Email

Banned: What does the TLP want?

A look at the demands put forward by the group, its negotiations with the government and the violence that ensued.
Published 20 Apr, 2021 04:41pm

Protests erupted across major cities in Pakistan on April 12 after the now-proscribed Tehreek-i-Labbaik Pakistan (TLP) chief Saad Hussain Rizvi was detained by security forces in Lahore as a "pre-emptive measure" ahead of the party's April 20 deadline to the government.

The deadline pertains to the party's demands from last year; in October, a history teacher who had shown blasphemous sketches of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) in class was decapitated and his assailant shot dead by French police as they tried to arrest him. In the days that followed the beheading, the caricatures were projected onto the facade of a building in one French city and people displayed them at protests around the country.

Following the killing, French President Emmanuel Macron criticised Islamists and vowed not to “give up cartoons” depicting Prophet Muhammad. Prime Imran Khan as well as other leaders of Muslim countries had denounced the French premier's comments while countrywide protests were held calling for boycott of French products.

Here, Dawn.com looks at the demands put forward by the TLP after the publication of the blasphemous caricatures in France and a timeline of its negotiations with the PTI-led government and the ensuing violence that led to the party being banned:

Karachi rally against France — Nov 7, 2020

The TLP rally makes its way down Sharea Faisal. — AFP
The TLP rally makes its way down Sharea Faisal. — AFP

TLP stages a big rally on Sharea Faisal in Karachi, demanding cutting of diplomatic ties with Paris and a boycott of French products.

The TLP asks the federal government to take “practical steps” otherwise it would be compelled to take “extreme action”.

The rally is led by then-TLP chief Allama Khadim Hussain Rizvi, who urges the federal government to “declare jihad” against France.

Talks starts ahead of march — Nov 12, 2020

TLP announces the ‘Tahafuz Namoos-i-Risalat’ march from Liaquat Bagh Rawalpindi to Faizabad in Islamabad on November 15.

Talks between the capital administration and TLP leaders start while the party seeks security cover for the protest rally.

A team of administration officers try to convince the TLP leaders and organisers of the rally to call it off due to Covid-19 spreading all over the country, including Islamabad.

Security tightened, arrests made — Nov 14, 2020

A view of Murree Road blocked with containers before TLP activists approach Islamabad. — Mohammad Asim/White Star
A view of Murree Road blocked with containers before TLP activists approach Islamabad. — Mohammad Asim/White Star

Blockades are installed at different entry points of the capital, including Faizabad, with the deployment of police and the paramilitary force to stop the protest rally of TLP from entering the city.

Meanwhile, police and other law enforcement agencies detain 181 leaders and activists of the TLP in different parts of Rawalpindi and send 65 of them to Adiala jail after producing them in courts.

TLP activists, police clash — Nov 15, 2020

Security personnel stand at Murree Road to prevent violence by TLP activists camped at Faizabad. — Mohammad Asim/White Star
Security personnel stand at Murree Road to prevent violence by TLP activists camped at Faizabad. — Mohammad Asim/White Star

Liaquat Bagh presents a scene of a battleground as police and stick-wielding activists of TLP clashed throughout the day.

The protesters, whose number was officially given at about 3,000, manage to reach Faizabad Interchange where they stage a sit-in.

Riot police resort to teargas shelling against the stone-pelting protesters. During the clashes, dozens of police personnel and several TLP activists are injured and shifted to hospitals.

“Heavy teargas shelling also affected residents of the adjoining areas with many complaining of difficulty in breathing,” a resident of a locality near Liaquat Bagh says.

Govt accepts 'all demands' — Nov 16, 2020

Sitting around empty tear-gas shells fired by the police, TLP supporters shout slogans during an anti-France demonstration. — AFP
Sitting around empty tear-gas shells fired by the police, TLP supporters shout slogans during an anti-France demonstration. — AFP

TLP announces that the government accepted all its four demands and releases a copy of the handwritten agreement carrying signatures of Minister for Religious Affairs Pir Noorul Qadri, Interior Minister Ijaz Shah and Islamabad deputy commissioner.

The agreement says government will

  • take a decision from the Parliament regarding expulsion of the French ambassador within three months
  • not appoint its ambassador to France
  • release all the arrested workers of the TLP
  • not register any case against the TLP leaders or workers even after it calls off the sit-in

There is no immediate confirmation from the government of the agreement, but the interior ministry issues a notification regarding immediate release of all those arrested during the past two days from different parts of Punjab.

New leader, fresh warning — Jan 3

Activists and supporters of TLP gather for the funeral prayer of Khadim Hussain Rizvi in Lahore. — AFP
Activists and supporters of TLP gather for the funeral prayer of Khadim Hussain Rizvi in Lahore. — AFP

The party’s new young leader, Hafiz Saad Rizvi, is appointed as his father’s successor shortly after the death of TLP founder Allama Khadim Rizvi on November 19, 2020.

In the first week of the new year, TLP threatens to relaunch its protest if the government does not fulfil its promise of expelling the French ambassador by Feb 17.

“We’re bound to honour the agreement till Feb 17. A war for (protecting) the honour of the Prophet (SAW) has been waged. If someone has some misunderstanding, it must be removed as we pledge that there shall be no delay in taking a decision after February 17,” the newly appointed leader of the TLP says at the chehlum of his father.

“If you have forgotten the promise, see our history [...] You’ve got time until Feb 17 to expel the French ambassador,” Saad warns the government while addressing thousands of the TLP workers attending the chehlum.

TLP's new agreement with govt — Feb 11

TLP calls off its protest after a new agreement is signed between the party leaders and the government in which it is decided that the latter would present the terms of an agreement signed between them last year in the parliament before April 20.

Prime Minister Imran Khan also says that as decided in the renewed agreement, his government would take the matter to parliament before April 20. The prime minster reminds the TLP that it must not forget that no one has done more than him to internationally highlight the issue of blasphemy, not because of the TLP but because it was an article of his faith.

According to the TLP, the government team expressed its inability to “implement” the agreement and wanted the TLP leadership to stop protesting. “The TLP, however, refused to budge and warned the government to act or risk protest,” says party.

After protracted rounds of negotiations, the government team agrees to meet all the demands by April 20.

If the parties involved undertake any activity that is contradictory to the spirit of the agreement before April 20, it shall be considered void, the text of the agreement says.

TLP chief Saad Rizvi detained — April 12

TLP chief Saad Rizvi being taken into custody in Lahore. — Screengrab
TLP chief Saad Rizvi being taken into custody in Lahore. — Screengrab

TLP naib emir Syed Zaheerul Hassan Shah says the government "completely deviated from" the agreement it had reached with the TLP regarding Namoos-i-Risalat.

Shah calls upon TLP leaders and workers to "come out on the roads" in their areas in protest against the government action.

TLP member Khalid Awan tells Dawn that government had "turned back on its promise" to expel the French ambassador by April 20 and took Rizvi into custody.

"We will not step back from our mission because of Saad Rizvi's arrest."

Protests continue, LEAs clear twin cities — April 13, 14

Policemen detain a TLP supporter in Rawalpindi. — AFP
Policemen detain a TLP supporter in Rawalpindi. — AFP

At least one police constable is martyred and 40 other personnel injured in Lahore as violent protests continue for a second day.

Meanwhile, Pakistan Rangers, Elite Force, Punjab constabulary and district police clear Liaquat Bagh of TLP activists by using tear gas shells and rubber bullets. According to sources, 135 law enforcement officials, including six Rangers were injured in the violent clash in Rawalpindi division.

Life in capital returns to normalcy as the local police succeed in removing TLP activists from Barakahu, Tarnol and Rawat.

Govt bans TLP as death toll rises — April 15

The federal government formally bans TLP as death of martyred police official rises to four while the French embassy in Pakistan advises all French nationals and companies to temporarily leave the country.

A notification declaring TLP as a proscribed organisation says government "has reasonable grounds to believe that Tehreek Labbaik Pakistan is engaged in terrorism, acted in a manner prejudicial to the peace and security of the country, involved in creating anarchy in the country by intimidating the public, caused grievous bodily harm, hurt and death to the personnel of Law Enforcement Agencies and innocent by-standers [...] blocked essential health supplies to hospitals, and has used, threatened, coerced, intimidated, and overawed the government [and] the public and created sense of fear and insecurity in the society and the public at large".

Read: Banning Mr Rizvi

Interior Minister Sheikh Rashid says the government "tried its best" to resolve matters through negotiations but TLP's "intentions were very horrifying".

"They did not want to step back from their agenda for April 20 at any cost."

Social media temporarily blocked — April 16

The Ministry of Interior directs the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) to temporarily block access to social media platforms — Twitter, Facebook, WhatsApp, YouTube and Telegram — from 11am to 3pm.

"It is requested that immediate action may be taken on the subject matter," the ministry directs the PTA chairman, after which the PTA releases an official statement saying: "In order to maintain public order and safety, access to certain social media applications has been restricted temporarily."

Later, in a video message, Sheikh Rashid apologises to the public for the hours-long blockage of the applications, saying the government will "try not to [restrict] social media in the future".

Lahore becomes battleground as 5 policemen taken hostage — April 18

Security personnel walk back after having a talk with TLP supporters during a protest along a blocked street in Lahore. — AFP
Security personnel walk back after having a talk with TLP supporters during a protest along a blocked street in Lahore. — AFP

TLP workers "brutally torture" a deputy superintendent of police (DSP) and take him as well as four other officials hostage, says spokesperson for Lahore CCPO Rana Arif.

Police say the violence occurred after "miscreants" attacked a police station and abducted the DSP, adding that it acted only in "self-defence".

An official report shows 15 injured police personnel under treatment at different hospitals in the city. Meanwhile, at least three protesters killed and several others injured during the clash, according to the party's workers.

Talks restart, policemen released — April 19

Interior Minister Sheikh Rashid in the early hours of April 19 announces that after the first rounds of talks with TLP, 11 policemen who were taken hostage in Lahore have been released.

"Talks have started with the TLP. The first round went well and the second round will take place after sehri," Rashid says in a video message. "They have released 11 policemen who were made hostages and have themselves gone into the Rehmatul Lil Alameen Mosque [Yateem Khana Chowk]. The police have also stepped back."

The minister expressed hope that the rest of the matters would be resolved with the TLP in the second round of talks.

Later in the evening, in a televised address to the nation, Prime Minister Imran referred to the violence perpetrated by TLP activists and the ensuing government crackdown as "regrettable" incidents.

Imran said like the TLP, the government too wanted that there was no blasphemy against the Prophet (PBUH) in any country.

"Only our methods are different," he said, noting that while the TLP wanted the French ambassador to be expelled and Pakistan's relations to be severed with France, his government had adopted a different strategy.

Read more here.

TLP calls off protest, NA is convened — April 20

Interior Minister Rashid says TLP has agreed to call off protests across the country, adding, "talks with the party will continue".

A National Assembly session is convened after Rashid's announcement that the government would present a resolution on the expulsion of the French ambassador in the parliament.


Header image: Supporters of Tehreek-i-Labbaik Pakistan gather as they block a street during a protest in Lahore on April 18. — AFP