Surrogates feel hurt by India's ban on foreign customers

Published November 18, 2015
30-year-old Bhagwati Chauhan, who gave birth to a Canadian couple's child rests at the Akanksha Clinic in Anand, India. — AP
30-year-old Bhagwati Chauhan, who gave birth to a Canadian couple's child rests at the Akanksha Clinic in Anand, India. — AP

NEW DELHI: For thousands of childless couples the world over, India has been the go-to destination to fulfill their dreams of becoming parents, thanks to its well-trained doctors, well-appointed fertility clinics and vast numbers of poor women willing to serve as surrogate mothers. Not anymore.

The Indian government recently banned surrogate services for foreigners and ordered fertility clinics to stop the practice of hiring Indian women to bear children for them. It's said to be intended to protect the women from exploitation, though some who have worked as surrogates say the ban actually hurts them.

"Becoming a surrogate mother is our one chance to build a house, or get a new roof. We earn more from one surrogacy than from 10 years of working as domestic help," said Tina Rajesh Chavan, speaking over telephone from Anand, a major hub of fertility clinics, in the western Indian state of Gujarat.

A nurse takes the blood pressure of a surrogate mother in a dormitory run by Akanksha Clinic, one of the most organised clinics in the surrogacy business, in Anand, India. — AP
A nurse takes the blood pressure of a surrogate mother in a dormitory run by Akanksha Clinic, one of the most organised clinics in the surrogacy business, in Anand, India. — AP

India was among the few countries in the world that allowed surrogacy — where a woman could be hired to carry the child of a couple through a process of in-vitro fertilisation and embryo transfer.

India's home ministry has ordered Indian embassies abroad not to grant visas to couples visiting the country for surrogacy, or "reproductive tourism" as the practice has come to be known.

Though laws governing surrogacy have yet to be passed, the government outlined its position in an affidavit placed before the Supreme Court on October 28.

It said India "does not support commercial surrogacy and the scope of surrogacy is limited to Indian married infertile couples only, and not to foreigners."

A previous order had already barred gay and unmarried couples and single people from hiring surrogates.

A government official, who spoke on condition of anonymity as he was not authorised to speak to the media, said the tightening of rules concerning surrogacy was to protect poor women from being exploited in the absence of legal safeguards.

Chavan, who served as a surrogate mother for two foreign couples, said her earnings through the two surrogate pregnancies ensured that her three children were able to complete their high school educations.

"Were it not for the surrogacy money, I would have had to pull them out of school," the 35-year-old said.

She currently works as a nanny helping parents look after their newborn surrogate babies during the time they are waiting to obtain visas for the infants.

"This ban does not help anyone. It has closed the door for poor people like us to earn a little money," Chavan said.

She said she made $7,700 for each surrogacy. That's typical for Gujarat, where the industry is most organised, but women in other states may be paid as little as $2,300.

Monthly checks for surrogate mothers are distributed at a dormitory run by Akanksha Clinic, one of the most organised clinics in the surrogacy business in Anand, India. — AP
Monthly checks for surrogate mothers are distributed at a dormitory run by Akanksha Clinic, one of the most organised clinics in the surrogacy business in Anand, India. — AP

Some women's rights activists say India's burgeoning surrogacy business should be regulated, not outlawed.

Banning it, they say, will only drive it underground. "In the last decade, fertility clinics that carry out surrogacy have come up everywhere — in the major metros as well as in small towns. And with it, there is a growing tribe of agents — men who procure poor women to serve as surrogates," said Manasi Mishra, a New Delhi-based researcher and author of two government-funded reports on surrogacy in India.

"These men are not going to give up their professional business. The whole practice will go underground, and it will be very hard to check the exploitation of the women hired as surrogates," Mishra said.

Since India legalised commercial surrogacy in 2001, thousands of fertility clinics have mushroomed across the country, making it a $1 billion to $2.3 billion business annually. Although there are no official figures available, a 2012 United Nations (UN) report said there were around 3,000 fertility clinics in India.

A worker sifts through paperwork at the Akanksha Clinic in Anand, India. — AP
A worker sifts through paperwork at the Akanksha Clinic in Anand, India. — AP

The clinics have attracted couples from Britain, the United States (US), Australia, South Africa and Japan. A surrogate pregnancy costs around $20,000 to $35,000 in India, compared to around $150,000 in the US, where surrogacy is permitted in many but not all states. Other countries that allow surrogacy include Russia, Georgia and Ukraine.

Thailand also had been a popular destination for those wanting a baby through surrogacy, but after recent scandals involving foreign clients, the country passed a law in August banning commercial surrogacy.

Activists in India say while the industry has proliferated, a lack of safeguards has led to rampant exploitation of thousands of poor, illiterate women by touts, agents, unscrupulous doctors and the owners of fertility clinics.

They say women may be paid far less than promised, with agents getting much of the cash and clinics taking deductions for everything from food to medical tests. Multiple embryos may be implanted without the woman's knowledge. Almost all babies are delivered by cesarean section, no matter whether it is medically necessary.

"Most often, the woman doesn't even know what she is signing, except that her womb will be used to carry a baby," said Ranjana Kumari, director of the New Delhi-based Centre for Social Research.

The surrogates are supposed to be at least 21, but agents persuade families to let girls as young as 16 become surrogate mothers, providing them with fake certificates showing them as older than their real age.

A nurse and a surrogate mother listen to a baby's heartbeat in a dormitory run by Akanksha Clinic in Anand, India. — AP
A nurse and a surrogate mother listen to a baby's heartbeat in a dormitory run by Akanksha Clinic in Anand, India. — AP

Kumari said strong regulation of the industry "would benefit all the concerned parties — the commissioning parents, surrogate mothers, and the child born of such an arrangement."

After long years of deliberation, India has reached the final stages of readying a law governing surrogacy for Indian couples. The legislation would bar the use of agents, require couples seeking surrogacy to pay all of the surrogate's expenses, and allow only women between the ages of 21 and 35 to act as surrogate mothers. It also says that women who have had more than five live births cannot serve as a surrogate.

The Indian Council of Medical Research is seeking public comment on the proposed legislation before Parliament votes on it.

Many women who agree to become surrogates view the job as an exceptionally rare way for them to make a large amount of money. For 26-year-old Christina Christian, it's a way to earn enough to buy her own home.

She's living in a dormitory in Anand with scores of other young women hired as surrogates for foreign couples. It's run by the Akanksha Clinic, whose workers regulate the activities of the surrogate mothers, ensuring that they take their meals and vitamin supplements, and that they do nothing that could jeopardise their pregnancies.

26-year-old Christina Christian, centre left, socialises with other surrogate mothers at a dormitory run by Akanksha Clinic in Anand, India. — AP
26-year-old Christina Christian, centre left, socialises with other surrogate mothers at a dormitory run by Akanksha Clinic in Anand, India. — AP

"If we felt we were being exploited, why would we come here?" Christian asked.

"This is our decision. There are many surrogates here for the second time. If they were exploited, why would they come back?"

Opinion

Elite privileges
20 Apr 2021

Elite privileges

Elite bargains provide a powerful view of our political economy.
A conjurer of limitless hope
20 Apr 2021

A conjurer of limitless hope

Rehman Sahib came across as a battle-scarred soldier who was perpetually planning to regroup after a setback.
Cabinet lotto
Updated 20 Apr 2021

Cabinet lotto

To return to finance, the second change in the key ministry is interesting for how it differs from the first.
Election ex machina
Updated 19 Apr 2021

Election ex machina

Neither EVMs nor i-voting are new innovations, yet their use remains deeply controversial.

Editorial

Media blackout
Updated 20 Apr 2021

Media blackout

A free flow of information is the best way to counter rumour-mongering and fake news.
20 Apr 2021

Gas utilities’ reluctance

THE government has ‘ordered’ state-owned gas companies SSGC and SNGPL to remove impediments hampering the...
20 Apr 2021

Saudi-Iran talks

EVER since the 1979 Islamic Revolution in Iran, ties between Tehran and Riyadh have been increasingly strained,...
19 Apr 2021

Vaccine shortfall

THE hope that the slew of Covid-19 vaccinations approved for use since the end of last year would vanquish the ...
Another package
Updated 19 Apr 2021

Another package

Sindh has not seen much development worth the name during the PPP’s more than decade-long rule in the province.
19 Apr 2021

Cricket triumph

TEAM Pakistan have a number of reasons to rejoice after their 3-1 T20 series win over hosts South Africa on Friday....