Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


SC and targeted killings


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

IT was never easy to get to see or even reach by phone the police chief of a city or a province. He was always said to have been summoned by the minister or the chief minister. Of late, the likely response also can be that he had gone to the Supreme Court.

For more than a year now, police officials of Karachi have been reporting the ‘targeted killings’ to the judges. It was naive of the learned judges to have assumed that their intervention would deter the killers or, even less likely, prompt police officials to greater action.

The general feeling is that killings, if at all, have grown and the killers find ever new victims for their belief, ethnic background or vocation.

Whatever the motive of the killers, bad luck of their victims, the SC ‘sou motu’ action, etc has not helped.

The resultant despondency can be fatal. No other venue is left to seek a remedy. The problem of crime is simple to understand.

It is made simpler by the report of Justices M. Munir and M.R. Kayani on the Punjab disturbances of 1953 which led to the imposition of the first martial law in a part of the country.

It ends on a poignant note: “We are prompted by something that they call a human conscience to inquire whether, in our present state of political development, the administrative problem of law and order cannot be divorced from a democratic bed-fellow called a ministerial government, which is so remorselessly haunted by political nightmares. But if democracy means the subordinate of law and order to political ends, then Allah knoweth best and we end the report.”

It is truer now than it was 58 years ago. Allah still knoweth the best. But the people also know this much that the law and order was never in greater subordination to politics than it is today.

KUNWAR IDRIS     Karachi

Comments (5) Closed

farmerdr Oct 28, 2012 08:32pm
Surely laws and processes to protect professional groups within the executive from political interference or intimidation can work if our subordinate judiciary was not as sub standard as it is.
Razzaq Oct 27, 2012 07:43pm
Every time I read,listen or watch about this subject, I fail to understand the justification in existence of law enforcing agencies and that too in a very large numbers. If these people would do even 50% of what is needed of them I am sure the results would be there for everyone to see. I therefore, suspect that apart from being politicised they also may be busy in other money minting activities as recent report on animal markets suggests.THEY MUST BE KICKED OUT OF CITY AND A NEW FORCE BE CREATED FROM YOUNG PEOPLE OF KARACHI.
Cyrus Howell Oct 27, 2012 03:16am
What does the supreme court have to do with "targeted killings"?
Ahmer Oct 27, 2012 05:44pm
The law and order is an executive responsibility. The CJP has enough scope for his activities within the legitimite judicial functions.
kaiser Oct 28, 2012 08:42am
Ask the supreme court.