Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Politics and state


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

TWO slogans in Pakistan’s two largest cities — both emphasising the leader. In Lahore the stage is being prepared for the return of Allama Dr Tahirul Qadri. In Karachi, wall chalkings of the MQM’s earlier slogan, ‘Manzil nahin rehnuma chahiye’ (leader not destination) have cropped up once again. The catchphrase for Dr Qadri’s Dec 23 rally is ‘Siyasat nahin, riyasat bachao’. Literally, this means ‘save the state, not politics’ but a clearer translation would be ‘discredit old politics to create room for your own’. This is so typical of born-again tehriks. Politics and the Pakistan Awami Tehrik have somehow not combined well, even though Dr Qadri has a large following and despite his past attempts. Dr Qadri rose to prominence during Gen Zia’s rule as a law teacher and religious scholar. Later, he chose to grace Gen Musharraf’s 2002 National Assembly. It is unfortunate the state could not be saved then and there, leaving it precariously in the hands of who else but the politicians.

Having decided politics was something not worth saving, Dr Qadri is happy over the backing he has got from the MQM — when no one quite knows how PAT is going to go about its campaign. When Dr Qadri thanked the MQM chief for his support recently, he said it was the fight against feudalism that had brought PAT and the MQM closer. It is ironic then that the wall chalkings in Karachi do not reflect this. Unless the objective is to convey that the leader is a destination unto himself, the slogan might come across as somewhat feudal in modern times. In earlier times, when the MQM was subjected to severe persecution by the state, the frustration was understandable, but now that it has entered mainstream politics as a democratic force in its own right it must aim for higher standards.

Comments (4) Closed

Cyrus Howell Dec 22, 2012 07:39am
He knows nothing; and he thinks he knows everything. That points clearly to a political career. Geporge Bernard Shaw
zkkhan Dec 22, 2012 01:02pm
State has nothing to do with religion is a success story in whole modern world. He is an eminent religious scholar. Couple of years back he delivered goood speach about terrorism and Islam in world economic forum. Better option for him is to educate the Pakistani masses to chose those leaders who can deliver good to Pakistan rather than throwing himslef in politics.
Agha Ata Dec 22, 2012 01:45pm
He should join PTI.
Dr. D. Prithipaul Dec 22, 2012 11:22pm
The vagueness and the ill-defined concepts which this article claims to be discussing give a clue to the mobility and the state of flux in the thinking of the elite. They thus provide an empty intellectual or rational space in which anyone can attribute any meaning at will and act accordingly. The outsider who reds such a text would be totally lost as to what to make of such a report. On the basisof what Dr. Qadri did or said or meant to be, one does not know what is the meaning of the state and what is the purpose of politics in Pakistan.