Following the introduction of Bt cotton in India, reportedly through illegal and secret trials initially during 1990's, here in Pakistan fears had been expressed by some quarters that like other items, seeds of Bt cotton may be smuggled into the country.

Unfortunately, these fears have proved true. In the year 2001-02, cultivation of Bt cotton was undertaken illegally both in the lower and upper Sindh probably with the seeds smuggled from India.

In the absence of any bio-safety laws, it was obligatory upon the two main bodies working under the federal ministry of food, agriculture and livestock (MINFAL) to take notice of the issue.

Unfortunately neither the Federal Seed Certification Department nor the Federal Plant Protection Department probed the matter. I would be proper here to mention that under the Seed Act, 1976, cultivation of any unapproved variety is not allowed.

Similarly, under Plant Quarantine Rules, 1967 no body is allowed to import any plant or plant materials including seeds without the import permit of the DPP. The apathy of both the departments concerned may be termed as almost criminal in view of the fact that cotton is the most important cash crop of Pakistan.

Regarding the performance of Bt cotton it would be pertinent to mention that two years observations of this transgenic variety, under the climatic conditions of upper Sindh, indicated that performance of Bt cotton was very much erratic.

Under no rain and hot and dry weather conditions it was found highly susceptible to Jassid and CLCV disease, whereas under heavy monsoon rain of 2003 it was found susceptible also to armyworm.

Besides, cultivation with mixture of Bt cotton and non-Bt cottonseeds was found harbouring more bollworms problem as compared to cultivation undertaken with pure non-Bt cotton seeds.

This very demerit of Bt cotton bears especial significance in view of the fact that mixing in seeds, fertilizers, pesticides etc is a common feature and should have to be taken note of while making any policy to this effect.

One most haunting aspect of Bt cotton cultivation may be that seed produced with Bt and non-Bt cotton will ultimately be used as poultry and animal feed besides its use in the edible oil preparation.

Moreover, the impact on milk and meat of animals and birds that will consume transgenic feed is not known to us. No doubt, Agriculture Extension, (Sindh) as well as MINFAL have been found advising growers not to undertake Bt cotton cultivation as it may lead to serious ecological consequences and even crop loss but reality on the ground was that their advice or warning gone unheeded by the farmers in Sindh.

As a matter of fact, craze of Bt cotton is due to the hype generated by seed mafia that its cultivation reduces the bollworm attack. According to an the Financial Express (India) (June 11), the Union tourism minister, Renuka Chaudhary hit out hard at unnecessary hype generated about the performance of Bt cotton. Ms Chaudhary said: "In Andhra Pradesh, both Bt cotton and non Bt cotton have equally performed well in 03 season.

At times it is difficult to differentiate between the two". Reportedly in India last year Mahyco-Monsanto had applied to the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee [GEAEJ for approval of a Bt cotton variety in north India, but this variety was rejected as it was found susceptible to the dangerous leaf curl virus.

However, this year Bt cotton varieties developed by a local Rasi Seeds have been granted permission for large-scale field trials in north India. In spite of the fact that in India large-scale cultivation as well as trials of Bt cotton variety were developed locally, it is also a fact that its performance has remained a matter of debate.

On May 12, 2003 the above-mentioned newspaper reported: "convener of Andhra Pradesh Coalition in Defence of Diversity [APCIDD], P.V Satheesh has said that contrary to the claims of Monsanto, Bt cotton has failed in the state.

The farmer who cultivated Bt cotton yielded 9 per cent less profit as compared to those who cultivated non-Bt cotton. This is dangerous. Cotton seeds are used in animal and poultry feeds.

Milk and poultry products derived from animals and birds which have consumed Bt feed may invite serious health hazards in humans". Moreover, according to the "Irish Independent" (18 June, 2004): "The Irish cattle and sheep Farmer/s Association has become the first farm organization to demand that Ireland become G M free.

It called upon the Government to adopt a policy to keep genetically modified organisms out of the Ireland and use this as a part of a strategy to develop and market the green image of Irish food produce.

This will give Ireland a marketing edge over EU countries that may take a different approach to G M The ICSA said survey clearly showed that the majority of E U consumer were strongly opposed to the use of G M organisms, whether as part of the human diet or in feed for animal ". Here in Pakistan, the government has been found adopting a policy of wait and see.

Supporters of the technology argue that useful traits such as higher vitamin content can help solve nutritional disease in developing countries. They claim using herbicide and insecticide resistant crops would reduce the need for chemical sprays.

Where as its opponents say that too little is known about this new technology and urge a precautionary approach to it. They argue there could be hidden health impact and modified plants grown in the open could spread herbicide- resistant genes into weeds, making them impossible to clear.

Suggestion: There is no denying the fact that violating Pakistan Seed Act of 1976 and Plant Quarantine Rules of 1967 cultivation of Bt cotton [GM] has been in practice for the last three years in the province of Sindh.

Since giving a free hand to this transgenic cotton variety may be perilous in the long run for the very agriculture of our country, it is suggested that a committee of highly competent cotton scientists be formed to monitor the performance of illegal Bt cotton crop as well as its ecological impacts on bio diversity during the current cotton season both in lower and upper Sindh regions.

If the committee finds that the Bt cotton may have a good potential in the country then Government may allow its cultivation with the Bt seeds developed in our own research centre in the country.

Opinion

Editorial

Judiciary’s SOS
Updated 28 Mar, 2024

Judiciary’s SOS

The ball is now in CJP Isa’s court, and he will feel pressure to take action.
Data protection
28 Mar, 2024

Data protection

WHAT do we want? Data protection laws. When do we want them? Immediately. Without delay, if we are to prevent ...
Selling humans
28 Mar, 2024

Selling humans

HUMAN traders feed off economic distress; they peddle promises of a better life to the impoverished who, mired in...
New terror wave
Updated 27 Mar, 2024

New terror wave

The time has come for decisive government action against militancy.
Development costs
27 Mar, 2024

Development costs

A HEFTY escalation of 30pc in the cost of ongoing federal development schemes is one of the many decisions where the...
Aitchison controversy
Updated 27 Mar, 2024

Aitchison controversy

It is hoped that higher authorities realise that politics and nepotism have no place in schools.