Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


A slow surrender?

Updated Aug 25, 2013 08:07am


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

IT’S an old trick of Nawaz’s: the more you see, the less you know. And he’s at it again.

DCC, NSC, CDNS, none of it matters really until you get the A, B, C right. I.E. It’s not the name that matters, it’s the configuration and the quality of the decisions that do.

Before the election, Nawaz seemed to be on the right track.

The NSC was anathema because it represented all that the politicians had come to loathe: institutionalising what was the de facto arrangement of power — military on top, the civilians thrashing around below.

Before the election, Nawaz seemed to get that the DCC is more miss than hit not because of its existing configuration, but because it didn’t have the right ammunition.

Give the DCC a proper secretariat, a dedicated staff that can help the principals make sense of things, and much of the fog would automatically lift — at least on the civilian side, because the military already has all the paper-churning backup it needs in GHQ and Aabpara.

That was before the election.

After the election, are we witnessing a slow surrender?

Nawaz being Nawaz, it’s never easy to say. Inscrutable and insular at the best of times, he’s taken it to a new level this time — just ask any of the desperate PML-N leaders always asking around about what their boss is thinking, or even up to.

But there are some clues to what Nawaz is thinking, if not planning and doing.

First, you have to go back to the basic Nawaz mould. He did and seems still to consider himself heir to the Mughal throne.

Ardeshir Cowasjee used to tell a brilliant, possibly embellished, tale about this particular tendency of Nawaz.

The prime minister’s office once rang up Ardeshir to inform him that Nawaz wanted to pay a visit to the splendid Cowasjee home in Karachi. He wasn’t told why, but since no one says no to a visit by the prime minister, Ardeshir agreed.

When an advance team arrived at his home to secure it and map out the visit, an objection was raised.

The little wooden door through which all visitors entered the Cowasjee home required everyone to stoop a bit, to avoid banging their head against the beam above the door.

The prime minister doesn’t bow his head before anyone, Ardeshir was told by the prime ministerial advance team, you’ll have to use a different entrance to receive him.

Heir to the Mughal throne means Nawaz will only do things when Nawaz is ready to do them.

The election, Nawaz decided, was a referendum on electricity, so that was his first priority. When terrorism quickly forced itself to the front of the queue, Nawaz’s default response kicked in: I’m not ready yet, I’ve got five years, I’ll deal with this in my way, on my own clock.

Terrorism, India, Afghanistan, Punjab, intelligence, police, CDNS — they’re all inter-linked and nowhere has the Nawaz imprint been made yet.

If it rested at that, perhaps it would not matter that much. But there is one significant difference between Nawaz 3.0 and the earlier versions: while he’s not ready to decide, he’s letting others decide.

It matters less that the leaner, supposedly more focused CDNS will have one more civilian member than uniformed; what matters is that the uniformed members can be expected to speak as one and they alone have a semi-institutionalised form of decision-making and input-taking.

How that squares with Nawaz’s pre-election promise of the civilians leading and the military following isn’t hard to figure out: it doesn’t.

The second clue to what Nawaz is thinking was doing the rounds for weeks and confirmed in his speech this week: he and his team had no real idea how bad things were.

That things were bad was obvious enough; just how bad they are has only dawned on the N-League leadership after coming to power. Reality has caused Nawaz to pause, to take stock first before figuring out what has to be done.

Politics is of course, and unhappily, supreme here. The right thing to do is secondary to the politically advantageous, or least disadvantageous, thing to do.

The go-slow approach — for now — is less about figuring out what to do, but about figuring out how to fit the new, post-election, since-coming-to-power information into the political matrix of decision-making.

Yeah, for example, dialogue isn’t going to go anywhere, but take it off the table quickly and what could that mean for peace in the realm — Fortress Sharif, Punjab?

The third clue comes courtesy the very small circle that speaks to Nawaz on such matters. Call it the ‘C’ choice: confrontation or co-option.

Confrontation is off the table, Nawaz’s aides claim. Don’t think about it as wresting power back from the army, they explain, think of it as finding ways to take everyone along.

Even talk of co-option makes Nawaz’s aides squeamish; they’d rather not frame civ-mil relations in a way that suggests one side emerging ahead of the other. Seen from that perspective, the CDNS makes sense.

An institutionalised role for the army; a decision in which there was some give-and-take (no NSC, but significant say); a group that presents a joint front; a body that allows one side, the military, to press its case, while the other side, Nawaz, makes up his mind — it gives the veneer of forward movement, while allowing the state of suspended animation to continue.

Essentially, the heir to the Mughal throne keeps his robes, while the original power centre doesn’t have to get its guard up. A neat, temporary arrangement, if ever there was one.

Except, passivity on the civilian side can lead to that most familiar of denouements: where everyone begins to see the heir to the Mughal throne is dressed in the emperor’s clothes.

The writer is a member of staff.

Twitter: @cyalm

The views expressed by this writer and commenters below do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.

Comments (10) Closed

Feroz Aug 25, 2013 09:32am

Pakistan is a unique society where right and wrong is decided by who holds the Guns. The Taliban has a very bright future.

avtar Aug 25, 2013 09:38am

As always, your writing leaves an impression that you so badly want to fit in Mr. Cowasjee's shoes. Strange and baffling.

Ali Changezi Aug 25, 2013 11:44am

Very well written, ths s something I had thought earlier while the campaign was for elections. Nawaz has never counted himself as a common person or civilian, he has always considered himself Superior than all. He has kept almost all the ministries with himself n made the advisories, one has to criticise against his act which s not fair for the govt and people of Pakistan. Taking the mandate of people of pakistan doesn't mean to play with their emotions n ruin their feelings... Pakistan today s suffering n passing by many serious n saviour problems and uptill now we ve nt seen any clear instance regarding the resolution for these problems from the Govt of PML-N. Foreign policy s the most severe problem existing in pakistan, but its so bad to say that we ve nt got a minister for foreign services yet...

M Rafique Aug 25, 2013 11:52am

He arranged to come at top to recover the losses sustained during the period he is not at top of affairs and such decisions are very prompt since 08.06.2013

junaid Aug 25, 2013 01:47pm

Call him a lion, a born hero and ask him to jump at the army and get a horn in belly, he have done it twice and you are pushing him for 3rd. Let him choose his way to jump or wait others party to jump and get squashed

Satyameva Jayate Aug 25, 2013 04:32pm

Very keen observations and analysis.... Reminds me of the quick change in Mr. Zardari's 'walk' after he became the president, though the 'talk' took a little longer, after he had to eat his own words a few times. The most potent problem for politicians is not from the terrorists, but from those in uniform, those who have already decimated the politicians four times.

khanm Aug 25, 2013 04:46pm

Never bring the problem solving stage into the decision making stage. Otherwise, you surrender yourself to the problem rather than the solution. Unfortunately I don

Avtar Aug 25, 2013 06:01pm

It is nice of Nawaz to dream as heir apparent to the Mughal throne but let us hope he does not govern Pakistan like Mughal emperors. It depends on which emperor. Bahadur Shah Zafar's II rule extended only to Shahjehabad or Old Delhi. His predecessor, Shah Alam's rule extended from Delhi to Palam (village where Delhi airport is located). Nawaz's role might be in fact that of a British Governor of Punjab with jurisdiction over North West Frontier and Border areas.

Agha Ata Aug 26, 2013 05:46am

@junaid: Lions have no horns. :)

Bilal Aug 26, 2013 10:01am

@Ali Changezi: Firstly can you tell me how many ministries are resting with Nawaz that you are so obliged to say that almost all ministries are kept by him?Secondly,if he would have appointed more ministers ,people like you would have been again criticising him for having a huge cabinet.He is doing all right till now.First time in 13 years Pakistan will be having a policy in the war against terror