Beyond HOTA

Published December 13, 2024

IN a welcome demonstration of HOTA’s oversight role, kidney transplant services have been suspended at Islamabad’s Max Health Hospital. The healthcare facility was found non-compliant with rules mandating the formation of an evaluation committee for transplant cases. Such regulatory interventions are essential given our troubling history with organ trafficking, where unscrupulous elements have exploited the desperate poor while catering to wealthy patients seeking quick transplants. Requiring the formation of an inquiry committee to investigate irregularities shows the authorities are taking their mandate seriously.

However, much more needs to be done. Despite legislation in 2010 criminalising organ trade, the practice has seen periodic resurgence, with criminal networks adapting their operations. Recent cases show how vulnerable populations, especially bonded labourers and the indebted poor, continue to be targeted by organ trafficking rings. The exploitation chain typically involves middlemen, compromised medical facilities, and even officials willing to look the other way — all profiting from human desperation. Action is needed on multiple fronts. To begin with, evaluation committees at hospitals must exercise stringent oversight of transplant cases to prevent commercial exploitation. Alongside, law enforcement needs to proactively investigate and prosecute organ trafficking networks rather than waiting for complaints. Moreover, the healthcare system must be strengthened to provide affordable dialysis and transplant services to reduce desperate measures by patients. Most critically, Pakistan needs to develop a robust organ donation culture. Religious scholars have already clarified that organ donation is permissible to save lives. Public awareness campaigns highlighting how a single deceased donor can save multiple lives could help overcome cultural barriers. The successful cornea donation programme with Sri Lanka shows such initiatives are possible. Ultimately, ending organ trafficking needs addressing the crushing poverty that forces people to sell body parts. Until then, constant vigilance and deterrent action remain crucial.

Published in Dawn, December 13th, 2024

Opinion

Editorial

Race against time
Updated 09 Feb, 2025

Race against time

While some bright spots emerged at Breathe Pakistan moot, we must streamline our climate governance.
Open door
09 Feb, 2025

Open door

THE door is still open for talks, National Assembly Speaker Ayaz Sadiq has reminded the PTI. What matters, however,...
Football suspension
09 Feb, 2025

Football suspension

ONCE again, Pakistan has been ousted from the global football family. FIFA recently suspended the Pakistan Football...
A year later
Updated 08 Feb, 2025

A year later

A war of egos has been fought between a handful of individuals at the cost of the well-being of millions of ordinary Pakistanis.
Wheat decision
08 Feb, 2025

Wheat decision

THE federal decision to stop setting the minimum support price for wheat and cease the staple’s procurement...
Dhanmondi attack
08 Feb, 2025

Dhanmondi attack

HISTORY has shown that unless states deliver development and equal rights to all, disenfranchised people can target...