Shrinking liberalism: When truth becomes Truth

Published October 11, 2014
Liberal ideas are largely considered deviant by our society as far-right extremism gains ground. -Illustration by Khuda Bux Abro
Liberal ideas are largely considered deviant by our society as far-right extremism gains ground. -Illustration by Khuda Bux Abro

Since its inception, Pakistan has remained a conservative country, where religion played a mammoth role in shaping politics, redefining policies and most important of all, enforcing particular narratives in society.

Nonetheless, despite conservatism dominating intellectual discourse, there has existed a significant liberal minority which exercised its right to speak and write openly and put across its points of view.

However, this tiny space for liberals in Pakistan has been shrinking more and more of late; reflecting an alarming trend toward far-right politics of a jealous nature which shuns any opportunity to question itself.

Also read: ‘Liberalism never allowed to grow in Pakistan’

It makes you think, why are liberalism and Pakistan in a state of chronic conflict? And more importantly, why are liberal ideas considered deviant by society at large?

The bone of contention lies within those who have wielded power in the country which directly or indirectly, has been maneuvered by forces within the state apparatus using a narrative of securing itself against outside aggression when in fact they harboured dangerous ambitions and tinkered with national institutions to fulfill those ambitions. Apart from the times of Ayub and Musharraf, the ideal citizen for the state was an India-hating religious conservative and was more security-obsessed than development-oriented.

All this is contrary to liberal values.

Education was used as a tool to achieve the targets. For decades, the nation's educational institutions have been promoting a hyper-religio-nationalist mindset based on insecurity against the neighbour India and with a huge inclination towards utopian Pan-Islamism.

Explore: What is the most blatant lie taught through Pakistan textbooks?

Thus, when a fourth grader's social sciences textbook introduces him to sub-continental history through "India's evil designs against Pakistan" and establishes as unwavering truth that certain state institutions are always right no matter what the Constitution advocates, it shouldn't surprise one to see the same student later react with fuming outrage against the idea of normalising ties with the neighbouring country. It would not just be abnormal for him, it would be a heresy. The call for revisiting Pakistan's security-centrism would be treacherous and advocating secular values an attack on the Islamic Republic.

When critical thinking is not appreciated, diversity is not recognised and a specific narrative is enforced generation after generation with additional support from the mass media, it is only natural that nations would end up precisely where we are today.

Take a look: How Pakistanis see their country today

Liberal ideas become a synonym for heresy, and truth becomes Truth – just one single interpretation of events, the discretion over which lies only with the state – be it Nazriya-i-Pakistan, the controversial 8th Amendment, the 2nd Amendment or the military's influence within the state, that “Truth” cannot be challenged.

Pakistanis must tell themselves that though conservatism is acceptable, far-right extremism is not.

The opposition of liberalism is more structural than anything else. The state wanted it, and soon they got it by exploiting conservatism and taking it to a whole new level.

And has Pakistan, as a result, been better off in the long run?

The fact that the state is still fighting extremists suggests not.


Related articles:

Opinion

Editorial

Spy games
Updated 02 Oct, 2022

Spy games

The audios leaked so far appear to have been carefully curated: they apply pressure but do not do major damage.
‘Geopolitical football’
02 Oct, 2022

‘Geopolitical football’

THE US-China rivalry is by all measures one of the globe’s most dangerous competitions for power and influence. ...
Fuel price reduction
02 Oct, 2022

Fuel price reduction

ISHAQ Dar is back; so are his signature policies. The reduction of a little over 5pc in fuel prices announced by him...
Untruths and politics
Updated 01 Oct, 2022

Untruths and politics

It would arguably be in the national interest for the Supreme Court to take up the cipher and settle the matter.
Farmers’ protest
01 Oct, 2022

Farmers’ protest

SEVERAL hundred farmers have converged on Islamabad for the last three days to protest against the soaring costs of...
Dasht-i-Barchi bombing
01 Oct, 2022

Dasht-i-Barchi bombing

ON Friday morning, Kabul’s Dasht-i-Barchi neighbourhood was rocked by a terrorist attack targeting an educational...