New NZ Test pitch under scrutiny as Williamson, Nicholls fall foul

November 23, 2019


NEW ZEALAND captain Kane Williamson ducks under a rising delivery during the first Test against England at the Bay Oval on Friday.
NEW ZEALAND captain Kane Williamson ducks under a rising delivery during the first Test against England at the Bay Oval on Friday. —Reuters

MOUNT MAUNGANUI: The manner of New Zealand skipper Kane Williamson’s dismissal and a blow to the head of Henry Nicholls put the pitch in Mount Maunganui under scrutiny with three days to play in the first Test against England on Friday.

In the first Test at the ground, the Bay Oval pitch showed signs of becoming unpredictable late on day two. And although honours appeared even after the first two days, England believe if the playing surface continues to deteriorate then they are in the box seat.

New Zealand go into day three on Saturday at 144 for four in reply to England’s first innings 353, but with senior batsmen Williamson and Ross Taylor already dismissed.

Williamson had cruised to 51, reaching his half-century with a boundary off seamer Sam Curran, but fell on the next delivery which unexpectedly reared sharply, forcing the New Zealand skipper to take evasive action and the ball was gloved to second slip.

The dismissal even took Curran by surprise, but he saw it as a good omen.

“It probably took off a little

bit more than the usual length but that’s a really good sign for us knowing we have runs on the board,” he said.

“The pitch may start being a bit uneven and fingers crossed that suits us and there can be a few more [wickets] and it gets worse as the game goes on, because most likely we’ll be bowling last.”

New Zealand’s senior paceman Tim Southee, who ignited the demise of the England middle and lower order when the pitch was playing true, said Williamson’s dismissal raised questions.

“That’s the unknown about playing a first Test match on this ground. He was looking reasonably comfortable and he got one that reared off a length which can happen,” Southee said, wary of having to bat last.

“If it does continue to deteriorate and we do start to see a bit more

of it going up and down we’d like to get as many as we can in this innings.”

Nicholls, who was not out on 26, was felled by a sharp bouncer from Jofra Archer but a medical check showed no immediate sign of concussion, although he will undergo a further examination before resuming on Saturday.

The unpredictable wicket was not the only source of drama with New Zealand ruing a missed review and nearly being made to pay for signing too many autographs.

Opener Tom Latham, given out leg before wicket on eight, walked without seeking a review, unaware of an inside edge that was detected by Hot Spot.

Earlier the exit of Jos Buttler for 43 had spectators scrambling through the rule book as he was caught by Mitchell Santner, who had been off the field of play when Neil Wagner prepared to bowl.

Santner had to stop signing autographs, leap the advertising hoardings and enter the playing area to take the catch, which appeared to contradict rules about player movement and a batter’s right to know field placements.

Buttler, though, had no objections as he walked off immediately.

After England resumed the day at 241-4, Stokes and Ollie Pope advanced the total to 277 when Southee struck with three wickets in 11 balls including the prized scalp of Stokes for 91.

Stokes was eyeing his ninth Test century when he was caught one-handed at first slip by a diving Taylor, who had dropped the all-rounder before stumps the previous day.

Buttler and Leach forged a late 52-run stand but otherwise there was little England resistance at the bottom of the order.

Southee finished with 4-88 and Wagner took 3-90, while Curran was the pick of England’s bowlers with 2-28.


ENGLAND (1st Innings, overnight 241-4):

R.J. Burns c Watling b de Grandhomme 52
D.P. Sibley c Taylor b de Grandhomme 22
J.L. Denly c Watling b Southee 74
J.E. Root c Southee b Wagner 2
B.A. Stokes c Taylor b Southee 91
O.J. Pope c Watling b Southee 29
J.C. Buttler c Santner b Wagner 43
S.M. Curran lbw b Southee 0
J.C. Archer c Southee b Boult 4
M.J. Leach not out 18
S.C.J. Broad b Wagner 1
EXTRAS (B-2, LB-11, W-3, NB-1) 17
TOTAL (all out, 124 overs) 353
FALL OF WKTS: 1-52, 2-113, 3-120, 4-203, 5-277, 6-286, 7-286, 8-295, 9-347. BOWLING: Boult 31-6-97-1 (1w); Southee 32-7-88-4; de Grandhomme 23-5-41-2 (1nb, 1w); Wagner 32-7-90-3 (1w); Santner 6-1-24-0.

NEW ZEALAND (1st Innings);

J.A. Raval c Denly b Leach 19
T.W.M. Latham lbw b Curran 8
K.S. Williamson c Stokes b Curran 51
L.R.P.L. Taylor c Pope b Stokes 25
H.M. Nicholls not out 26
B.J. Watling not out 6
EXTRAS (B-9) 9
TOTAL (for four wkts, 51 overs) 144
FALL OF WKTS: 1-18, 2-72, 3-106, 4-127. TO BAT: C. de Grandhomme, M.J. Santner, T.G. Southee, N. Wagner, T.A. Boult. BOWLING (to-date): Broad 10-4-20-0; Archer 14-4-40-0; Curran 10-4-28-2; Leach 12-1-29-1; Stokes 4-0-16-1; Root 1-0-2-0.

Published in Dawn, November 23rd, 2019