As the Sadiks crossed continents and frequently moved between Pakistan and the United States, the doctor continued to advance her own knowledge, enrolling twice at Johns Hopkins in Baltimore. She was eminently qualified to head the UNFPA when she was chosen to do so in 1987, following the death of Rafael Salas of the Philippines. While she is best known for this job, Sadik also served on Pakistan’s Planning Commission as well as the country’s nascent family planning programmes. Regardless of the position she held, she stood up to those denying women their reproductive rights, whether it was the Pope in the Vatican or George W. Bush in Washington.
Miller has demonstrated tremendous passion for her subject in travelling the globe, listening to women’s stories and talking to Sadik’s many childhood friends as well as family members. However, she can be faulted on two counts — firstly, the research on Pakistan. She writes “In 1971, when Ayub Khan was driven from office and replaced by Zulfikar Ali Bhutto (father of Benazir Bhutto), a more conservative era ensued. One of the leader’s first steps with the very visible family planning program was to make it fade into the background.” Apart from the chronological mistakes, Bhutto only turned ‘Islamic’ in 1977. In fact, in the mid-70s his government, in collaboration with the Family Planning Association of Pakistan, was all set to take a revolutionary step — the commercial marketing of contraceptives in Pakistan. It was General Ziaul Haq who pushed back Pakistan’s programme and the country is still feeling the repercussions. Other trivial inaccuracies prevail — such as a reference to Sheraton in the Lahore of the ’50s and Jinnah described as Pakistan’s president.
The other grouse I have is the breathless, gushy approach she’s adopted for a woman known for her professionalism. Champion of Choice has too many references to Sadik’s “Radha eyes”. Surely the doctor and the readers would prefer a more objective biography to something close to a hagiography.
The reviewer is the chairperson of the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan
Champion of Choice: The Life and Legacy of Women’s Advocate Nafis Sadik
(Biography)
By Cathleen Miller
University of NebraskaPress, US
ISBN 978-0-8032-1104-9
496pp.