What's the proof??

Shame on India and Afghanistan. This will back eventually.

RAW you will never be successful in your plans - EVER - PERIOD!

Pakistan must produce evidence of RAW and NDS involvement.

ISIS already claimed responsibility for quetta attack

Thought home grown Lashkar-e-Jhangvi took the responsibility.

@raj Kalbhushan Yadav!

Proofs required please

Who indoctrinated these kids to become suicide bombers? Reach them. There is no other way to end this menace.

The American people and Washington not so willing to help Pakistan anymore. That's the truth. Intelligence sharing is as far as we can go. We are always willing to do that. The rest is up to you.

Hope the NSA gave concrete proof to the US ambassador. Proofs such as voice recordings, GPS used by the terrorists etc. They should also provide details of the handlers and their training camps.

What makes you think that u.s. is not???

finally they are talking

@raj when your government blames us do you react the same way?

Someone has said that if you don't accept the real cause of problem you will be never able to address that problem. If things continue like this authorities will just keep on blaming RAW and NDS and root cause of problem will be never addrsessed. Better they realize soon....

Not surprised. They have been doing terrorism in Pakistan from last decade

Pakisthan must give actionable intelligience.

Indian government and military are involved with the help of Afghan puppet government. Pakistan establishment must give them befitting reply otherwise these enemies will be succeed.

If RAW and NDS involve in such activities then it failure of our agencies.

The world will change in 10 years time. India will come begging for talks.

This has become trend to put blame on foreign agencies. The question is when these foreign agencies are active why our security forces are inactive??

@amin no we provide you the proof and concrete proof at that.

Afghanistan and India will pay heavy price for it

This is absolutely the work of RAW, it has its prints all over on this attack.

Sorry correct me if I am wrong. Did ISIS not claim the responsibility for the attacks? Does anyone has proof of India's involvement.

@Friend totally agree with you

@raj "What's the proof??"

Modi himself and his words that he spoke on your national day about Baluchistan. Do you deny that?

ISIS claimed the responsibility. How can you blame India?

@SFthe Bcoz India is supporting ISIS in Afghanistan. Clear !!!

US will not do anything. They are themselves playing the double game. Best to initiate your own intel sources in Afghanistan and take these murderers out without any mercy.

why India has so many consulates near the pakistan border in Afghanistan? India it self being one of the poorest country giving billions of $ to Afghanistan why?

Pakistan will give never healing wounds to the enemy!

Match goes on - Pakistan blames India and India blames Pakistan. During this never ending drama - innocent civilians on both sides continue to die. SHAME.
Hope and pray that at some point in due time, some SANE minds will take a strong exception and try to get rid of this menace - mercilessly and without any hidden agenda

@SFthe we all know who launched ISIS in Afghanistan using their embassies in Syria

Shame on india and Afghanistan.

@Changez Khan; Very interesting comment; hope the world and US can read your PRINTS.

India investings billions in Afghanistan for launching terror attacks in pakistan.

@Sajid You must be talking about ISIS in Afghanistan which somehow does not target any Indian interests but for some reason have bone to pick with Pakistan. Why would ISIS target police cadets in Quetta of all places? No matter which way you cut it, RAW and NDS hands will be most visible.

@raj The proofs: a) Modi's recent threatening comments against Pakistan, b) increasing RAW offices on Afghanistan border and c) Kulbhushen Yadav who is an Indian spy caught promoting terrorism in Pakistan as admitted by himself. Indian officials have also taken ownership of this terror-promoting spy.

As if US is unware of it .

India will never do such cruel things. India is a peace loving country.

ISIS and LeJ names are used by enemies as a cover-up.

ISIS = NDS LeJ = RAW

How can it be RAW when Lashkar e Jhangvi has claimed responsibility for the attack? LeJ is originating in Punjab. The problem is within

@amin we given strong proof each time. Ask your mind and you will get the truth

@Pakistani... you think you are asking pertinent questions. what you are doing is raising conspiracies!

Please stop this blame game. Eradicate all terrorists from the country. There are no good and bad terrorists. All terrorists are bad.

Attacks like these are happening in Pakistan since last 15 years. Modi is only in power since last 2 years. You are blaming us without any evidence,

How come these terrorists are able to move freely, carrying heavy weapons? Why not Government confiscate all weapons from all people?

It is the duty of the Government to protect its people, by eliminating all terrorists.

@raj Whats the proof you say. Well Pakistan caught one of Indias , serving Navy colonel yadove in Pakistan doing and directing terrorism, and bombing.

Shun extremism. Extremism leads to terrorism. Extremism and terrorism are two sides of the same coin. Moderate in everything is best.

@Talha good narrative

The only thing Pak can do is, highlight the Kashmir issue internationally and work towards an Independent Kashmir, this will shut India up. And at the same time, Pak should take action against the camps in Afghanistan. Whats the point of having all this high tech equipment, when you cant take action against your enemies living just next to you.

And the US response, predictably will be, "Pakistan needs to do more" to fight radicals.

The death of these young men is a tragedy. Heart goes out to their families.

@Self critical ISIS and TTP on Afghan soil is funded, supported and motivated by Indian Government and RAW.

LJ group originating from Pakistan may have joined IS, all these terror groups have same ideology so switching loyalties is simple. IS is gaining more popularity with their successes all over the world. It is important that terror groups are tackled unitedly by all countries, this political blame games help terror groups.

@Self critical Thanks for your insight Einstein, just because a group has claimed it, does not mean they were behind it. IS and LEJ both claimed it, yet they dont work with each other. You are gullible if you believe reports of groups claiming it. We all know who ordered and carried out the attack.

ISIS is claiming responsibility and they are blaming neighbors !!!

@A Reader from India! Precisely that, Pakistani people need to realize that some madrassas are connected in spreading terrorism!

@raj 1) Kalbhushan Yadav, 2) Indian Army weapons found in Afghanistan and Baluchistan, which by the way Indian authorities countered by saying that they were sold by traitorous Indian soldiers to the black market. Which black market, no one knows. 3) Modi's speech about Baluchistan and about destroying Pakistan.

@GHEUNTAAK ok here is the proof in USA you have 6 missions, in Saudia arab where millions of indian work you have only 2 missions,in uae there also millions of indian work 2 missions, in Bangladesh 3 and in Afghanistan you have 5 wow interesting.....

Can you not find out the nationality of the attackers?

@The Pakistan Lover Khulbhoosan Yadav was abducted from Iran he is a businessman.why no counselor access is given to him Pakistan should prove it courts if he is a spy

@Pakistani Who told you India is a poor country, its 7th biggest economy in the world...check your facts before commenting.

@Pakistani Maybe you are correct here, but remember it takes two to tango!!!! Both sides need to be flexible and stop living in the past. It's time India and Pakistan get smart, why not work like countries in EU?

Pakistan must produce evidence of RAW and NDS involvement.

@Mandy;

India has the largest bulk of people living below the poverty line.

@Indian;

' Khulbhoosan Yadav was abducted from Iran'

How come Iran didn't protest?

Where is the proof you did not even mention their names.

@raj do you have any proof of URI attack carried by Pakistan???????

@Napster;

' why not work like countries in EU? '

They don't have a caste system in Europe.

@Mustafa R. May be; But, Indians are peace loving people and living peacefully:)

@Mustafa R. , How do you expect that Governments will share everything with you?

Pakistan and India should not compete on violence.

@Mustafa R. What caste system has to do with business and prosperity? The entire world is trading with India.

This is sorry state of affairs, when Nawaz should have condemn the quetta attack, put pressure on Afghan and India by mentioning Modi recent hate speech and Yadav arrest inn Baluchistan

@Mustafa R. I have personally met Pakistanis here in America. I would say that everyone I have met has been very nice and friendly. So, kudos to that, but there was a common consensus, that your country is on wrong track and they agreed that India is way way better than Pakistan. Now, these are all highly skilled intelligent people who figured that life of an average Pakistani is not very good in Pakistan.

@raj this is the same type of proof that india provided United states (US) and us (pakistan) on pathankot. ie phone call record and tracings. Janjua wont go and talk to US ambassador without proof to get embarrassed? Second proof is Modi recent speech regarding baluchistan (which is a very big mistake by any premier in my opinion). Lastly Yadav arrest in baluchistan.

Complaining to US is not going to do anything. Just beef up your own capacity to fight back. To start with clean up refugee camps and dismantle any and all elements who show even a hint of disloyalty to Pakistan.

All terrorists are bad. Period.

@Mandy India has the largest number of poor people in the world. http://time.com/2999550/india-home-to-most-poor-people/

@Mustafa R. First of all get the facts right, your PM says one third of Pakistan lives below poverty line which is 34% whereas in India it is between 20 to 22%. India is 10 times bigger than Pakistan in terms of population and we still manage poverty much better than Pakistan.

R.I.P innocent souls.

@Pakistani India poorest country? Go check your figures mate.

Produce evidence. Give it to media

@raj "What's the proof??" Sir, writing is very much on the wall. These terroist events in Quetta happened after Modi's speech where he mentioned Balochistan what other proof do you want!!!

The term poverty is relevant. Everyone knows both countries have problems, so why not work together, even a 5 year old would understand this. Keep your differences aside, keep part of Kashmir you have with yourself and just move on.

@Pakistani India is a poorest country? its a 2.2 trillion dollar economy. worlds 7th largest. get your facts right.

Any terrorist attacks shall be condemned. According to US news, ISIS is responsible and ISIS showed the attackers photos in their web site. Why to blame unnecessarily India, which is nothing to do with this attack. This type of cruel attacks are highly condemned by any sensible thinker.

America is Blind and deef on Pakistan

@Umar from Dubai;

Even if I take your statistics India still has about 270 million people living below the poverty line, which is more than any other country, that is all I am trying to say. Same goes for bulk of illiterates, TB victims, leprosy victims, child labor, infant death, you name and India is shining.

What proof? We caught your active agents red handed. This will back fire soon.

pl provide actionable proof

@The Pakistan Lover then why did your prime minister not raise the Kulbushan Yadav issue in the UN General assembly?

There is nothing good coming out of the other side of the border from Afghanistan. Never have and never will be. Drugs, Weapons, smuggling, illegal trade, black money , terrorism, illegal immigrants and I can go on and on . If Pakistan needs prosperity and secure CPEC and improve its vision in the outside world it needs to first safe guard its interest ; it needs to build a wall between its borders of Afghanistan. As hard as it may be; we need to do this.

we should not always seek U.S help to resolve our issues. instead building cordial relations with neighbours should be our priority

@raj;

'What's the proof??'

Who is the judge? you don't provide proof to the accused!

@Napster;

' highly skilled intelligent people who figured that life of an average Pakistani is not very good in Pakistan.'

Rest assured USA has a lot more Indians than Pakistanis. who have also figured out that the life of an average Indian is not very good in India.

@Napster;

'What caste system has to do with business and prosperity?'

Wow!! what a question.

Any evidence?

Well said, everyone is aware of existing situation.

So what would have been US response to Pakistan's request?

@Akbar, The Great.

We have heard this argument before from Ajit doval

@Mustafa R. Haha really!!! Indians are smart, hard working, intelligent, peace living and sincere. They are ceos, doctors, engineers, scientists etc. It's called more opportunities. Jealous fool. I'm a surgeon. I love my country. I'm getting a chance to learn more so why not!!! Silly reply

I can say with pride and confidence that India is the most peace loving country in the world.

INDIA WANTS ONLY PEACE IN THIS REGION.

India has more Muslims than in Pakistan. India is elder brother. Though you hate us, we always want your friendship and relationship.

Now will you give some proof. .?

When not complaint every time to USA. It's like a child complaining to teacher. You can't get anything with this attitude. Rather change your approach with terrorists and try to change their mind set

Why do we continually believe the US Admin when they sympathize with our tragedies. They are not going to do anything for our country and never will. We need to look in the mirror and correct our own faults and build upon the True Patriotism of the majority of the population.

Seal the border with these 2 countries if you want to stop terror attack in Pakistan.

@Indian Indian spies especially a military officer don't get "consular access" when they are caught. Use some common sense. His capture and confession alone are sufficient truth

@Shahzeb What makes yu think that?

India and Afghanistan blaming Pak or Pak blaming Afghanistan and India for terrorism is unfortunate. All countries have to be sincere in tackling terrorism, no one should harbor and train terrorists for peace and prosperity in the region. Hope countries are mature and stop this terror games. Only talks and not terror is the solution to conflicts, keep talking for Trillion years for Trillions of times, with every talk many issues will be solved. Keep talking to solve conflicts of interests. Terror is not the solution but terror creates more problems, more animosity and more pain. Talks should be conducted in the absence of terror. Talk, Talk, Talk..............to Solution.

@Pakistani India is atleast richer than Pakistan, if you don't believe please refer GDP data of both India and Pakistan. Additionally, India is moving closer to middle income countries and in near future it is destined to become the third largest economy, it surely does have money.

LOL .............. in first place ISIS has already claimed responsibility ... 2ndly Why run to US everytime Paakistan has a problem ..... grow up solve your own problems

ridiculous.............. take proof when you accuse

Nothing changed even after many attacks, Same blame game and same way of fooling own public, and innocent readers get it the way its intended

@Changez Khan Show us the prints then

@Merchant Yes that's one solid proof Say the same to UN n see what response u get

Instead of making just allegations, it's better to talk with proof.

@aga khan - Wrong. Blame has no value. We don't give any credit to government for blaming Pakistan. Government must do their bit to prove why they are blaming someone and what action they are taking against it.

Government must know that no military operation against terrorists will ever work unless the border with Afghanistan is sealed and all the Afghan refugees are sent back to their country. Pakistan urgently needs to erect Laser security walls at the border with Afghanistan to stop terrorists crossing the border and entering into Pakistan.

@Talha - this is called bending the truth and lie.

@raj and what proof india has when it always blame Pakistan for everything that happens in india?

@Everyone... trace out from where the attackers came in and do the surgical strike.

Instead of doing tit for tat and blame one another, let us both fix our internal problems. How Pakistan will feel, if we say these are freedom fighters ? Terrorists are terrorists, not freedom fighters. We condemn this act of terrorists.

Stop this game of blaming foreign hand for our problem. This may be good for public consumption at home, no pays any attention to this at international level.

US is not neutral...Don't ask US...Retaliate in the same pattern and make them pay for their deeds..each and every Pakistani is behind the security agencies..

@Pakistani . Not as poor as you think my friend. We have helped when ever we could. Look at India's record over the last 20- years.

@Mustafa R. First of all India is a secular country and yes it has faced religious tensions , but overall people of all faiths including Jews can live here without fear. I am not here to compare who is better, truth doesn't need any defense. I agree that India should strive to get better and compete with the best, keep on spending money on education, free-market principles and innovation. Yes, it still has problems and eventually it will become a better country.

@Mustafa R. Again, I don't know why you disregard the numbers :) Indians are in fact present in most countries and have occupied prestigious positions and they are influencing the policies of the countries they live in. India has its fair share of problems, but it's also true that its becoming a better country. Again, I wish you best for your country, may it progress and becomes good neighbor of India.

@Akbar, The Great. Correct

@Sajid - "Sorry correct me if I am wrong. Did ISIS not claim the responsibility for the attacks? Does anyone has proof of India's involvement. '

When blaming India, Pakistan needs no proofs. And while arresting anti-Indian elements no amount of proof is enough for them.

@Mac. My heartfelt condolences brother but please do NOT blame any one without being able to substantiate it.I am a Hindu and can't see any one getting hurt not even animals let alone human beings.

@Talha this is not concrete proof. Give actionable evidence

@raj i wish you would ask modi the same question when your government blames pakistan with in 30 mins of any attacks.

@Muhammad . What is that as a %age of 1.3 billion my friend? Read my comment above.

@Mustafa R. In that case continue to accuse each other and make fool of each other in the eyes of the world. I am sure that's not the real answer to our problems. It's the lack of trust. .

Pakistan security has failed. Without evidence Pakistan shouldn't blame the neighbors Afghanistan and India.

Pakistan should present the dossier to Afghanistan government to take action against terrorists if Afghan nationals are involved in the attack. Pakistan shouldn't blame Afghanistan and India without evidence.

Pakistan's Zarb-e-Azb seems to be unsuccessful.

Wait if ISIS is claiming responsibility, how is india involved than?

When u point your finger at some one else's the thumb an three fingers always points towards you... Some of us have become so addicted to pointing fingers at others for all the wrong that happens in our lives that self-assessment has become synonymous with blaming.let us not play the blaming game instead let us develop the skill to tackle the issues at hand...

why to go and plea to the US each end every time... who are they to do the policing over other nations...!!! Eliminate US and other nations while dealing with the internal issues and bilateral issues ... the are not gonna solve that . They will just act for their own interest . THEY DONT WANT PEACE .

Before we put the blame on India or Afghanistan, we should bring the evidence.

India did not have this kind of policy.

When will Pakistani Military and Politicians face the TRUTH? NO ONE in the world believes these unsubstantiated, incredulous accusations.

Don't point fingers at others please fix your house first.

we all Indians condemn the dastardly attack. don't blame RAW for this. even a child on the streets of quetta won't believe you for that. But if RAW hands proven, we will topple our government. trust us , we Indians don't support terrorism. Please join hands against terrorism. don't take that shabby escape route of Kashmir.

And nothing has changed since 2007.

Pakistan has to put our house in order. Eliminate corruption and corrupt politicians. Have in Punjab clean out operation. Prosecute politicians and public officials not trustworthy. Don't blame anyone now. Just handle this situation.

@Pakistani sir , India is the poorest of countries ? Looks like you haven't checked your facts lately. Maybe googling on Indian economy will be of some help to you

Telling someone something he already knows has only limited value.......this should have been raised at the UN assembly.

@amin sir we provided facts and pretty hard ones at that. I am sure the world will listen to you if you provide some facts too

@Asif Kashmiri please care to elaborate what exactly are those plans

@Pakistani India is no longer poorer country.India is fastest economy in world .and 9th largest economy in the world.

@The Pakistan Lover is that all you have as a proof?

These are not soft corner.We are incompetent and corrupt too.Like an ostrich our head is dug in the sand.Unless those responsible from administration and security forces are not punished in failing for their duties,we will face the music.

India will never roll in dirt with terrorists. Its not because India loves Pakistan. Its because India loves India. Terrorism is a snake that bites the hand that feeds it

ISIS claimed the responsibility. anyway, this is cruel activity. Terrorism should be abolished completely. It cannot be good for anyone.It will always against humanity

@Pakistani Note that India and Pakistan BOTH have 5 diplomatic missions in Afghanistan, so what's your point?

@Muhammad and what about India fastest growing economy in the world? India one of the biggest no of startups in the world!? And India one of top ten industrialized nation in the world?

@Pakistani As you well know, both India and Pakistan both have FOUR consulates in Afghanstan, all located near each other in Herat, Mazar-e-Sharif, Kandahar and Jalalabad! just how do these quality as "many along the border"?????

Wow misleading everyone when ISIS has already claimed responsibility. India is not obsessed with pakistan, we don't need to do anything, you will implode urself due to your own insecurity against India.

@Napster Pakistan needs strong devoted leaders who mean business mean what they say, to unite and take the country with them out of this mess. Thourough investigation must be done before blaming anyone otherwise, the real culprits will get away to do the same, all over again and again.

@lafanga Sorry correct me if I am wrong. Did ISIS not claim the responsibility for the attacks? Does anyone has proof of India's involvement

@JMasood India does not support ISIS. We hate ISIS.

I don't understand that why Pakistan have to inform US each n everything. Pakistan should tackle this all by themselves. US should not be involved, whatever happens in the country. US has no right to take part in country's affairs.

@raj theydont need one...........just the word from that minister good enough

@Asif Kashmiri There was no plans. Never.

Show us the Evidence. Dont jump into a decision, without an investigation.

Stop good and bad taliban. Stop all terrorists..

Whats the point in telling US ? Pakistan should provide proof to India.

This is extremely sad!

@Dilip Thorat where is uri attack proof?

@lafanga ISIS is trying hard to recruit and foment trouble everywhere. Every country has to keep its eyes, ears and mind open.

An honest analysis is required not motivated by politics to address terrorism for humanity.

Give India evidence

@Akbar, The Great. Please read your comment again and refer to Modi and his ministers speeches for reality check.

@Pakistani you are wrong INDIA is not poor. Not anymore. Even Indians are very rich in India and abroad.

@ART KP that has been the strategy for long. Looks like it's hurting Pakistan more than anyone else

@Asif Kashmiri what makes u conclude that ? Read some history and make another judgement

@Muhammad Is anybody asking to feed Indian poor people. Looks at the statistics and then decide where Pakistan stands on every aspect of development in compared to whole world. The comparative numbers are coming out everyday.

Do not wait for US they will do nothing as india is doing it under their umbrella...make noise at international level and take punitive actions against Afghanistan.

@raj You never ask for evidence when indian media blames Pakistan five minutes into any act of terror inside india....

@techscribe India is rich country just like Pakistan, but the wealth is controlled by few familes. Street of Delhi Capital city any almost all cities in India still have people expiring on the street, same can be said about Pakistani cities. We keep comparing each other and while the world keeps going ahead. Politicians and religious organizations have controlled most people mindset.

Concerned officials must be called for an inquiry and should be held responsible for their incapability to enhance security. Pakistan government should also be held responsible for failing to improve the conditions of the premises, where government officials reside. It is learnt that walls are not high, there are no security posts, no lights and there are no bob wires installed. How can you protect your own people if the government does not care about proper security installations. These terrorists will keep striking. Pakistan has to break the nexus of the terrorists and increase security at all government facilities.

Where are the proofs ?. We cannot blame any country for Quetts attacks without any valid proofs.

How convenient Mr. Janjua to deflect attention to hide your failure.

Proof please, else nobody in the world will buy this narrative.

No evidence till date but crying hard to hide incompetency.

@amin they provide proof then we blame my dear friend

@amin we (India) produced evidence for the bombay and uri attack. Will you??????

@Pakistani - bad News - India is no longer one of the poorest countries

@JMasood - prove it !

@Pakistani coz we believe in development

@Shahzeb Let's see

@lafanga ... Your are right. It is about time Pakistanis did something to protect the country.

@Mustafa R. You are absolutely correct on those facts.

@raj The same proofs you always have without any roof.

@ART KP we are already paying the price

@JMasood we are not friend of ISIS.

@JMasood boss common sense is bigger then any consiracy theory... if a blind man try to complain that room is dark there is no light .. so what has to be pressumed when world listen to this...