China’s path to reform

Published March 19, 2012

LAST week’s dismissal of Bo Xilai, the party secretary of Chongqing province, casts this autumn’s Chinese Communist Party Congress, with the anticipated replacement of President Hu Jintao and Premier Wen Jiabao by Xi Jinping and Li Keqiang, in a dramatic new light.

Bo Xilai, son of a former Communist Party leader and veteran of the Long March, has been exploiting his office for a thinly veiled campaign for a place on the standing committee that runs China. His fall was triggered when his right-hand man, the police chief Wang Lijun, sought refuge in the American consulate in Chengdu, claiming that his life was under threat from Bo.

The coup de grace was delivered by Wen at the annual National People’s Congress, when he warned that China risked another “historical tragedy” like the cultural revolution. Bo’s dismissal followed almost immediately.

It is not surprising that tensions in the Chinese Communist Party should be running high at this time. The forthcoming congress will decide who will run China for the next 10 years. Profound policy questions are at stake. After 30 years of extraordinary economic growth, China is the world’s second-largest economy and a major global power. It is a very different country from the one in which Deng Xiaoping launched his reforms: fundamental changes now confront the new leadership.

First, the era of cheap labour and low value-added production is coming to an end as the economy becomes increasingly sophisticated: a major shift in economic strategy is under way. Second, China has acquired a panoply of global interests that require its foreign policy to be rethought. Third, the enormous growth in social inequality, combined with mounting corruption, has fostered a sense of grievance that could threaten the country’s stability. And fourth, major political reform must be instituted.

Debate and argument is no stranger to Beijing. When a country is growing at around 10 per cent per annum, it is constantly throwing up huge new problems that demand solution. There is a presumption in the West that there is little discussion and argument in China. This is wrong: it would be impossible to go through the kind of change that China has experienced without it provoking major conflicts. And because China now faces the need for a major policy shift on several fronts, this has been intensifying. Beijing is currently home to the world’s most interesting debates.

Could the conflicts get out of hand? Wen’s reminder about the lessons of the cultural revolution was patently a reference to Bo Xilai’s conduct in Chongqing, where he has been accused of ignoring legal procedures in the name of a crackdown on organised crime, using torture to extract confessions, and targeting powerful businesspeople who are not his allies.

He has combined this with a populist political campaign that has carried distant echoes of the cultural revolution. China has come a long way since those dark days, when lawlessness and arbitrary authority reigned. If not the rule of law, there is certainly now a much greater respect for due procedure. But the revelations about Bo’s behaviour indicate that old attitudes and practices still persist, and are perhaps even widespread, and could — under certain circumstances — provide the basis for a serious political regression.

More likely, however, is that the process of growing political accountability and openness will continue and deepen. This is not to suggest that China is on the verge of introducing universal suffrage and a multiparty system, which is the knee-jerk western response to any mention of political reform. Political reform will be gradual and cautious.

We can already detect some of its characteristics. The constraints on the media have been considerably loosened, while the internet has provided, except on the most sensitive issues, a platform for a convulsive and hard-hitting debate. — The Guardian, London

Opinion

Editorial

Palestine MPC
Updated 09 Oct, 2024

Palestine MPC

It's a matter of concern that PTI did not attend the Palestine MPC. Political differences should be put aside when showing solidarity with Palestine.
A welcome reform
09 Oct, 2024

A welcome reform

THE Punjab government’s decision to abolish the corruption-ridden and inefficient food department, and replace it...
Water paradox
09 Oct, 2024

Water paradox

A FULLY fledged water crisis is unfolding across the world, with 2023 recorded as the driest year for rivers in over...
Terrorism upsurge
Updated 08 Oct, 2024

Terrorism upsurge

The state cannot afford major security lapses. It may well be that the Chinese nationals were targeted to sabotage SCO event.
Ban hammer
08 Oct, 2024

Ban hammer

THE decision to ban the PTM under the Anti-Terrorism Act is yet another ill-advised move by the state. Although the...
Water tensions
08 Oct, 2024

Water tensions

THE unresolved tensions over Indus water distribution under the 1991 Water Apportionment Accord demand a revision of...