Researcher says Caravaggio used photographic techniques

Published
0

FLORENCE (Italy) Italian Renaissance painter Caravaggio used revolutionary optical instruments to “photograph” his models more than 200 years before the camera was invented, according to a researcher in Florence.

The 16th century artist celebrated for his dramatic chiaroscuro (light and shadow) paintings mastered “a whole set of techniques that are the basis of photography,” Roberta Lapucci told AFP.

Caravaggio worked in a “darkroom” and illuminated his models through a hole in the ceiling, said Lapucci, who teaches at the prestigious Studio Art Centres International in the Tuscan capital.

The image was then projected onto a canvas using a lens and a mirror, she said.

Caravaggio “fixed” the image, using light-sensitive substances, for around half an hour during which he used white lead mixed with chemicals and minerals that were visible in the dark to paint the image with broad strokes, Lapucci said.

She has hypothesised that Caravaggio used a photo-luminescent powder from crushed fireflies, which was used at the time to create special effects in theatre productions.

One of the main elements of these mixtures was mercury - to which prolonged exposure can affect the central nervous system causing irritability and other symptoms - which Lapucci said would help explain Caravaggio's notorious temper.

One of his many brawls ended in the death in 1606 of a young adversary, Ranuccio Tomassoni, which forced him to flee Rome to Malta.

“The entire set-up was suggested to him by his friend Giovanni Battista Della Porta, a physicist,” Lapucci said.

“Caravaggio was very tied to a community of scholars interested in optics.”

While Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519) had earlier described the “camera obscura” or darkroom, Caravaggio was the first painter to use it, Lapucci said.

The Italian researcher has collaborated with British artist David Hockney, who wrote in his 2001 book “Secret Knowledge” that Caravaggio and later the Flemish Baroque artist Anthony Van Dyck (1599-1641) and French neoclassical painter Jean Auguste Dominique Ingres (1780-1867) used optical instruments to compose their paintings.

Art historians say the assertions have not been proven and complain that they devalue the artists' genius.

“There is lots of proof, notably the fact that Caravaggio never made preliminary sketches,” Lapucci said. “So it is plausible that he used these 'projections' to paint.”

Noting that “an abnormal number of his subjects were left-handed,” Lapucci said “That could be explained by the fact that the image projected on the canvas was backwards.”She added “This anomaly disappears in the artist's later works, a sign that the instruments he used were improving. Also thanks to technical progress, his paintings gain a lot in depth of field over the years.”

Lapucci is especially keen to refute charges of detracting from the artist's work.

“His mastery of certain techniques before his time in no way diminishes his genius,” she said.

“To the contrary - clearly, you can't just project images on a canvas and copy them to become a Caravaggio!”—AFP

Opinion

Editorial

Restructuring plans
Updated 29 Oct, 2026

Restructuring plans

The primary reason for governance failure in Pakistan is not the geographical size of the existing provinces but the reluctance of provincial capitals to empower local bodies.
Polluted priorities
Updated 29 Oct, 2026

Polluted priorities

Enforcement must continue, but decisions should follow evidence, not the visibility of machinery on city roads.
Continuing genocide
29 Oct, 2026

Continuing genocide

FOR the people of Gaza, despite the ‘ceasefire’ reached last October, the genocide never really ceased. This ...
Regional security
Updated 28 Oct, 2026

Regional security

Iran and the Makkah pact states should pledge not to let external actors use their soil to launch aggression against each other.
Rate hike
28 Oct, 2026

Rate hike

THE SBP’s decision to raise its policy rate by 50 basis points to 12pc was largely expected. It is also justified...
Press solidarity
28 Oct, 2026

Press solidarity

PAKISTAN’S journalists have seldom lacked organisations speaking in defence of press freedom. What has been ...