Bilawal Bhutto struggles to shake off father's legacy

Published November 16, 2014
Chairman of the Pakistan People's Party Bilawal Bhutto Zardari.— AP file
Chairman of the Pakistan People's Party Bilawal Bhutto Zardari.— AP file

NAUDERO: He was a 19-year-old Oxford undergraduate when his family named him chairman of Pakistan's oldest dynastic party.

In the years that followed, Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, now 26, has been groomed to take over the dynasty and bring his family's political party back to power.

The young Bhutto officially launched his political career last month, telling hundreds of thousands of supporters at a rally in the city of Karachi he would fight for the revival of the Pakistan People's Party.

Read: For Bilawal, politics is 'Bhuttoism' or 'Dictatorship'

Even though he has emerged as the idealistic new face of the party, his father, Asif Ali Zardari, remains firmly in charge.

Zardari's five years as president were marked by allegations of corruption and misgovernment and the PPP was voted out in a 2013 election when Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif came to power.

Also read: The curious presidency of Mr Zardari

While the PPP relies on the Bhutto name and legacy to bind its supporters, party insiders say Bilawal has little future without the political expertise of his father.

“The son realises he does not have his father's experience. The father knows his son's enthusiasm and energy is greater,” said a family friend, requesting anonymity as he was not authorised to speak to the media on the matter.

“The day-to-day running of the PPP, all the decision-making, policy-setting, is still Asif's domain. Bilawal has no authority or experience. ... The boss is Asif Ali Zardari.” But being the face of Pakistan's greatest political dynasty is a highly dangerous job.

Bilawal's grandfather, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, died at the gallows, hanged in 1979 after being deposed in a military coup.

Also read: Garhi Khuda Bux awaits another Bhutto

His mother, Benazir Bhutto, was killed in a bomb and bullet attack in 2007, months after she returned to Pakistan from eight years in self-exile.

Placing the burden of blood and history on the son reveals an enduring strain in politics in South Asia. In India, four generations of the Nehru-Gandhi family have dominated politics. Dynasties also prevail in Sri Lanka and Bangladesh.

Speaking in his mother's study at the family house in the village of Naudero, Bilawal told Reuters he was being tutored by his father to play a role in politics.

“I have learnt politics from both my father and mother,” he said. “But I engage in progressive politics, learning from the past but looking forward and asking where do I go from here.”

'Fire daddy's friends'

Bilawal's grandfather was known for having mobilised the country's first mass-based party, using the slogan of “food, shelter and clothing” to shift the focus from religion to economic issues.

Under him, government services and educational opportunities were opened to women for the first time and all Pakistanis had the right to a passport.

“(Zulfikar Ali) Bhutto's charisma was not just emotional. He had an economic plan,” Haji Mumtaz Ali, a government official said at Ghari Khuda Bakhsh, a village set among paddy fields where seven generations of the Bhutto family are buried. “Bhutto brought investment. He gave us the nuclear programme.”

But analysts and many voters believe the memories of Zulfikar Ali and Benazir Bhutto have begun to fade and the moment has been seized by politicians like former cricket star Imran Khan whose anti-corruption message has attracted young people wanting to break free of dynastic politics.

“Bilawal is not tainted with any of the rumours that afflicted the PPP in the past,” said Husain Haqqani, a family friend and a former ambassador to the United States.

Political analyst Jami Chandio said: “This is a very competitive political environment and Bilawal needs a new team and a new message. He needs to fire daddy's friends if he wants to change things.”


Let women be, control the man
Updated 11 Apr 2021

Let women be, control the man

Men need to be educated and then read the riot act. The enforcement of the law must be merciless in such cases.
Twixt torch & tray
11 Apr 2021

Twixt torch & tray

Some may say that the lawyers’ indignation is not without merit.
Behaviour bond
10 Apr 2021

Behaviour bond

States have turned the imitation of repressive laws into an art form...


11 Apr 2021

Dissension within PTI

WITH the dust from the PDM’s implosion still not fully settled, the PTI is now faced with growing dissension from...
11 Apr 2021

Power to arrest

A SUPREME Court verdict announced on Thursday spelled out what might be considered a self-evident truth in any...
11 Apr 2021

Unequal vaccine distribution

IT is in times of crisis that we often see the best — or worst — of humanity. In this regard, the pandemic has...
10 Apr 2021

Greater tax burden

THE FBR’s tax target of Rs6tr for the next year under the IMF-mandated fiscal adjustment policies will increase ...
UK travel ban
Updated 10 Apr 2021

UK travel ban

Pakistan continued to allow passengers to arrive without quarantine requirements.
10 Apr 2021

IS in Mozambique

IT was not too long ago when the dreaded shock troops of the self-declared Islamic State group were rampaging ...