WASHINGTON, March 23: The human rights organization Amnesty International has expressed its dissatisfaction with the rules announced earlier this week for US military tribunals and said the original presidential order authorizing the tribunals is itself flawed.

In a statement released on Friday, Amnesty said the operating guidelines for trials by executive military commission, issued by the US Secretary of Defence, “have thrown into stark relief the fundamental defects of the Military Order signed by President Bush on Nov 13, 2001 .... That the Pentagon has paid lip service to due process in its commission guidelines cannot disguise the fact that any trial before these executive bodies would violate the USA’s international obligations.”

The organization repeated its call for the military order to be rescinded, and pointed out the discriminatory nature of the order, which stipulates that US nationals would not be tried by military courts even if they were accused of the same offence as foreigners.

The tribunals have been set up to try Al Qaeda/Taliban men arrested or likely to be arrested by the US.

Amnesty said there would be no right of appeal from the tribunals to an independent and impartial court established by law. Instead, there would be a review by a three-member panel appointed by the defence secretary.

“We note the Pentagon’s rules include the presumption of innocence,” Amnesty said. “However, this guarantee has been undermined by a pattern of public commentary on the presumed guilt of the Guantánamo detainees by the very officials that control the commissions.”

Opinion

Editorial

Reserved seats
Updated 15 May, 2024

Reserved seats

The ECP's decisions and actions clearly need to be reviewed in light of the country’s laws.
Secretive state
15 May, 2024

Secretive state

THERE is a fresh push by the state to stamp out all criticism by using the alibi of protecting national interests....
Plague of rape
15 May, 2024

Plague of rape

FLAWED narratives about women — from being weak and vulnerable to provocative and culpable — have led to...
Privatisation divide
Updated 14 May, 2024

Privatisation divide

How this disagreement within the government will sit with the IMF is anybody’s guess.
AJK protests
14 May, 2024

AJK protests

SINCE last week, Azad Jammu & Kashmir has been roiled by protests, fuelled principally by a disconnect between...
Guns and guards
14 May, 2024

Guns and guards

THERE are some flawed aspects to our society that we must start to fix at the grassroots level. One of these is the...