Going, going, gone?

Updated Aug 05, 2013 04:43pm

The bare Babusar Pass

Last summer, I finally got a chance to travel across the scenic Babusar Pass on my way back from Gilgit. Just before Chilas, we turned onto a dirt track that leads to Babusar Top. Our mobile phones soon stopped working as we snaked up to the pass, the jeep laboriously making its way up the steep incline. There were a few scattered villages with little children in rags playing on the roadside. But what struck me the most was the lack of trees. There were hundreds of stumps along the road, so trees indeed grew here but they were all gone! Later on I found out that there were once thick forests in the area but they were all cut once a proper road was made across the top. It is a familiar story in the northern part of the country – once you build the roads, in comes the timber mafia and soon goes the forests and the wildlife that lives in them.

“My village is just 4 km away from Babusar Pass – and I’m sorry to say that it was my own relatives who were involved in the cutting of trees in Babusar. It is completely bare now,” says twenty-five years old Khan Muhammad Qureishi who now lives in Islamabad where he is working and studying International Relations. The son of a policeman, Juma Mohammed Qureishi, whose family still owns other tracts of forests in Diamer District, KM Qureishi has turned into an active campaigner against deforestation. Diamer is a district in Gilgit-Baltistan famous for its forests and wilderness. Now both the forests and the wild beauty are rapidly disappearing thanks to an order passed by outgoing Prime Minister Raja Pervez Ashraf during his last days in office, to allow the transportation of legally and illegally cut 4 million cubic feet of wood to the rest of the country within four months.

The controversial order led to an outcry by NGOs and civil society, and the media has drawn attention to this issue in the past two weeks. “Since the 1990s there has been a ban in the country on transporting timber down country to discourage deforestation, although of course there is an internal demand for wood in Gilgit and Skardu. Now thanks to this last minute order by the PM, they have started doing fresh cutting of trees. We have made videos of them cutting our forests in Diamer just last week and are going to release them to the TV stations,” explains KM Qureishi.

He claims that since the order was passed on March 15th 2013, around 1000 to 1500 trees are being cut each day. The forests in Diamer are owned by the local communities, but are regulated under the Forest Regulations of 1970 and managed by the Gilgit-Balistan Forest Department. “My heart is really broken to see all the carnage taking place in Diamer. The youth of Diamer are taking footage of the cutting with their cameras and sending it to me. In some villages like Thak Juti, the villagers are stopping them. You see they rely on non-timber forest products (Chilgohzas (pine nuts), wild fruits and vegetables) for their income so these forests are valuable to them but where there is no unity in the communities they are being exploited”. By “they” KM Qureishi is referring to the powerful and well-connected timber mafia that is behind Raja Pervez’s last minute order. The timber mafia sells the wood in cities like Islamabad and Lahore for Rs 3,500 per cubic feet (for high quality Deodar), while Rs 25 per cubic feet (for Deodar) is all that the local people will earn from selling their trees.

Some GB forest officials claim that the timber that had piled up over the years along the Karakoram Highway was starting to decay after being exposed to the sun and rain so this order is welcomed. But the IG Forests, Syed Mahmood Nasir, is himself upset with the implications of this order. Recently, he has been trying to implement the ‘Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation’ or REDD mechanism in Pakistan, which is a good initiative under the global climate change agenda to decrease deforestation and enhance carbon stocks in existing forests. In his view, Pakistan can save and manage its forests by adopting REDD, which provides a mechanism to calculate the carbon stock that can be sold in the market or traded against funds for projects related to forests. Now with this rampant cutting of forests going on, he says he is “helpless” because the order is not under the purview of the federal Ministry of Climate Change.

More-cut-trees_290
More-cut-trees_290
The civil society of Islamabad has gotten together with the youth of Chilas, and yesterday NGOs like the Bioresource Research Centre (Pakistan) and the Dr Akhter Hameed Khan Resource Center issued a resolution on the PM’s order, which incidentally was pushed by the Gilgit Baltistan Council (the forests are now under provincial control, but in the case of GB they come under the affairs of the GB Council, whose chairman is the Prime Minister). According to the resolution, “This issue is brought into light in view of the dwindling situation of forests in GB where since 1992 the forest area has been reduced to half and deforestation is going on unabated. The heavy deforestation in the catchment area of the Indus is not only threatening the biggest reservoirs of Tarbela but is also jeopardising mega projects like Bhasha Dam and the Dasu Hydel Project. It appears that for the short-term personal interests of a few powerful people we are sacrificing the future of a nation. Pakistan being an agriculture country heavily relies on the sustained supply of fresh water from the upper reaches of the Indus Basin. The current decision of the GB Council tolls the death bell for our agriculture and energy sectors.”

We just don’t seem to learn from all the disasters that have hit us in the north in recent years – the massive flooding of 2010 (made worse by deforestation) and the earthquake of 2005, which caused massive land-sliding in deforested areas. The 1992 ban on green felling was in fact, imposed by the federal cabinet after severe floods hit the region. In 2008 the Ministry of Kashmir Affairs and Gilgit-Baltistan submitted a summary to the federal cabinet requesting the relaxation of the ban on illegally cut timber after the imposition of fines. Permission was granted from February 2008 till September 2008 and the cabinet decided to confiscate the left over timber if not transported by that date. In August 2012 the GB Council was informed that 4.014 million cubic feet of timber was still left. The Ministry of Climate Change insisted that the remaining timber must be confiscated as per the cabinet decision but instead of doing that the GB Council, with the Prime Minister’s order, has allowed the extraction of this timber.

Islamabad’s civil society plans to start a campaign and is hoping the interim Prime Minister of Pakistan “may take a note of the aggravating situation of forests in Gilgit-Baltistan and issue a directive for the withdrawal of Gilgit-Baltistan Council letter No. C-6(1)/2011 GBC dated 15 March 2013 for immediate stoppage of fresh timber harvesting”. They would also like the Prime Minister “to order strict compliance of the decision of the federal cabinet which required the confiscation of illegal timber to discourage deforestation in Gilgit-Baltistan”.

In KM Qureishi’s view, “even the Supreme Court can take suo moto notice of the situation and stop the cutting of fresh trees. We want an assurance that in the next twenty years no more trees will be cut. There are still many forests left and if we take action now they can be saved. But with the cutting going on at this rate, these forest will soon disappear”. He has high hopes in the Diamer Youth Forum and other youth organisations of the area, which have now decided to block the Karakoram Highway in order to protest against the rampant deforestation by the timber mafia. “The timber mafia is just making a fool out of the local people and the youth realise that and they have taken the protection of their forests into their own hands”.


Rina-80x80
Rina-80x80
The writer is an award-winning environmental journalist based in Islamabad, who also covers climate change and health issues. She can be reached at rinasaeed@gmail.com


The views expressed by this blogger and in the following reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.


The writer is an award-winning environmental journalist based in Islamabad, who also covers climate change and health issues.



She can be reached at rinasaeed@gmail.com


The views expressed by this blogger and in the following reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.

More From This Author

Crawl to the crab

The best kinds of solutions are simply natural: an aquaculture intervention in the Indus Delta improves fisherfolk.

Wild baggage

The export and import of wildlife has taken on a life of its own

‘A $15 billion industry’

Hammad Naqi Khan, the new director general of the World Wide Fund for Nature–Pakistan talks to Rina Saeed Khan about

Comments (26) Closed




MS Abdul Rahman
Apr 16, 2013 12:34pm
Just goes to say the lack of interest in this subject, nobody has said anything. If the forests are being cut with such ferocity, something should be done to plant new trees at the same time. Batrasi forest near Mansehra used to be a very thick one with all kinds of wildlife found there, including monkeys, but now practically there is no forest left with a few tree here and there dotting the mountainsides. So the timber mafia is active from Abbottabad to all the northern areas , but seems like nobody is bothered about it or people prefer to keep quiet fearing for their lives. It really law of the jungle in a jungle of trees. May Allah guide us !!
ibnarastoo
Apr 16, 2013 12:53pm
The timber "mafia" is foreign backed , just like some terrorist groups. You have to not only protect the forests of the North West you have to extend that climate to the rest of the country.
Silajit
Apr 16, 2013 01:15pm
You're joking, right?
pakistani
Apr 16, 2013 02:23pm
Salute for writer for highlighting such important issue. While my recent visit to Mahandri, KPK, i felt so sad when i visited in 2010 and before that in 1997 when situation was even better then 2010, just three years back those mountain places which were covered with trees are just now empty with no trees left other then few here and there, and big wooden logs were lying along the road side. It's not only timber mafia but the demand in their own villages and cities for which they are cutting the trees. I request new PM if he cares for Pakistan to null and void such order or take Supreme court should intervene to stop our precious wood and trees for future generation. When do we learn from our mistakes. If we disturb the balance of nature then Nature will not forgive us in way of earthquakes and floods and land slide.. May G-d protect Pakistan from such ruthless timber mafias.
Khan
Apr 16, 2013 02:36pm
Since the arrival of afghan refugees our forest suffer immense destruction
Khalil
Apr 16, 2013 05:04pm
Dear Rina, You are doing great work by bringing this issue to the worlds attention. This carnage cannot go on as it will have a devastating effect on the local area and the environemnt in general.The deforestation will inevitably bring floods and moodslides during monsoons then severe droughts in the summer. Culprits like the former PM and other officials should be tried in courts for this reckless act. Please try to raise this issue in the court before its too late and set up some kind of a campaign to save the lovely valleys. Khalil (UK)
Amjad Wyne
Apr 16, 2013 05:17pm
It is not lack of interest - it is helplessness- total surrender. Pakistan's prime minister "Raja sahib" approved huge contracts to the timber mafia just before leaving the office (it was reported by the Dawn). The point being - what can a country do when its custodian is the biggest thief.
Naveen Kumar
Apr 16, 2013 05:17pm
Pakistan is in need of a Chipko Movement.
Waqas
Apr 16, 2013 05:22pm
Why bring Allah into everything?
BRR
Apr 16, 2013 06:32pm
So what is new - some people will sell their mother for money, and trees are just a casulty due to man's greed. The people who are most affected long term themselves actively often engage in deforestation in their villages. Man is worse than animals - he burns his own village for profit.
Khan of Kalabagh
Apr 16, 2013 06:45pm
for heaven sake, please stop involving 'foreign invovlement' mantra... oneday i can forsee a protest in one of the city of Pakistan, blaming foreign involvement in the poor standard of cooking or irregular shape of CHAPPAATI, huh, foriegn hand.
Keti Zilgish
Apr 16, 2013 07:00pm
Since 1970 the timber mafia has disguised itself as the PPP.
fkhan
Apr 16, 2013 07:50pm
Vote for PTI. there is awareness on every issue. In sha Allah we will get back the lush green forests if we stop being selfish and vote wisely.
Bakhtawer BIlal
Apr 17, 2013 12:21am
It is not only a loss of view, it is a loss in terms of environmental changes for now and for the generations to come.
babar
Apr 17, 2013 01:52am
Forest Department has generally failed to protect and manage natural forests throughout the Pakistan. They have resources and lot of manpower but timber mafia seems more powerful -- why not , they are backed by the political, civil administration and the Forest Department itself. Unfortunately forestry is very low in the national agenda.
Mubeen
Apr 17, 2013 05:32am
MAH, Abu Dhabi
Apr 17, 2013 06:48am
What people can get away here with ... The ex-PM issued such an obviously questionable order and yet it was not even mentioned in his election papers scrutiny. But I think who is most at fault are the local communities who themselves do not think of their forests.
naeem
Apr 17, 2013 08:37am
We need to move towards renewable tress forestation like in Australia. Under this management style the native tress will be protected and better yielding hardwood trees will be grown alongside, The whole issue needs better management.
Kesar
Apr 17, 2013 09:25am
Trees are the most wonderful creation of nature. Destroy it at your peril!
Hassan
Apr 17, 2013 09:30am
For the last decade, people are asking to declare Northern areas as National Forest but it falls on deaf ears. Local people do not care for themselves. "God help those who help themselves". Technically, why PM, CM, MNAs, MPAs, governor and presidents care... they have all their assets abroad, their families are mostly abroad for shopping, education, vacation, etc. So why they will care for Pakistan. This is beauty of Pakistan.....
Hassan
Apr 17, 2013 09:32am
yes. sarcasm... what a sense of humor
Rajiv
Apr 17, 2013 09:39am
You are right... This made a lot of difference in India... I visit MP in india last month and i am so glad to see those forests there..
Hasan Zaman
Apr 17, 2013 04:53pm
Ali Hassan
Apr 17, 2013 05:34pm
How can a tree which grows in hundred of years in northern areas of pakistan can come back in five years :)
Aslam
Apr 17, 2013 11:16pm
The timber that is already cut is not wasted by rotting. It provides essential nutrients to the soil that helps future forests be more healthy. It is a natural fertilizer and without human intervention that is how nature works.
Zeeshan Shamsi
Apr 18, 2013 05:00am
Planting new forest should be the strategy, ten saplings for each tree cut.