Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to
Sectarian violence has grown in Pakistan over the past few decades, adding to the law and order worries of local administrations and police, particularly in urban centres. Advent of terrorism in the name of religion has put heavier demands on law enforcement agencies to provide protection to the Muharram Majalis and processions – and beyond.
Such a procession has morphed into a religio-legal fuss for the Islamabad police since it was first taken out in sector G-10, with the permission of local administration, in 2012. But the next year, the mandatory permission was denied in view of the worst Shia-Sunni bloodshed on the Ashura day in neighbouring Rawalpindi. The organisers, however, went ahead with the procession ─ and in 2014 too – but not without consequences.
Clashes marred the procession on both occasions and police made several arrests. The clash took place between the participants of the procession and members of the opposite sect in 2013 and 2014, with police caught between them.
This year, though, the Islamabad police put their foot down as the local administration directed them to arrest both the organisers of the procession and those who react against it, under the Maintenance of Public Order Ordinance (MPO).
A senior police officer said Ramna police detained six persons under section 3 (power to arrest and detain suspected persons) for four days to avoid a repeat of the clashes of previous years.
Those arrested included Tabusum Abbasi, the organiser of the annual procession, Kausar Abbas, a government officer in Grade 17 from whose residence the procession was taken out, and three other persons suspected of objecting to the procession, including a leader of the local chapter of Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat. They were put in Adiala jail.
This parity of three detainees from both sects reflected a desire on the part of the authorities to appear ‘politically correct’ in handing the sectarian situation.
However, despite the overnight arrests and the deployment of police at the residence of Kausar Abbas to preempt the procession, the illegal procession was taken out.
According to SHO Ramna Fayaz Ranjha, it all started with a resident of Chakwal, Tabassum Abbas, adding a procession to a vow made by the devout wife of Kausar Abbas.
Years ago, he says, she vowed she will arrange a Majlis at her residence in Block-E at G-10/3. But Tabassum added a procession to her vow some four years ago which has led to all the fuss.
Senior police officers rushed reinforcements on learning that participants were gathering at a worship place away from Kausar Abbas’s house. They were deployed at different roads to intercept the procession and prevent possible clashes with the other sect.
Accordingly, mourners were appealed not to take out the procession and avoid precipitating an ugly law and order situation. “But the some 200 people gathered there ignored our appeals and proceeded with their planned procession,” a police source said.
Police blocked their path at Sawan Road and when their demand to remove the barriers was not met, the participants of the unauthorised procession started pelting stones. “We responded by firing teargas shells, and when they became more violent with a baton charge,” the source said.
After two hours of street battle, the police encircled the trouble creators and arrested over 50 of them. The rest of the crowd was persuaded to leave peacefully in groups four or five.
All those arrested were freed later, except the 20 considered the hardcore organisers of the procession. A case has been registered against them.
A senior police officer noted that this time it was a direct clash between the police and those behind the unauthorised procession.
“Tabassum is not a resident of Islamabad, comes to the city from Chakwal only for the procession. He claims to be a journalist there but we could not verify his claim so far,” the officer said.
“As he is not a resident of Islamabad, he cannot arrange or organisze the religious procession,” SHO Ranjha told Dawn.
“We are considering putting the organiser’s name (Tabassum Abbas) in the fourth schedule of Anti-Terrorism Act to restrict his entry in Islamabad, especially during Muharram,” said a senior police officer.
In 2012, the organisers sought and were granted permission to take out the procession from Block E in G-10/3 up to a worship place in G-10/4. The next year, they again sought permission in the aftermath of the November 16, 2013, volatile Ashura. But “elders of the area” consulted by the Islamabad administration advised against because few Shias lived in the locality and a mosque of the other sect lay on the route of the procession. So the permission was denied.
But organisers discussed the rejection at an imambargah in G-9/2 on November 25, 2013, and then gathered at Ibne Sina Road and took out the mourning procession. They resisted police’s attempt to intercept them but dispersed when police used force.
A case was registered against them over taking out the illegal procession.
“Tabassum is not a resident of Islamabad, comes to the city from Chakwal only for the procession. He claims to be a journalist there but we could not verify his claim so far,” the officer said.
“As he is not a resident of Islamabad, he cannot arrange or organisze the religious procession,” SHO Ranjha told Dawn.
“We are considering putting the organiser’s name (Tabassum Abbas) in the fourth schedule of Anti-Terrorism Act to restrict his entry in Islamabad, especially during Muharram,” said a senior police officer.
Published in Dawn, November 9th, 2015
On a mobile phone? Get the Dawn Mobile App: Apple Store | Google Play
Comments (12) Closed
what happened to the tolerance. Both Shia and Sunnis need to show tolerance. It's a few select days that this poor community which is number 1 target of terrorist take out processions, they are not hurting anyone. Please let them exercise their right. For Shias, it's important to follow the law of the land. If Govt does not give permission then please don't take out procession. We need to build a civil society that abides by laws and is tolerant.
people should respect each other's religious belief. the speeches should not provoke / offend others. if we followthis then i think there will be no issues in taking out processions
The religious processions on streets should be banned completely for 3 years (until this terrorism issue is somewhat settled)
The best way to deal with such situations are through education and knowing each others red lines. The government should take up this matters seriously and implement heavy penalties on such provocations.i believe such religious procession should be stopped altogether .
Procession is their Right. No one can stop them to take out procession whether its Islamabad or Karachi.
@Hussain Rehber... So mach happens on daily basis... people die left and right, all around there is injustice, extremism,hunger , poverty but no one dare take out any procession.... wonder why only MUHRRAM procession...
Government should check and issue the procession licenses and anybody found to be violating the license should be dealt accordingly. I have found people from both sects doing things to settle down their own egos it has nothing to do with their rights
In my opinion, taking out religious processions (within an accepted code of conduct) should not offend anyone else and should not be denied to any community (whosoever). Only, the govt needs to legislate the code of conduct for such processions and ensure its strict implementation. Those violating this code should be brought to book. Outright denial of permission is more of a problem than a solution and is also not optically correct as it seems to target a particular community. We see all kinds of protest gathering, marches and processions (some even by proscribed organizations) without any intervention by the administration. Then why to single out religious processions for political reasons. Hope sense prevails all around!
@khanm well said. Totally agtee with you
I am for total religious freedom to all sects / religions. With due respect to all sects
@khanm A more apt question would be: Why not? I mean why not also protest against all those injustices and everything that you have highlighted. The main issue in our society is that people are more concerned about others' religion than their own. I wonder how can one object to a religious community taking out a procession. What if that community objects to a 'rival' community's mosque enroute their procession? It is totally senseless. And it is never ending. If we want to live peacefully ourselves, we must learn to let others live peacefully too. And if it is important for them (for whatever reasons) to take out processions, let's allow them to do that peacefully. For them, it's their reigion. Why to create hurdles or deny them this right? Ok, let's suppose we don't want any processions. Then let there be no processions at all - not religious, not political, no awakening walks nothing. But if we don't want to do that, why clamp down only on Muharram processions???
@khanm : Your point is Valid too only if we see Karbala Incident in the context where injustice was at its peak by the then ruler. Karbala is a movement always remind us all to be brave, brave enough and strive to eliminate every injustice from the system. The movement of Karbala gives us all the strength to look around us and at least do some analysis of your life, your society, the people who rule you. Unfortunately we as a society have been indulge in sectarian differences else without any doubt, Karbala is the way forward for us all. So the point should not be creating any hurdle to Muharram procession but emphasis should be given over the real lesson of these processions.