US-India deal humiliating: BJP

Published December 11, 2006

NEW DELHI, Dec 10: A bill that will allow the United States to sell nuclear technology to India compromises India’s independence, its main opposition party said on Sunday, adding that the ‘humiliating’ law should be rejected.

Legislation sailed through Congress early on Saturday, ending the isolation imposed after New Delhi developed nuclear weapons in contravention of international standards.

The deal, first agreed in July 2005, has caught the imagination of many in India and is seen as a major move towards becoming a regional power. But it has also attracted criticism after it was modified in the US legislature.

In a sign of the battle the government faces, the BJP in a statement said early fears that the United States was only interested in capping India’s nuclear weapons programme “stood confirmed”.

India’s nuclear scientists have also expressed concern over a provision in the Act passed by the US Congress that seeks to cap India’s right to conduct atomic tests.

The BJP statement said the bill did not deliver full civil nuclear cooperation, imposed “rigorous” assessment obligations, failed to guarantee uninterrupted fuel supplies for civilian reactors and prevented India from reprocessing spent fuel.It also banned future nuclear tests and rendered the weapons programme “subject to intrusive US scrutiny”.

Strategic analysts and members of the Indian nuclear establishment have cited similar concerns.They argued against inspections and said the deal would constrain India’s military nuclear programme by separating it from the civilian side.

An earlier draft stated that cooperation would depend on India’s support for international efforts to restrain Iran’s nuclear programme, rankling New Delhi.

That provision was watered down, but the US president will have to give yearly assessments.The BJP said: “The US Act seriously compromises the independence of our foreign policy.” “India is not just to toe the line of the US in regard to Iran, it is being afforded this (deal) on the grounds ... that its foreign policy will be ‘congruent’ with that of the US.” “The Act aims at capping, rolling back and eventually eliminating India’s nuclear weapons capability. By going in for agreement under this legislation, the government is binding India’s future – in security as well as technical advancement.”

Though Indian scientists too expressed concern over the bar on conducting nuclear tests, they were of the view that the current legislation was meant only for US lawmakers and bilateral cooperation on sharing civil nuclear technology would be governed by the 123 Agreement between the two countries.

“India need not worry about the legislation passed by the US Congress as it is meant for the US lawmakers. India is obliged only to the bilateral agreement (123 Agreement),” former Atomic Energy Commission chairman M. R. Srinivasan told PTI. —Agencies

Opinion

Editorial

GB polls’ aftermath
Updated 11 Jun, 2026

GB polls’ aftermath

The new administration must address the region’s issues proactively.
Peace in retreat
11 Jun, 2026

Peace in retreat

THE ceasefire announced in April was supposed to create space for negotiations. Instead, it has been repeatedly...
A few good men
11 Jun, 2026

A few good men

IT was a brave move, no doubt. This Tuesday, in the land of the Afghan Taliban, a few good men decided to take a...
Centre vs provinces
Updated 10 Jun, 2026

Centre vs provinces

The reason the centre finds itself in this position is rooted in its failure to expand the tax net and boost revenues.
Party in crisis
10 Jun, 2026

Party in crisis

THE young KP chief minister must be starting to realise just how thorny a seat he occupies. There has been a flurry...
Varsity woes
10 Jun, 2026

Varsity woes

FINANCIAL crises affecting public sector universities across Pakistan are now having an impact on academic...