Daily SectionMarker

Misc SectionMarker

Weekly SectionMarker

Weekly SectionMarker

Pakistan's Internet Magazine
Herald
Dawn GroupMarker

Archive, Search, Feedback & HelpMarker

Weather
Dawn Classified



FrontPage National International Local Business KSE Forex Sports Editorial Opinion Letters Features Today's Cartoon PTV 2 Guide Cowasjee Ayaz Mazdak Review Dawn Magazine Young World Images Dawn Group Subscription To Advertise

DINA
Previous Story DAWN - the Internet Edition Next Story


28 March 2004 Sunday 06 Safar 1425






Fragile post-poll scenario in Iraq

By Mark Matthews


WASHINGTON: With less than 100 days to go before the United States gives up the reins of government in Iraq, analysts and even some administration officials warn that the six months after the transfer could bring even more instability and violence.

Publicly, Bush administration officials speak optimistically about the transfer of sovereignty to Iraqis set for June 30.

"It will be a happy event for all Iraq," Paul Bremer, who heads the US-led occupation authority, said this week. "Iraq is now on a path to full democracy in a united state at peace with its neighbours."

But signs of future instability are obvious. No one knows who will rule Iraq during the first months of sovereignty or control its oil revenues, and a process for future elections has yet to be established. Although US troops will remain indefinitely, there is no formal agreement between the United States and Iraq over how they will operate.

US military officers have predicted an increase of violence as the handover approaches. Already, nearly 600 Americans have died since the war began, many as victims of an insurgency composed of Iraqis and foreign Muslim fighters.

Now, some analysts and officials fear that the fragile post- June 30 period could be even worse.

"There seems to be an assumption that as soon as we turn over sovereignty, the bad guys will stop doing what they're doing," said one administration official, speaking on condition of anonymity.

"The question of turning over sovereignty means nothing to these people," the official said. "I expect it will get worse before it gets better."

The post-June 30 period, which coincides with the final months of the American presidential race, will help determine whether Iraq moves forward towards becoming the regional democratic beacon that the Bush administration envisions or slides backwards into ethnic strife among its Shia majority and Sunni and Kurdish minorities.

The uncertain Iraqi political outlook creates "a very dangerous situation", said Marina Ottoway, an expert on democracy-building at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. "The administration is trying to gloss over it, but we're at a very critical point because we don't have a viable transition plan."

Neither the Bush administration - nor Iraqis, nor leaders overseas - wants to postpone the date for handing over sovereignty from the US-dominated Coalition Provisional Authority to Iraqis.

On that day, Bremer will leave the heavily guarded US "green zone" in Baghdad for a vacation home in Vermont. Many of his American employees will become staff members of a US Embassy under an ambassador who has yet to be appointed.

A huge American presence will remain in the country: at least 100,000 troops and one of the largest US Embassy staffs in the world, together with contractors funded by $18 billion in US reconstruction aid.

Although Iraqis want the aid and continued protection from US troops, they will resent any continued American rule over their government, analysts said.

But forming an interim government has produced a power struggle involving the US-picked Iraqi Governing Council and outside groups.

A year after it resisted giving the United Nations a central role in Iraq, the Bush administration has turned to the world body to help ensure a smooth transition, prepare for legislative elections by the end of January and full-scale national elections by late next year.

A UN team, due to arrive next week, will be led by Lakhdar Brahimi, who enjoys broad international credibility for his painstaking work in knitting together a new government in Afghanistan.

But many Iraqis are skeptical of Brahimi's mission.

"The mood on the Iraqi street is hostile to a robust re- engagement of the UN," said Ray Salvatore Jennings, a senior fellow at the United States Institute of Peace, who recently returned from eight weeks in Iraq. He added: "The UN will have a very difficult time getting in place in time (for its work) to be meaningful."

Brahimi's efforts may be undercut by an agreement between Bremer and the Governing Council to decide by April 15 what the interim government will look like. Many analysts predict they will agree to preserve the Governing Council, perhaps in an expanded form.

"It will be de facto some kind of expansion of the Governing Council," said Walter B. Slocombe, a former undersecretary of defence who until recently advised the US occupation authority.

"I see that as problematic," said Bathsheba Crocker, a specialist in post-conflict reconstruction at the Centre for Strategic and International Studies. "As we've all seen, the Governing Council is not viewed as legitimate body in or outside of Iraq."

"We run a real risk (of having) a supposed sovereign government without legitimacy," Crocker said.

Bush administration officials have pointed to the recent adoption by the Governing Council of an interim constitution as a major milestone for the region, with unprecedented protection of individual rights.

But the document is not as trailblazing as the administration proclaims, according to a recent paper by Patrick Clawson of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, and its importance will rest on how well it is implemented.

Most Arab states, he notes, have constitutions containing many of the same rights. Yet these countries are ruled by repressive regimes that are widely condemned for abusing human rights. -Dawn/The LAT-WP News Service (c) The Baltimore Sun.




Previous Story Top of Page Next Story

© The DAWN Group of Newspapers, 2004