ISTANBUL: Nato apologised to Turkey on Friday after Ankara pulled its troops from a military exercise in Norway to protest incidents deemed insulting to President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and the country’s modern founder Mustafa Kemal Ataturk.

The alliance’s Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg, himself Norwegian, moved quickly to say sorry after an angry intervention by Erdogan on an episode that risked creating further strife between Turkey and its allies.

The incidents took place during Nato’s “Trident Javelin” exercise in the southern Norwegian city of Stavanger aimed at increasing coordination between the allies at headquarters level, which wound up Friday.

Erdogan said that Ankara had withdrawn its 40 troops from the exercise in protest, adding: “It’s not possible to have this kind of alliance.”

Norway’s Defence Minister Frank Bakke-Jensen, speaking to AFP, also expressed “regret” over the incident.

Nato gave no details on the nature of the incident, saying only that “offence had been caused”.

But Turkey’s state-run Anadolu news agency said that an image of Ataturk had been used to portray an enemy protagonist in a scenario.

In a second incident a chat account was opened under Erdogan’s name during a virtual scenario as a collaborator with a “leader of an enemy state”.

Without going into detail, Erdogan said an image of Ataturk and his own name were used “and these were the targets”.

He said Turkey’s top general Hulusi Akar and EU Affairs Minister Omer Celik — who were on their way to a Nato conference in Halifax, Canada — had informed him of the incident.

“They said ‘this has happened... and we are going to take out our 40 soldiers’,” Erdogan said while speaking in front of giant pictures of himself and Ataturk. “And I said ‘Absolutely, don’t hesitate, take them out right now’.”

Ataturk founded modern Turkey out of the ruins of the Ottoman Empire in 1923 and is widely credited with salvaging a functioning Turkish state in the 1919-23 War of Independence.

Insulting his memory is a criminal offence in Turkey that is punishable by jail.

While critics accuse Erdogan of tainting the secular vision of Ataturk, the president has in recent months made increasingly clear his admiration for Turkey’s modern founder.

On the Nov 10 anniversary of Ataturk’s death in 1938, Erdogan eulogised Turkey’s first president, saying he should be remembered with “grace and gratitude”.

Turkey, which became a member of Nato in 1952, is a key member of the alliance but tensions have grown in recent months over its crackdown after a failed coup and Ankara’s increasingly close alliance with Russia.

Its Western allies have been particularly troubled by a deal for Ankara to purchase an S-400 air defence system from Russia and the cooperation between Ankara, Moscow and Tehran on the Syria crisis.

Stoltenberg, a former Norwegian prime minister, in his apology emphasised the importance of Turkey within the alliance.

“I apologise for the offence that has been caused. The incidents were the result of an individual’s actions and do not reflect the views of Nato,” Stoltenberg said in a statement. “Turkey is a valued Nato ally, which makes important contributions to allied security.”

The Trident Javelin exercise in Stavanger is described on a Nato website as a “computer assisted exercise without troops on the ground”, aimed at improving command structures for major operations.

Stoltenberg also said the individual responsible for the incident was not a Nato staff member.

“He was a civilian contractor seconded by Norway and not a Nato employee,” Stoltenberg said. “It will be for the Norwegian authorities to decide on any disciplinary action. Nato has been in contact with the Norwegian authorities on this issue.”

Anadolu said the “technician” who made the error was not aware that the image used had showed Ataturk and had apologised.

Published in Dawn, November 18th, 2017



28 Jan, 2022

Never-ending debate

PAKISTAN is gripped by a debate on the presidential system, again. From apparently nowhere, calls for this system...
28 Jan, 2022

Riverfront verdict

THE Lahore High Court decision scrapping the controversial multibillion-dollar Ravi Riverfront Urban Development...
Karachi violence
Updated 28 Jan, 2022

Karachi violence

WEDNESDAY’S events in Karachi indicate that unless the controversy over the Sindh local government law is handled...
Corruption index
27 Jan, 2022

Corruption index

The Transparency report punches a hole in the self-righteous façade of a party that has long beaten the drum of accountability.
27 Jan, 2022

Oslo meeting

A DILEMMA continues to confront the international community where Afghanistan is concerned: whether or not to...
27 Jan, 2022

Sanitary workers’ rights

RELIGIOUS discrimination in Pakistan has many faces and one of its most troubling manifestations is the virtual...