THIS is apropos a report in a section of the press about the legal case for dams (Jan 13). Our energy and water problems cannot be resolved through half measures. Whereas there are many options for power generation, it is only dams that can help us overcome the water shortage.

There are only a few sites available for medium dams. No number of small dams can cope with the ever-increasing shortage of water for irrigation, or cater to the 30 million acres of cultivable land lying barren in Pakistan, 80 per cent of it in Sindh, neither can small dams make even a small dent in the annual floods.

Of the mega dams, Dasu and Bunji dams will give us power but no water. The Bhasha dam will take 10 to 12 years to complete and by which time the water crisis will have already been upon us. The Bhasha dam is only half the dam that the Kalabagh dam will be. It will be dependent on snow melt from the glaciers which have a projected life of 30 years. The Siachin glacier is already turning into a lake because of the military presence there.

The Bhasha dam will not utilise the copious flows of Kabul, Chitral, Swat, Kuram, Siren, Haro and Soan rivers, nor will it trap their floodwaters. Being outside the monsoon range, it will not utilise any of the 30 maf of monsoon flows, nor stop the monsoon floods which will keep devastating south Punjab and Sindh every year.

Water from the Bhasha dam or from any other dam on the Indus will not reach north Punjab without the left bank canal at the Kalabagh dam. What will be the future of agriculture in Pakistan if the largest tract of cropland in the country is deprived of water from the Indus?

The tragedy is that the Kalabagh dam is being rejected for the imaginary fear that it will deprive Sindh of water. If the Tarbela dam could give Sindh an additional 7.0maf of water, why would the Kalabagh dam not give another 2.25 maf to Sindh. Sindh, not having the groundwater that Punjab has, needs the Kalabagh dam more than Punjab.

Amanullah Khan
Lahore

Opinion

Editorial

A new war
Updated 01 Mar, 2026

A new war

UNLESS there is an immediate diplomatic breakthrough, the joint Israeli-American aggression against Iran launched on...
Breaking the cycle
01 Mar, 2026

Breaking the cycle

THE confrontation between Pakistan and Afghanistan has taken a dangerous turn. Attacks, retaliatory strikes and the...
Anonymous collections
01 Mar, 2026

Anonymous collections

THE widespread emergence of ‘nameless donation boxes’ soliciting charity in cities and towns across Punjab...
Afghan hostilities
Updated 28 Feb, 2026

Afghan hostilities

The need is for an immediate ceasefire and substantive negotiations, with the onus on the Taliban to rein in cross-border attacks.
Cutting taxes
28 Feb, 2026

Cutting taxes

PRIME Minister Shehbaz Sharif’s plan to cut direct taxes for businesses in the next budget acknowledges the strain...
KCR challenge
28 Feb, 2026

KCR challenge

THE Karachi Circular Railway is being discussed again. It seems that the project, or, rather, the hopes of it, are...