Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Pakistan drives railways towards ruin

Published Dec 21, 2011 04:15am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Railway tracks are seen vacant at Cantt Station in Karachi due to late arrival of the trains.—Online

RAWALPINDI: For 44 years, Jaffer Hussain has worked as a porter, hauling luggage around bustling platforms in exchange for handsome tips. But these days, he just sits and waits.

“I've been working here since 1967. I've seen the boom of railways. Now it's a dead department,” he told AFP, despondent without a single customer for a train heading on the 30-hour journey south to Karachi.

Corruption, mismanagement and neglect have driven Pakistan Railways to the brink.

Haulage and passenger services have been slashed and an urgent rescue is called for to save a much-loved legacy of British rule from the scrap heap.

When Britain closed the curtain on its empire and Pakistan was born in 1947, the country inherited thousands of miles of track and trains provided the most popular and affordable transport for millions.

But as Pakistan has spluttered from crisis to crisis, tarnished by corruption, straining under the near doubling of fuel prices in five years and the expansion of domestic flights, the decline has quickened.

Since the current government took power in 2008, the railway has retired 104 of 204 trains in a country larger than Britain and Germany combined.

State-owned, it relies on handouts of 2.5 billion rupees ($2.8 million) a month just to pay salaries and pensions; and faces expected losses of 35 billion rupees ($390 million) in fiscal year July 2011 to June 2012.

In October there was uproar when a retired train driver died outside a bank after waiting three days for his pension.

Railways Minister Ghulam Ahmad Bilour has no illusions about the situation.

“The state of railways is very bad,” he told AFP. “It can never become a profitable organisation, if we reduce its deficit, it would be an achievement.”

He blames previous governments for decades of failure to invest, but recognises that the current administration is just as guilty.

The cabinet approved emergency funding of $125 million for the railways in January but it has yet to be released by the finance ministry, Bilour said.

He says the ministry requested 300 new engines to return to normal operations “but they did not give us a single penny”.

“We got 69 locomotives in 2004 from China but we did not sign an agreement to get spare parts and the engines started breaking down,” said the minister.

Flying from Islamabad to Karachi takes two hours and a network of luxury coaches is considered more comfortable, which means that today only the poorest of Pakistan's 174 million travel by train.

“There is corruption and mismanagement at every level,” said former railways minister, Sheikh Rashid Ahmed.

“The workers don't work, mechanics don't change the oil and the officials wait for destruction of the machinery to buy new and get commissions.”

But the government is now trying to stave off total ruin. It has released a 600-million-rupee subsidy to repair engines and the board is hoping the private sector can become its knight in shining armour.

“We have devised a strategy to rehabilitate 360 locomotives with the help of the private sector and bring all of them back to working condition in the next three years,” Shafiq Ullah, the secretary of the Pakistan Railways board, told AFP.

“By August, we will get all these 69 Chinese locomotives on the track,”said, adding that only six freight trains are operational —a fraction of the 100 goods trains that once used to run.

Independent analysts estimate it will take at least five years and millions of dollars to haul the infrastructure into the 21st century.

“Constant neglect has led Pakistan Railways into such bad shape,” A. B. Shahid, an economy expert and former banker, told AFP.

“They need at least three to five years to revive the department, and inject at least 25 billion rupees, for infrastructure and repairing locomotives. They should privatise local trains and improve signalling,” he said.

Saqib Shirani, a former adviser to the finance ministry, said the government should remove interest from central bank loans and end political appointments.

“It shouldn't be fully privatised but investment in a few sectors like goods trains and some passenger trains will be really fruitful,” he said.

But 60-year-old Hussain, despondent in the deserted station at Rawalpindi, fears none of that will come soon enough.

Desperate to repay a 70,000 rupee ($780) debt for his daughters' dowries, he waits interminably. When a train eventually splutters into view, the hustle and bustle ends in moments. He feels the debt getting heavier on his shoulders.

“In past, I could earn up to 500 rupees ($5.50) a day, now I hardly earn 150 rupees ($1.60) which I spend on the day's meal,” he said.


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

Comments (8) Closed

hassan Dec 21, 2011 04:03pm
please its not Pakistan which has driven railways towards ruin rather its the incompetent ministers and officials. Please change the headline to "Incompetent and corrupt officials drive railways to ruin".
p r sharma Dec 21, 2011 07:50pm
change of article's headline will not solve the problem in railways. sickness has to be diagnosed by and remedial measures be sincerely implemented. Public private partnership in some part of railway operations, particularly goods movement has achieved better results in many other countries. improvement in goods' transport services shall definitely improve revenue generation and shall be motivating force to the private & public sector both.
Umer Hasan Dec 21, 2011 09:16pm
The Trains in Pakistan are out dated, model wise and every thing from inside out needs to go away.. the entire trains need to go away..A deal with china should be made to fix the entire problem.
Deepak manchanda Dec 22, 2011 03:06am
Pakistan railways should not rely on china, india or any other country too much. The most positive way to make profit is through freight trains. Running passenger trains on small routes (till enough funds are collected). Pakistan should ask india for the spare parts, if any, could be provided. As pakistan has declared india the most favored nation, i think india would surely help out something.
Janakiram Dec 24, 2011 08:28am
The Pak govt for the time being shall bail out by giving loan so that the Railways can buy good machinery and build necessary infrastructure. But later, it should be allowed to live with it's own resource. This will improve quality and performance. In India, the nationalized banks, telecom(BSNL) are working in the similar fashion.
vivek sehgal Dec 25, 2011 12:10am
one solution to this problem which has helped india and can help pakistan too is to reduce the turn around time for fraight trains. its the time that a train takes to go from point a to point b unload and come back. india increased its 40% profit from fraight trains without increasing a single engine or train just by reducing turn around time from 7 days to 5 effectively increasing the haulage. The chap who was the brain behind this was a delhi school of economics graduate(IAS) and the mantri was our very dear joker lallu prasad yadav.i referred the names of these two people coz i believe that pakistan too can achieve alot despite their cartoon politicians.
SBMishra Dec 25, 2011 02:30pm
The working conditions and climate in Pakistan and India are similar. The Chinese machines will not be durable in pakistan. Instead pakistan should ask for indian desiel and electric locomotives. They are cheap,reliable,easily maintainable,made to operate under harsh hot weather conditions suitable to Pakistan. Moreover spare parts are readily available and very cheap.Every thing that Pakistani railway needs is availabe in India.
Usman Dec 25, 2011 03:47pm
Two words - Privatization and Deregulation. $390 million for PR, $800 million PIA, Pakistan cannot afford this, why should people who will never fly in a plane or people who don't use the railway subsidize these?