Egypt: Military coup or people's revolution?

Published Jul 31, 2013 03:48pm
Supporters of Egypt's ousted President Mohammed Morsi chant slogans against Egyptian Defense Minister Gen. Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi at Nasr City, where protesters have installed a camp and hold daily rallies, in Cairo, Egypt, Sunday, July 28, 2013. Deadly clashes broke out during funerals of slain supporters of Egypt's ousted Islamist president Sunday, as the supreme leader of the Muslim Brotherhood urged his followers to stand fast after more than 80 of them were killed in weekend violence. (AP Photo/Hassan Ammar)
Supporters of Egypt's ousted President Mohammed Morsi chant slogans against Egyptian Defense Minister Gen. Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi at Nasr City, where protesters have installed a camp and hold daily rallies, in Cairo, Egypt, Sunday, July 28, 2013. Deadly clashes broke out during funerals of slain supporters of Egypt's ousted Islamist president Sunday, as the supreme leader of the Muslim Brotherhood urged his followers to stand fast after more than 80 of them were killed in weekend violence. (AP Photo/Hassan Ammar)
In this Friday, July 26, 2013, photo released on Saturday, July 27, by Egyptian army, opponents of Egypt's ousted President Mohammed Morsi demonstrate at Tahrir Square in Cairo, Egypt.  (AP Photo/Hossam Diab, Egyptian army)
In this Friday, July 26, 2013, photo released on Saturday, July 27, by Egyptian army, opponents of Egypt's ousted President Mohammed Morsi demonstrate at Tahrir Square in Cairo, Egypt. (AP Photo/Hossam Diab, Egyptian army)

A comparison of Egypt just before the 25th January 2011 revolution, and over two years after, shows that a lot has changed. Where liberals and Islamists once chanted for democracy together, protesters now hailed an army chief as a national hero.

After a taste of ‘people power’, many couldn’t be satisfied with whatever Mohammed Morsi had to offer. In Cairo’s affluent Zamalek district, a taxi driver explains that they got rid of an ‘Ali Baba’ – Hosni Mubarak – only to find another one ruling them.

For a lot of people in Egypt, the last three years have been life-changing. Many lost their friends in front of their eyes, saw them maimed in clashes with the police, the armed forces and the Muslim brotherhood; hundreds were arrested on false charges, thousands tried by the military.

Morsi, it seems, wasn’t worth all those sacrifices. Waleed Rashed was one of the co-founders of the April 6 Youth Movement and a prominent participant in anti- Mubarak demonstrations. But while he spoke of the earlier struggle against the dictator with passion, one now sees a clear transformation.

“I left ‘April 6’ for personal reasons; nothing related to the movement, it was related to my business, life style, i always prefer my privacy. The movement was looking for a better life and it means both overthrowing Mubarak and making democracy a reality in Egypt. The future of Egypt is in the power of the people. The military is not in power now in Egypt and I say what happened during the last days in Egypt is not a military coup, there's an interim president Adly Mansour and a presidential election will be held soon.” What one sees is a general acceptance of the ouster of Morsi, as well as of the resurgence of military might (Many see his removal as a military coup).

There are different interpretations, however, of whether the removal of Morsi from power is justified or not. Ahmed Maher, another founder of the April 6 Youth Movement, who is still with the organisation expresses his concern about military involvement. “If we assume it’s not a coup, and I tell people it’s not a coup, when they do to us again what they did in 2011, what would I tell people?” he says.

‘People power’ versus ‘military rule’

The path to where things stands today in Egypt has been a long one. Egyptian revolutionaries didn’t just pour out onto the streets – for many, it was a matter of painstaking strategy and techniques. One institution that helped them strategise was the Centre for Applied Non-Violent Action and Strategies (CANVAS), based in Belgrade, Serbia.

By the end of 2008, one of the April 6 Youth Movement members visited United States to take part in a State Department-organised "Alliance of Youth Movements Summit" in New York City. According to a recently released Wikileaks cable, the activist said he discussed with other activists there techniques to evade government surveillance and harassment. In the summer of 2009, blogger and April 6 activist Mohammed Adel travelled to Serbia to take a course on strategies for nonviolent revolutions from CANVAS.

Srdja Popovic, the co-founder and executive director of CANVAS, doesn’t see the recent development in Egypt as a negative outcome of efforts. In the fall of 2000 Popovic and his colleagues helped to achieve the unthinkable, by forcing the resignation of Slobodan Milosevic. Popovic was recently named among Foreign Policy’s Top 100 Global Thinkers, for "inspiring Arab Spring protestors directly and indirectly.”

CANVAS has trained thousands of activists from all over the world. They have worked directly in 40 countries, and hosted over 200 workshops since 2004. They have also published their material online in open source documents so that people who are unable to attend a workshop may learn on their own.

Speaking on the role of military intervention in Egypt, Popovic says: “People in the military are citizens as well, and there has to be a moment of conversion where we pull at their identity not as a military force against the people, but part of them. From the point of “pillars of support”, Serbian analysis, very differently from Syrian or Egyptian it can be seen that in Serbia there was conscription type of military, made out of young boys – population not too fond of Milosevic, and therefore not too loyal to the regime, but the key pillar was the police, which we have talked to on various levels for years.” He added: “Every society needs to understand (which is in part content of our trainings) what are the most important pillars in that society – pulling this pillar from the side of government towards the side of the movement is actually the corner stone of every movement’s strategy.”

But then what about self-professed democratically elected leaders who fail to implement the fundamentals of a democratic state?

“People power is power to make any institution, including the military, accountable, and the most important difference between happy and unhappy societies is who keeps whom accountable. In happy societies, governments are “afraid” of the people, or accountable to the people via democratic institutions, like freedom to protest or elections. In contrast in unhappy societies people are afraid of their governments – whether civilian dictators or military juntas,” Popovic explains. His argument highlights that while some see it as a military coup, many see it as an extension of the power of the people.

The long history of military takeovers from Chile in the 1970s to Pakistan in the 1990s tells us that it was welcomed at first, but regretted in years to come. Time will tell if Egypt’s political turmoil will follow a similar sequence of events or not.


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Comments (8) (Closed)


Anas Qaimkhani
Jul 31, 2013 07:38pm

Typical article from Dawn with a liberal bias. The article seems to show that there are more people against Morsi than for him. Yet, there are hundreds of thousands of people protesting in his favour (with dozens dying) everyday.

The article barely speaks a word against the Egyptian Army which disposed off a democratically elected government. If MB had no support then why is the army looking to ban it from contesting future elections? If, as the picture shows, there is so much support for the secular parties then why all these arrests and shoot-to-kill orders? What are they scared off?

Anas Qaimkhani
Jul 31, 2013 07:41pm

The truth is that Egypt is divided 50-50 between pro-Morsi and anti-Morsi camps. Unfortunately, very few media outlets are showing this as such.

bhatti
Jul 31, 2013 08:13pm

The egyptian does not know the taste of democracy. They have been ruled by dictators over the last several decades and therefore they do not know how to handle democratically elected president. They have to decide whether they need democracy or a system where army has strong role to play. By toppling Morsi the egyptian have toppled democratic process and have brought country to edge of civil war. The egyptian will pay high price for what they are doing in the streets. The only solution is to restore democratically elected president and remove him through democratic means without the inovolvement of armed forces.

Omar
Jul 31, 2013 08:54pm

It is deeply hurting that this is even a question! Nothing can justify this foreign backed saudia, qatar and US funding military coup.

shahzad khan
Jul 31, 2013 11:54pm

Morsi is a great man. He is standing against the tyrants and the operessors against muslim world..whoever is against morsi is againt islam simple as that. we are not stupid like the generation before us. We will fight against persecution till its no more.

saad
Aug 01, 2013 01:33am

It's was like the 1953 Iranian coup d'

Pankaj
Aug 01, 2013 03:10am

democracy doesn't mean majority gets the right to exploit the minorities...... democracy means playing by rules and fundamental constitutional rule of secularism can't be broken..... Morsi was trying to do exactly that..........

Anam Gill
Aug 01, 2013 03:09pm

@Anas Qaimkhani: I wrote a detailed analysis hightlighting in detail the military coup, the papers most of the time want to slash things down for various reasons. Being a writer of this feature, visiting Egypt twice and feeling strongly about what's happening there i wanted to stay objective. My conclusion is that we have been fooled by power structures who value profit over welfare of the people and it's time we define our problems in a way that connects us al, trying to fool the empire for once. There are those same people masking themselves hiding their true nature, be it Morsi, a dictator or Hosni. I wished that the essence of my piece wasnt lost in the way.