on Karachi.Now I am very anxious to visit this great city. However, I have heard so many good things about this city from some Indians who have migrated to India from this city in1947.Yes,I am very fond of Karachi Halwa which I purchase from Chaina Ram Halwai at Fatehpuri,Chandni Chowk ,Delhi.
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 02:35pm
@Ahmed True but Mumbai's GDP is 3 times bigger than that of Karachi's. Wow that means Mumbai is 21 times richer than Karachi?
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 03:00pm
@apoorva
Depends on where you eat. On the right side of the spectrum, the five star types I mean, it could be much more costlier than Rs 60/- and on the left, you could get it for one fourth of this cost.
We need to talk in absolute terms to get an idea, or if it's a relative one, we need to measure against a reference.
Apart from that, I think it would be better for us to see where our cities are on the livability index which considers all other aspects like infrastructure, job opportunities, law and order, security, affordable medical care, entertainment, sanitation, green spaces, clean air and water etc apart from the cost. The cities in the subcontinent are nowhere near the other ones from the developed world. Our countries should strive to inch up the global scale, rather than living in a small world of our own in comparing subcontinental cities.
A recent report has mentioned Hyderabad(Deccan !) as the best city to live in India by more infrastructure being developed. Before we Hyderabadis became ecstatic, the mood was soberly tempered by the sting that our city ranks 138th on the global index, followed by poorer ranks nearby for other Indian cities. So, while the progress is growing by inches rather than miles, there is a lot to do to catchup with the others globally.
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 04:33pm
Bangalore? i am paying 35000 Indian rupees for a 2BHK apartment in a good colony. Its like almost 55000 Pakistani rupees. And a movie cost 500INR that is like 900 PKR. No way Bangalore is cheap. Chennai, Delhi and Calcutta are cheaper than Bangalore.
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 07:33pm
@J.K.Sharma : Please come here, you will love it....
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 07:52pm
@vNu : Average educated person salary is around RS 30,000. The average apartment in a middle class area starts from Rs 5 million.
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 08:12pm
The cost of living in Pakistani cities are intriguing. I visited this beautiful land at least four provincial capital- cities simultaneously more than once. I found the cost in an average is cheaper than other countries in the region.The 24- hours lively Karachi where I visited five times, I never run for the cheaper items.Because, I knew it for sure, I would get the best and cheapest one.Moreover all over the country, the sellers would add another rebate for us that I named as "Bangladeshi- Beradari."How they smell about my roots, to me an enigma.Still, my wife and children using the shawls which I had bought many years back.During my visit, I tried to find why the city does not sleep also the pulse of the great city.And roamed freely at night by rickshaw.Certainly, I believe, these are not gone with the wind.
Thanks, Dawn for touching such an interesting item of the day.
Recommend
0
Mar 05, 2015 10:14pm
Mumbai is not cheap. Next news story.
Recommend
0
Mar 06, 2015 02:04am
Being abroad Karachi you will always be in my heart.
Recommend
0
Mar 08, 2015 03:34am
How come the Karachi is the Cheapest City and have a Lowest Cost of Living ,if the basic earning of a labor PKRs 6000 to PKRs 8000 per month and the nominal cost of living is PKRs 80,000 to PKRs 120,000 per month of a single household ??
The inflation rate of unemployment is the highest in the Pakistan i.e. 58% where Food and non-food inflation rates are no much matter with the Economy.
Most of the Evaluations of EUI is ambiguous and have no groundless proof for declaring the City ,a lowest cost of living ?
Thank you.
Recommend
0
