Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Aggressive discrimination


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

IN the mad race for power that has affected participants and spectators alike nobody seems to be bothered about the havoc being wrought by intolerance-driven violence.

For several months, the 20 or so Ahmadi families living in village Shamsabad, in Chunian tehsil of Kasur district, not far from the Punjab capital, have been subjected to harassment and violence by the majority community because of their belief.

A public meeting organised by a man who had just returned from Europe declared all Ahmadis living in the village liable to be killed. They were told to abandon their faith or leave the village. Mob rule followed. Ahmadis were persecuted in various ways. Some labourers were driven out of the village. After repeated complaints a police post was ordered to be set up in the village but political influentials got this decision rescinded.

On March 25, about 50-60 armed men attacked the Ahmadi community leader and subjected him and his family members to violence and after beating him mercilessly left him for dead. The district coordination officer and the district police officer arrived, an FIR was registered but no action was taken against the culprits. Instead, the Ahmadis are being advised by the administration to make up with their tormentors, obviously on the latter’s terms. Quite a few people have their eyes on their lands — prized booty certainly.

In Lahore itself several Ahmadis were subjected to violence for distributing their newspaper, Al-Fazal, and then arrested on the charge of blasphemy.

Meanwhile, the news from Islamabad is that there will be no peace for Rimsha, the Christian girl who was acquitted by the Islamabad High Court of the charge of desecrating the Holy Quran. The complainant has appealed to the Supreme Court against the high court decision but no date of hearing has been fixed. Earlier, his petition had been dismissed by the Supreme Court for non-prosecution. The vengeful attitude of Rimsha’s persecutors is beyond reason and impossible to justify.

It is possible that the victims in these cases have done something to deserve being beaten up, booked under dreaded charges, and threatened with death. In that case let them be dealt with under the law. An administration that leaves the minorities at the mercy of overzealous vigilantes and their patrons in the police will not escape indictment for complicity — and worse.

The mischief must be suppressed forthwith, otherwise it will spread to a dangerous extent in the days before the next government takes over. But that is a relatively minor issue.

Far more important is the need to take a dispassionate view of what may be described as the third phase in the persecution of religious minorities and sects in Pakistan, under the heading: deliberate, aggressive discrimination.

In the first phase the minorities, like the poor belonging to the majority community, were at a disadvantage. They could not get good jobs because they lacked the means of qualifying. They had little access to justice or ability to engage the counsel of their choice because they could not afford the cost.

To be disadvantaged was bad enough but the state, goaded by preachers of intolerance, made the situation worse for the minorities by legalising their disadvantage. It did this by denying a non-Muslim the right to engage a non-Muslim lawyer to defend him in a Zia-made religious court, by denying a non-Muslim student admission to higher classes on merit, by barring Ahmadis from getting a commission in the army that fellow Ahmadis like generals Akhtar Malik and Abdul Ali had served with distinction.

As if the phase of state-sanctioned discrimination were not enough, the state has been blinking at the organised and large-scale persecution of minorities by non-state elements.

Some prominent manifestations of this form of persecution are: many individuals and groups have made it a profession to incite violence against the minority communities and kill them, and the state has done nothing to curb the menace; blasphemy charges are bandied around for the heck of it and the trend has been strengthened by the executive’s lack of will and by the accommodation allowed to mischief-makers by the courts in several cases.

A conference on the challenges faced by the religious minorities in South Asian countries held recently in Karachi by the Pakistan Institute of Labour Education and Research fully revealed the pattern of minorities’ persecution following the mixing of religion with politics in the law and constitution in several of these countries. Some of the most moving presentations were made by the victims of vigilante squads and police alacrity in throwing the victims of violence in jail instead of the culprits.

What is the source of the strength of the growing breed of non-state actors in this phase of organised, aggressive discrimination against the minority communities? In one sentence: a state that has been unhinged from its democratic moorings. The question all responsible citizens may ask themselves is: could there be a link between the rise of aggressive minority-baiting and the belief-dominated discourse on electoral matters?

Tailpiece: Those attacking the interior minister for recognising Nawaz Sharif are patently in the wrong. He would have risked his job if he had spoken well of Asif Zardari or Asfandyar Wali or even Altaf Hussain. The laws made to deal with patwaris and head constables cannot be applied to the chosen few, who are so busy refurbishing their reputation for piety that they do not have time to notice the systematic annihilation of ANP candidates and cadres in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. What a simple way of cleaning Pakistan of the opponents of bigotry and extremism.

The views expressed by this writer and commenters below do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.

Comments (8) Closed

Tahir A Apr 18, 2013 08:17am
Sadly the hatred and acts of savagery against the minorities are even expressed by the so called "educated" people of Pakistan these days. In an article that appeared in Dawn on 11 April 2013 entitled "Minorities:Voting Cautiously, or not at all", one person posted this comment: Quote Islamic law itself discriminates against non-Muslim minorities. Under the Islamic Sharia, non-Muslims cannot join the army, become leaders, be appointed to sensitive government positions and practice their religion openly. This must be news to you, Aamir! As for Ahmadis, they are not only non-Muslims. They are APOSTATES as well. The punishment for apostates in Islam is execution with the sword, nothing less. Because of Pakistanis general ignorance about the fundamentals of Islam, DAWN newspaper is able to get by with publishing articles like the above. Unquote Such is the audacity and built-in hatred of even the "learned" people. Therefore, what else can one expect from the general illiterate public. It is a good thing that Dawn does allow such articles and such horrendous comments to appear. Many thanks.
SAL Apr 18, 2013 02:12pm
Islam teaches us to live in peace and harmony with other faith and religion. Let them follow there religion and live in Peace. I am a Muslim and I Believe in this. Alhamd O Lillah!.
Jari Apr 18, 2013 06:28pm
what is going on in Pakistan with Ahmadies and other minorities is horrible. The people who are watching all this happening may be next. Famous saying is that what goes around it comes around. Police and government is actively involved in the massacre and violence agains humanity. This should be stopped immediately
Muthu Apr 18, 2013 06:43pm
I didn't know that Pakistan had Ahmadi generals in the past. The only prominent Ahmadi I knew was Dr.Salam. Seems an intelligent sect is paying for the mistakes of their forefathers. They should've stayed in India.
Kausik Apr 18, 2013 10:56pm
If Pakistan wants to pursue democratic rule instead of swinging between benevolent military dictator rule as portrayed by sympathizers and interim democracy without proper foundations or pillars of 1) fully independent judiciary2)fully independent free press and journalists to express opinions guaranteed by constitution.3) some sort of provential autonomy like states in India4) at least some assurance to minorities even though now it is Islamic Republic5)Last but not least Dig up Ayub khan,yahya khan,ziaand Musharraf under criminal charges for subverting constitution of Pakistan and condemn za Bhutto for obstructing mujibur Rehman victor of 1970 elections from becoming PM and breaking Pakistan.Indians critisize Gandhi,Nehru for being soft on Pakistan and admire Sardar Patel,Maulana azad they still are criticized after we all need to be self critical.I am amazed Azad predicted future of Pakistan in 1946 and he is a Maulana and devout Muslim mj Akbar your columnist author of tinder box shows weakness of Pakistan thinking and actions.Time to correct may elections good sign all administrations are corrupt at least in civilian you have recourse.stop discriminating other sects with in Islam you are no different than Hindu cast system all are equally bad and I condemn them and that is why B.RAmbedkar father of Indian constitution of India and Greatest Indian Rejected Islam and became Buddhist as he perceived and saw how untouchables were treated in Islam see India untouched documentary by Stalin.
Engineer Apr 19, 2013 06:16am
This is extremely disappointing.. we are calling for the Azab-eIlahi...Hazrat Ali (R.A) has rightly said that "Kufr ka nizaam to chal sakta hai ,Zulm ka nizaam nahi chal sakta:..This is Zulm ka Nizam. That is why each and every system of our country has been collapsed and near complete destruction. Authorities are crossing their limits. May Allah guide them to the right path otherwise they will find no will out after these barbarian acts.
KTShamim Apr 19, 2013 03:37pm
Our "forefathers" knew very well what would happen in Pakistan once we got here. But they also knew that creating Pakistan was, in principle, the right thing to do. Because Muslims could not expect justice from a people who discriminate within their own based on caste.
KTShamim Apr 19, 2013 03:38pm
Really sad this is happening. Islam taught patience, Mullahs teach impatience: [3:187] "... you shall surely hear many hurtful things from those who were given the Book before you and from those who set up equals to God. But if you show fortitude and act righteously, that indeed is a matter of strong determination."