Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Soft on the enemy


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

WHITHER the much-talked-about talks with the Pakistani Taliban? There is no sign yet of them taking off. But even if the talks happen it would be more like talks between the victor and the vanquished.

While the national leadership pleads for mercy, the militants dictate the modalities of the surrender to the state. With no will to fight, the Sharif administration has already conceded too much ground to the Taliban with extremely dangerous consequences for national security, and it may not be easy to retrieve the situation. The latest escalation in violence, including the killing of a senior Khyber Pakhtunkhwa minister, makes the intention of the militants even clearer — talks but only on their terms.

It was frightening to watch Hakeemullah Mehsud on BBC recently, arrogantly justifying the killing of those who do not subscribe to the Taliban’s retrogressive worldview. “We have targeted those who are with the infidels, America, and we will continue to target them,” the Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) chief declared. For him, whoever is not with them is an infidel and deserves to be killed.

His triumphant tenor and newfound confidence was shocking. Just a few months ago, the TTP chief was afraid for his own safety. The group was dealt a serious blow after the death of Waliur Rehman, the deputy commander of the TTP, in a drone strike. Surely, the inaction of the government has given a new lifeline to his supporters.

In a more recent interview, the TTP spokesman Shahidullah Shahid said that they would never engage in talks under the Pakistani Constitution since it enshrines democracy, which according to him is a secular and un-Islamic system. He also wants the Sharia’s enforcement in the country. Are these preconditions acceptable to the state? They will be tantamount to legitimising a Taliban dictatorship.

Emboldened by the government’s dithering and the defeatist approach of political leaders such as Imran Khan, the TTP is now threatening to eliminate journalists and intellectuals who are challenging its tyranny. What is most appalling is the complete silence of the political leaders over these death threats. But it must not surprise us since these leaders did the same when the militants targeted the activists of the Awami National Party during the May 11 elections, virtually pushing it out of the poll race.

In fact, the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) to some extent owes its electoral success in KP to the compromise it had made with the Taliban. It is also fear that drives the PTI’s current pro-TTP policy. But what Imran Khan and his supporters do not understand is that appeasement may not protect them for long.

The message was clear when the militants murdered provincial law minister Israrullah Gandapur in a suicide attack on Eid day. He was the third provincial assembly member to be killed by the militants in the past few months.

It is now several weeks since the all-party conference mandated the government to initiate the so-called peace talks with the militants. But there is still no clear strategy for negotiations. There is huge ambiguity over whom the administration intends to talk to. The TTP is a loose group of more than 30 factions and each one has its own views on the negotiations. Moreover they are not bound by the decisions taken by Hakeemullah Mehsud.

Most TTP groups have publicly rejected the government’s peace offer. It is not surprising that different factions accepted responsibility for the recent terrorist attacks in KP. For instance, the Peshawar church attack was carried out by the TTP’s Mohmand branch which is totally opposed to any peace talks with the Pakistani state.

Imran Khan has come out with a bizarre demand of allowing the outlawed militant network to open its office in Pakistan to clear the way for dialogue. The sheer ridiculousness of the suggestion aside, it is not clear whether the PTI chief wants offices for all the TTP factions.

Then, there are also numerous splinter factions of outlawed Pakistani militant groups operating from North Waziristan. Known as the Punjabi Taliban, they may be cooperating with the TTP in carrying out terrorist attacks, but they have their own specific agendas too.

One of the most powerful Punjabi Taliban leaders, Asmatullah Muawiya, is, perhaps, the only one who has publicly supported the government’s peace offer. This positive response apparently came only after the prime minister suspended the execution of two members of the Lashkar-i-Jhangvi convicted on several murder charges. Muawiya had threatened to target the members of the Sharif family and to unleash terrorist attacks in Punjab. There cannot be long-term peace with the government buckling under terrorist threats.

I recently watched a speech of Muawiya on video, on the killing of Osama bin Laden. In a most vitriolic diatribe against the Pakistani security forces, the militant leader vowed to carry out the mission of the late Al Qaeda chief. Does the Sharif government understand the ramifications of dealing with Al Qaeda affiliates and those responsible for sectarian killings?

Not only would peace deals with such groups clear the way for the Talibanisation of Pakistan, they would also be dangerous for regional security. More importantly, the move would reinforce the suspicion of the international community about Pakistan’s unwillingness to fight against violent extremism.

Indeed, there is very little hope of achieving peace through dialogue with the militants. But more worrisome is whether the administration has an alternative plan to deal with the worsening security situation. The choice is not between dialogue and a military operation. The state must use all options to enforce the rule of law.

No state can allow its writ to be challenged by armed groups, or a parallel system to operate. What is needed are measures to strengthen the civilian law-enforcement and intelligence networks to deal with the menace of militant violence. The government has to act more firmly if it wants to eliminate terrorism in Pakistan. The threat cannot wither away by romancing the enemy.

The writer is an author and journalist.

Twitter: @hidhussain

The views expressed by this writer and commenters below do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.

Comments (10) Closed

shahid Oct 22, 2013 09:45am

The author should read this story in DAWN of today:

SaleemC Oct 22, 2013 11:20am

A long rumbling article justifying drone attacks. What a shame!

Peace has to be given a chance. You cannot and must not conduct war on your own people. Negotiations are imperative.

Feroz Oct 22, 2013 12:48pm

Seeing the lack of comments from readers on such an important existential issue, citizens seem to be living like Alice in Wonderland.

Parvez Oct 22, 2013 04:17pm

Down to earth clear thinking and advice.

Ali Oct 22, 2013 06:34pm

I fully agree with Zahid. The government and its institutions have lost the will and courage to safeguard the constitution and the fundamental rights enshrined in it to the people of Pakistan. The present lot of our so called leaders are bunch of cowards.

Eddied Oct 22, 2013 08:56pm

This is one of the most comprehensive reports on the real status of Pakistan that I have read...kudos to the author...

samy Oct 23, 2013 12:23am

Sensible article. any liberal Pakistani who love his country should stand against this menace. This lady is bold and brave.IT seems only malala is bolder than any one in this great nation.

samy Oct 23, 2013 12:41am

SORRY DAWN : I Thought it was written by sherry rehman. so I put in last comment as lady reference to the writer. any how this one is bold and precise without fear most importantly truth.

Ashraf Oct 23, 2013 01:16am

Mr. Zahid Hussain and few other eminent column writers have been writing and highlighting the grave consequences that will ensue due to the government's dithering in the face of the Taliban's determination to carry out their mission.The Taliban's objective of the implementation their brand of Sharia does not remain confined to them only. It is now a fanciful mind set of the majority of the people of Pakistan. Unfortunately, this mind set is not just confined to the illiterate and poor Muslim lot. A good number of the educated Muslim lot such as engineers, doctors, computer nerds and other highly qualified Muslims all over the world have this mind set. This lot has penetrated into all segments and systems of the Pakistani society. Something has gone terribly wrong somewhere. There is no sign to indicate that this alarming situation will change in the near future. Certain interested parties are working real hard to ensure that this situation prevails so that their objective of implementing their brand of Shariah is achieved. In view of this a lot more bloodshed is going to take place.

jawaid Oct 23, 2013 08:09am

Very true. Taliban are the perfect symbols of height of illiteracy and brutality. They only know the language of death and destruction.

Our leaders should delivery and serve the people rather than hiding under the garb of campaigning against drone attacks and peace talks with them. The former act is difficult and the later very easy.

In fact the done attacks are blessings and have taken out very dangerous killers which we could not have done on our own.

Our people want peace & stability that would come only after crushing them and making them non-entity. But the biggest challenge is the leadership to make that happen.