Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience



Your Name:

Recipient Email:

A DAY after the epic debacle that was Monday’s assault on Dera Ismail Khan’s Central Jail, KP Chief Minister Pervez Khattak said it was “very strange that people came in pickup trucks, motorbikes, broke into the jail and took away 250 prisoners easily”. Strange may be the correct term but it is equally applicable to the failure of his administration whose responsibility it is to ensure that such security breaches are prevented. This was no repeat of the Bannu jail raid last year. In this case, security and administration officials knew that such a hit was imminent. On Monday, hours before the attack, the area’s commissioner held a conference to discuss the matter with law-enforcement agencies and the civil administration. For the provincial administration to say, then, that it was an intelligence failure was both disingenuous and an irresponsible effort to deflect culpability. It was a tactical failure, pure and simple.

Why this tactical failure occurred, though, is extraordinarily disturbing in its implications. After the jail-break information was shared, standard operating procedures were fleshed out and specific response tasks were worked out. Over 100 jail guards and 75 personnel of the Frontier Reserve Force were available, as well as the Elite Police Force and armoured personnel carriers. But when it came to holding the line, the defences melted away. As a disgruntled security official said, metaphorically, the gun was there but there was no one to pull the trigger. Do law-enforcement personnel even have the capability of facing hordes as organised, single-minded and well-armed as the various militant groups clumped under the TTP? True, money has been pumped into the police force, particularly in KP, but most of it has gone towards salaries and increased strength. There has been little consideration of the fact that the numbers of personnel are immaterial if they aren’t trained for a fight that makes very specific demands.

If we are not to reach a situation where militant groups can set their sights on ever higher targets, the law-enforcement apparatus needs an immediate overhaul to meet the escalating challenges posed by what has been the reality for several years now. Pakistan needs to set up modern maximum-security prisons designed to resist assault and prevent escapes; colonial-era internment centres, relics of another age, are simply not enough. The equation is, on paper, simple: the militants are increasingly well-organised, trained and armed; the state law-enforcement apparatus is not. The outcome of the conflict will ultimately be decided on the basis of the disparity between the two sides’ capabilities.

Comments (8) Closed

showz_up Aug 01, 2013 12:39pm

and to blame the PTI led 2 months old govt for this failure which was caused by 60 years of negligence is not exactly being very honest.

Aamir Aug 01, 2013 06:02pm

spot on. KPK CM is incompetent.

brr Aug 01, 2013 06:11pm

spineless individuals, totally incompetant - what happened to the pakhtun bravery, sense of duty? or is it all fluffy nonsense, used just to intimidate women?

Imran Ahmed Aug 01, 2013 07:20pm

Until and unless party political interference ceases in Police appointments, promotion and transfers professional morale and efficiency will continue to fall or stay at rock bottom.

Imran Ahmed Aug 01, 2013 08:55pm

Journalists should demand that KPK government give them the names of the officers involved in the fiasco, their training qualifications and whether they are political appointees.

Ahmer Aug 02, 2013 02:53am

It is easy to blame the police because it cannot bite back. What was a whole brigade of Army located next door doing? The information about the impending attack must have been given to them too.

Tam Aug 03, 2013 05:15am

@Ahmer: it is not the job of army to protect the civil jail until it is told by the civil administration that it is out of there hand and sadly no one told army. On how many places you will put army to protect? Is police of no use? It was totally the fault of police they did not even fire a single round. and now you are saying it is the fault of Army bde that police did not fight taliban. so open your eyes and your small brain and then write your stupid comments.

Ahsan ilyas Aug 03, 2013 05:36pm

CM talk about cowardice of police then whats this?

1-A suicide attack was attempted on Ex-DPO D.I.Khan on 14th Jan 2012. He is still on the hit list of TTP (confirmed by intelligence reports as they said that DPO office may be attacked). 2-Out of 40 top notch extremists belonging to TTP that guy (DPO) arrested 13 from DI Khan ncluding Qari Bilal. 3-He has been made OSD and all security has been taken back. Now if TTP again make him target who will be responsible. 4.He served in that district for almost 3 years where none of the officers have even served for more than 18 months