Dr Muhammad Reza Kazimi speaks at the event.—White Star
Dr Muhammad Reza Kazimi speaks at the event.—White Star

KARACHI: A discussion led by historian Dr Muhammad Reza Kazimi on Stanley Wolpert’s book Jinnah of Pakistan was held at the Pakistan Institute of International Affairs (PIIA) on Wednesday evening.

Introducing the programme chairperson of the institute Dr Masuma Hasan said it was being held in honour of Mr Wolpert’s memory, who died on Feb 19 last year. Apart from the book under discussion, she took the names of some of his other books such as Nehru: A Tryst with Destiny; Zulfi Bhutto of Pakistan: His Life and Times; Gandhi’s Passion: The Life and Legacy of Mahatma Gandhi; and India and Pakistan: Continued Conflict or Cooperation. She told the audience that he wasn’t just a historian but was also a fiction writer. He came to the PIIA in 1989 where he first met Dr Kazimi.

Dr Kazimi then came to the podium and gave his truncated view of Jinnah of Pakistan, because he skipped quite a few passages of his presentation. He started with points raised by a former US ambassador to India John Kenneth Galbraith’s review of Mr Wolpert’s book in the Washington Post in 1984 and then examined the author’s point about Jinnah’s ‘pride’.

But it was the question and answer session that followed the talk which proved more interesting. Responding to a question about certain omissions from his talk Dr Kazimi said Gandhi did ask Jinnah to become the prime minster of India to avoid partition, but Jinnah turned it down as it was mentioned in V.P. Menon’s book.

On another point he said Motilal Nehru was not a revivalist Hindu. If there’s a psychological factor to the partition of India, then it’s Jawaharlal Nehru’s aversion to his father. It was Motilal who tried to make Jinnah oppose Gandhi’s noncooperation resolution. “Even if he had been a revivalist, then how did Jinnah and Lokmanya Gangadhar Tilak get on?” It was the power orientation of Gandhi and Nehru which created the situation [leading to partition events].

‘Gandhi forced the Indian government to transfer financial assets to Pakistan’

Dr Kazimi said Jinnah exercised all options available to him. Liaquat Ali Khan had opposed the Cabinet Mission Plan. But in spite of such a strong objection from a strong personality, Jinnah had tried to give peace a chance. “Riots did not occur because of the partition of India, they occurred because of the partition of the provinces,” which had not been agreed to. As Jinnah came out of Mountbatten’s room after a meeting, he said partition was inevitable. Mountbatten and Nehru tried to remove Gandhi from the scene, sent him to Calcutta and in reply Gandhi called Nehru up. Two days before his [Gandhi’s] assassination he was saying that the Congress should be disbanded. Wolpert in his Gandhi’s Passion wrote that Gandhi wanted to become the first governor-general of Pakistan, but Mountbatten and Nehru frustrated him. That was why Gandhi forced the Indian government to transfer financial assets to Pakistan.

Dr Kazimi said it’s true that Jinnah did not want Mountbatten to become the common governor-general of India and Pakistan because it would undo partition. But Jinnah had not nominated himself; he had nominated the nawab of Bhopal. Referring to a book by Inam Aziz, Dr Kazimi said at a Muslim League council meeting every aspect was discussed, and finally on the intervention of Sir Ghulam Husain Hidayatullah partition was agreed upon. Then Jinnah made a speech. Maulana Hasrat Mohani spoke and said nobody except Quaid-i-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah could become the governor-general of Pakistan.

Published in Dawn, February 21st, 2020

Opinion

Missing I.A. Rehman’s wisdom
18 Apr 2021

Missing I.A. Rehman’s wisdom

Does the state of Pakistan, all institutions included, have the political will to address the runaway intolerance in society and
Ostrich approach
18 Apr 2021

Ostrich approach

The logic of blocking social media to contain protests is flawed.
Wings of mediation
18 Apr 2021

Wings of mediation

ADR benefits could ensure the expeditious settlement of tax disputes.
Banning Mr Rizvi
17 Apr 2021

Banning Mr Rizvi

Sooner than later, fanatics start to pull their own strings.

Editorial

18 Apr 2021

More cabinet changes

PRIME MINISTER Imran Khan has reshuffled his cabinet yet again in what is obviously another attempt to shore up his...
Blocking social media
Updated 18 Apr 2021

Blocking social media

FOR four hours this week, all social media platforms in the country were shut down, a measure the government said ...
18 Apr 2021

Peasant rights in Sindh

IN a seminar held in Nawabshah recently, the Sindh Human Rights Commission and Hari Welfare Association reiterated a...
17 Apr 2021

Pak-India mediation

QUESTIONS had been swirling about what and who has prompted the latest detente between Pakistan and India. Now, it...
17 Apr 2021

Energy exploration

SOME exploration and production companies want the government to prioritise offshore exploration — a high-risk...
17 Apr 2021

Professor’s removal

IN a step that will go far in sending a message of reassurance to female students and academic staff in ...