Email

Fenced in: The Kashmir barrier that is endangering wildlife

Published Feb 23, 2016 10:57am
A view of snow-covered Neelum Valley in Pakistan-held Kashmir. ─ AFP
A view of snow-covered Neelum Valley in Pakistan-held Kashmir. ─ AFP

NEELUM VALLEY: A double row of fence and tangled concertina wire curves like a Frankenstein stitch across the Kashmir frontier, blocking anything that might try to cross one of the world's most dangerous flashpoints ─ including, environmentalists say, migrating wildlife.

Built in 2007 by India, the impenetrable barrier scarring hundreds of kilometres of snowy forests has obstructed militants for years, but it has also halted the movement of some spectacular and rare species formerly abundant in the area, wildlife officials have told AFP.

Creatures such as black bears and leopards, fenced in on the Pakistani side, are being driven by hunger into nearby settlements, often with fatal consequences.

In the lush hilltop hamlet of Arang Kel, more than 8,000 feet (2,500 metres) above sea level, residents say they have no choice but to kill the wild animals stalking their land.

"Our cattle, sheep, goats and cows are not safe from them and sometimes they attack people," villager Roshan Khan, who is in his 60s, tells AFP. "That's why they are being killed."

Pakistani Kashmir girl pulling a sheep in the snow-covered Neelum Valley. ─ AFP
Pakistani Kashmir girl pulling a sheep in the snow-covered Neelum Valley. ─ AFP

"They have to travel towards human settlements in search of food, where they are killed by people when they attack their livestock," says Yousuf Qureshi, the former director of the wildlife department in Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK).

Explore: Teacher helps save pair of rare Indian wolves

Since 2007 around 35 common leopards, five bears, and several brown bears have met their fate this way, says AJK assistant wildlife and fisheries department director Naeem Dar.

The detour, exacerbated by deforestation and coupled with a lack of resources available to wildlife officials, has contributed to the eradication of many such species on the Pakistani side of the Line of Control (LoC), officials say.

'Tragedy'

The electric fence stands up to 12 feet tall in places, and is attached to an elaborate network of motion sensors, thermal imaging devices, lighting systems and alarms. The area immediately around it is peppered with land mines ─ all in a bid to protect the frontier from infiltration.

Kashmir's thick forests and soaring slopes are divided between Pakistan and India along the de facto border agreed on in a 2003 ceasefire, but claimed by both in full. Two of their three wars since independence have been fought over the region.

The Srinagar-based commander of the Indian army's XV Corps, Lieutenant General SK Dua, tells AFP the flow of militants crossing over from AJK is "down to a trickle" now, crediting the formidable fence and other counter-insurgency initiatives.

But, while they claim blocking militants ─ and subsequently wildlife ─ from Pakistan, the barrier has also prevented animals moving from the Indian side.

Read more: Pakistan to lead global initiative to save snow leopard

Creatures such as the markhor, a type of wild goat with majestic horns, simply no longer appear on the Pakistani side ─ blocked by hundreds of kilometres of barbed wire and explosives, says Qureshi.

"[The markhor] would travel from Pir Panjal [in the Himalayan mountains in Indian-held Kashmir] to Neelum Valley, but the fence created a barrier and their migration has ended," he says. "This is a tragedy."

A Pakistani Kashmir man walking with his livestock in the snow-covered Neelum Valley. ─  AFP
A Pakistani Kashmir man walking with his livestock in the snow-covered Neelum Valley. ─ AFP

The same goes for the hangul, or Kashmir deer, once common in the area but now "totally extinct" on Pakistan's side of the border, he says.

Tear down this fence

The fence itself is not the only issue, Qureshi warns. The barrier has not stopped regular instances of firing by soldiers on both sides across the LoC which, he says, which has also driven wildlife away.

"Once they abandoned their habitats they did not go back," he says.

Know more: 41 tigers dead in India in 2015: Wildlife groups

Deforestation also plays a significant role. Neelum Valley winters are harsh, with wood the only fuel for villagers bereft of electricity or other sources of power.

Indian security border post in Neelum Valley as seen from Pakistan-held Kashmir. ─ AFP
Indian security border post in Neelum Valley as seen from Pakistan-held Kashmir. ─ AFP

When India and Pakistan were created in 1947 forest covered some 24 per cent of Pakistani Kashmir, but that has now dropped to 11pc.

"The natural living places of these animals are being destroyed," says Munawaar Hussain, a wildlife employee posted in Arang Kel.

For Muhammad Arshad, district programme manager for the Himalaya Welfare Organization, the problem is clear: the area needs peace.

"Fencing on the LoC has disturbed their natural habitat and limited the territory," he says.

"India and Pakistan should have peace in the region and dismantle the fencing on the LoC for the conservation of these species," adds Qureshi.

Read: Asian ibex: The elite hunting club has a new favourite victim

For now, villagers in Arang Kel say they have no choice but to keep killing the animals ─ despite the threat of fines and imprisonment for illegal hunting.

"We are worried the wildlife department will lodge a case against us when we kill these animals," says villager Khan.

"There must be some solution."

Know more: Animal hunting in Pakistan deserves no applause