View from Bangladesh: Ten take-aways from the Modi visit

Published June 10, 2015
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi visited Bangladesh for a mere 36 hours, but left an impact big enough to wipe away mistrust that had crept in the Indo-Bangladesh relationship over the decades. -Reuters/file
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi visited Bangladesh for a mere 36 hours, but left an impact big enough to wipe away mistrust that had crept in the Indo-Bangladesh relationship over the decades. -Reuters/file

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi visited Bangladesh for a mere 36 hours, but left an impact big enough to wipe away mistrust that had crept in the Indo-Bangladesh relationship over the decades. The credit for such a short sojourn leaving such a big impact and raising such high hopes goes to both the leaders, Narendra Modi and Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. Despite being from critically different backgrounds, they are now united in a shared vision of a connected South Asia – making development the top priority for their own nations and the region and in their sheer ability to be bold and decisive.

While time alone will be the ultimate judge of the impact of this trip, here is a mix of the highs and lows, the highlights and takeaways as seen from Bangladesh:

  1. Modi didn't wear any jackets or suits with funny stitching, which was a welcome relief. Given the brevity of his trip – only 36 hours – we could ill afford any sartorial distractions. The trip was packed with events, including visits to the National Monument, Bangabandhu Museum, a Hindu temple and much more that only a man of Modi's energy could sustain with good cheer.

  2. On a more serious note, this trip marks the end of a long tradition of mutual wariness. Sheikh Hasina was the first to take a bold step in that direction when she returned to power in 2009, and started stamping out terror outfits, whether they were aimed against Bangladesh or India. Bangladesh had expected India to reciprocate with a solution to its most urgent issues, such as water, but the Manmohan Singh visit of 2011 proved to be a dud. In a rivetingly sharp contrast of competence, Modi made the passing of the long-pending Land Boundary Agreement (LBA) a precondition of his trip.

  3. What is most remarkable is the visible blossoming of trust between the two leaders, and thereby the two nations. Most Bangladeshis viewed Modi with scepticism once. In words and gestures, Modi's visit seemed designed to signal the one thing that many Bangladeshis have felt missing from their bigger neighbour: respect. Between Hasina's and Modi's delivery, respectively, on counter-terror and the LBA, there is just enough substance in hand now not to dismiss the intangibles.

  4. But, there will always be those who carp. In Bangladesh, it takes the form of: What about sharing the Teesta waters? (In India, I suspect, it is: What about illegal Bangladeshis?) To the Bangladeshis, I say, Modi's multiple pronouncements make it clear that he's heard us loud and clear. He persuaded West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Bannerjee to accompany him, which former Indian prime minister Manmohan Singh had failed to do, is sign enough of his commitment. It is a complex issue where political will is now evident and one must give some time for the process and procedures. As for illegal Bangladeshis, I personally am happy to take back any who are truly Bangladeshi and residing elsewhere illegally. But India can't keep treating Bangladesh unfairly on trade and water and not expect economic migration to persist.

  5. Hasina and Modi have achieved more in our bilateral relations in this one year than any two of our leaders since former Bangladeshi prime minister Sheikh Mujibur Rahman and Indira Gandhi. It is easy to dismiss promises as "carrots" that may never be delivered, but Modi saying that India will not go ahead with a project like the controversial Tipaimukh water dam without consent from Bangladesh is not insignificant. It's a serious departure from the past when the Indian attitude was one of a mighty neighbour with upper riparian advantages. Anyone who wants more evidence on water issues is frankly being wilfully difficult .

  6. In a trip where one could hardly find a fault, some critics have seized on the power plant deals granted to the Reliance and Adani groups of India. They will build, respectively, 3000 and 1600 megawatt plants in Bangladesh. Leftist hackles are raised anytime big companies from bigger countries enter Bangladesh. Nationalists react similarly when they happen to be Indian. Both point to the fact that these deals were granted under a power plant deal that eschews a tendering process. What they skip is that the deal also requires that the rates match or better the last tendered deal. Bangladeshis can't both whine about the lack of foreign direct investment and get all defensive when it does come in.

  7. The trip saw the signing of a remarkable raft of memoranda and protocols. Few of them will mean much to most common citizens of either country. Still, they mark a kind of zeal about working together that will hopefully translate into delivery on bigger asks from both sides. Regional connectivity will help not only both nations, but the entire region. Indeed, we can't expect to be part of the Asian Highway without connecting with one another. It's absurd. And to that end, the start of Kolkata-Guahati direct train service is a most welcome step in the right direction.

  8. Returning to a lighter note, social media took a lot of interest in the menu for the state dinner. It was vegetarian, of course. It's less of a stretch for Bangladeshis (unlike what many Indians might imagine) than it has been in some Western or other capitals. Puritans wondered why Bangladesh tried to serve Modi non-Bengali specialties like Masala Dhokla. The menu was in fact a brilliant mix of pan-Indian and Bengali dishes, making it a perfect complement to the bilateralism that was thick in the air.

  9. One of the treats of this trip has been the side show called "The Taming Of Didi (Mamata Banerjee)". Mamata Banerjee once enjoyed quite a bit of popularity in Bangladesh as the fire-breather who brought down the Communist Party of India (Marxist). Who doesn't like an underdog? But her popularity here plummeted precipitously when she refused to share the Teesta waters with Bangladesh. Neither Banerjee's strident defence of Bengali Muslims nor Modi's words about illegal Bangladeshis have made as much of a mark as what they have said and done about the one issue that Bangladeshis most care about: water.

  10. So, if there is to be a final take-away from this trip, it is this: our citizens have grown savvy and are not easily swayed by communal rhetoric. They want to hear smart policies and see results. Modi and Hasina both seem to get that, and also the fact that one has to give to be able to take. Scepticism is a sign of intelligence, but getting stuck in that mode is not. Things are not moved forward by doubters, but by those who have the courage to place faith in others and take risks.

This article originally appeared on Scroll In and has been reproduced after permission.

Opinion

Editorial

Return to the helm
Updated 28 Apr, 2024

Return to the helm

With Nawaz Sharif as PML-N president, will we see more grievances being aired?
Unvaxxed & vulnerable
Updated 28 Apr, 2024

Unvaxxed & vulnerable

Even deadly mosquito-borne illnesses like dengue and malaria have vaccines, but they are virtually unheard of in Pakistan.
Gaza’s hell
Updated 28 Apr, 2024

Gaza’s hell

Perhaps Western ‘statesmen’ may moderate their policies if a significant percentage of voters punish them at the ballot box.
Missing links
Updated 27 Apr, 2024

Missing links

As the past decades have shown, the country has not been made more secure by ‘disappearing’ people suspected of wrongdoing.
Freedom to report?
27 Apr, 2024

Freedom to report?

AN accountability court has barred former prime minister Imran Khan and his wife from criticising the establishment...
After Bismah
27 Apr, 2024

After Bismah

BISMAH Maroof’s contribution to Pakistan cricket extends beyond the field. The 32-year old, Pakistan’s...