IN a recent political development that has surprised many in the United States, a Muslim candidate, Zohran Mamdani, emerged victorious in the Democratic primaries for the post of New York City mayor. This is despite the fact that New York has for long been a stronghold of the Jewish lobby, and Muslims make up less than five per cent of the population. Yet, Mamdani defeated former governor Andrew Cuomo by securing over 43pc of the vote compared to Cuomo’s 36pc.

It is obvious that the support of Muslim voters alone could not have taken Mamdani this far. It was the support of the young voters, regardless of their faith, that is behind the surprise victory. And, more to the point, it is the sense of frustration among the young with current US and Israeli policies and the ongoing genocide of hapless Palestinians that has given Mamdani the edge more than his own charisma or agenda.

Mamdani gained popularity by taking a bold stance on the Gaza war, openly criticising US and Israeli actions, and even likening Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as war criminals. His clarity of thought, especially in a city long dominated by establishment politics, resonated with the youth and progressive voters.

If Mamdani wins the mayoral election in November, which is likely since Democrats typically win in New York City, he will become the city’s first Muslim and South Asian mayor. His intraparty win has already caused shockwaves within the American establishment, the pro-Israel lobby, and even within his own party. Donald Trump has called him ‘crazy’, while several Democratic leaders have been clearly uneasy about his rise.

Mamdani’s progress thus far signals a major shift. American youth, including progressive Jews, are increasingly opposing war-driven policies, especially regarding Gaza. mamdani’s campaign has shown that supporting Palestinian rights is no longer a political burden or liability for the progressives. In fact, it can actually be a winning strategy. Analysts believe that this could be a turning point and an example that moral, inclusive and grassroots leader can challenge an entrenched system.

Ghulam Hyder Mugheri
Karachi

Published in Dawn, July 18th, 2025