ECONOMIST Daron Acemoglu and his co-authors recently won the economics Nobel Prize for their work on institutions. Interestingly, there is a critique of Acemoglu’s work about which not many people know. Prof Mushtaq Khan at the School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS), who is inspired by the Marxist theory, has been hugely critical of Acemoglu’s work. Taking cue from the professor, I also critiqued Acemoglu’s famous book, Why Nations Fail, in my doctoral thesis.

The main criticism of Acemoglu’s work is that his interpretation of history is ahistorical. His team has given many examples of ‘virtuous’ and ‘vicious’ economic and political institutions in history whereby the societies that had ‘virtuous’ political institutions led to economic growth as, in his view, democ-racy and rule of law helped the countries grow economically.

In contrast, the countries that had ‘vicious’ political and social institutions deteriorated economically.

The flaw in this argument is that the research team took the coming together of these political and economic institutions as a given, and did not explain why some countries had ‘virtuous’ institutions and others had ‘vicious’.

In the political economy analysis offered by the likes of Prof Mushtaq and others, mature and inclusive political institutions evolved due to structural changes in the economy, and the ‘virtuous’ institutions were the result of structural transformation, and not the cause of it. In other words, Acemoglu and his colla-borators figured out the incorrect sequ-ence of causality.

The Marxist analysis offers a much better explanation of historical change by trying to understand the capitalist transformation. Capitalism, which was born out of a violent process of colonialism, slavery and land-snatching, led to limited democracy. Acemoglu skipped all that structural and theoretical rigour.

Foqia Sadiq Khan
Islamabad

Published in Dawn, January 15th, 2025

Opinion

Editorial

IMF scrutiny
Updated 11 Feb, 2025

IMF scrutiny

Strengthening foundations of the economic superstructure will help make the economy competitive and boost growth.
Shadow voices
11 Feb, 2025

Shadow voices

OVER the weekend, another ‘open letter’ addressed to the army chief and attributed to former prime minister ...
Paradise at a premium
11 Feb, 2025

Paradise at a premium

PAKISTAN’S recent triumph at the New York Travel and Adventure Show 2025, winning the Best Partner Pavilion Award,...
A positive note
Updated 10 Feb, 2025

A positive note

With govt unable to press growth accelerator without upending fragile recovery, sufferings of low-middle-income households are unlikely to disappear soon.
Justice for all
10 Feb, 2025

Justice for all

ALONG with his domestic agenda, Donald Trump is busy ripping to shreds the post-World War II ‘rules-based...
Held back
10 Feb, 2025

Held back

IT is a crying shame how women are conspicuously absent from Pakistan’s civil services. Despite comprising half ...